SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Judicial Analysis Court Copy Headnote Facts Arguments Court observation
Listen Audio Icon Pause Audio Icon
judgment-img

1997 Supreme(Raj) 1210

RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT AT JAIPUR BENCH
Anshuman Singh, J.
Rinesh Gupta - Appellant
Versus
State of Rajasthan and Ors. - Respondent
S.B.C.W.P. Nos. 5787/97, 5877/96.
Decided On : 27-06-1997

The Jaipur Development Authority has no power to allow conversion of residential colony into a commercial colony under Section 73-B of the Urban Improvement Trust Act, 1959 after coming into force of JDA Act, 1982.

Headnote:

URBAN DEVELOPMENT - Jaipur Development Authority Act, 1982 - Section 17(1) and (5) - Urban Improvement Trust Act, 1959 - Section 73-B - Whether the Jaipur Development Authority has got power to allow conversion of residential colony into a commercial colony under Section 73-B of the Urban Improvement Trust Act, 1959 after coming into force of JDA Act, 1982? - Held, no.

Fact of the Case:

Petitioner, a practicing Advocate of the Rajasthan High Court, approached the Court through this writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, in the nature of public interest litigation, inter-alia with the prayer to direct the State Government and its functionaries including the Jaipur Development Authority. Rajasthan Housing Board and Municipal Corporation to take strict and firm action thereby stopping, closing/removing, the commercial establishments and commercial centres viz;. fast food centres, hotels, hospitals, marriage lawn/homes, restaurants, small scale industries which are actively going on in the residential areas, inasmuch as, they are being run illegally and without seeking proper permission under the Urban Improvement (Change of use, of residential land or premises for commercial purpose) Rules, 1974.

Finding of the Court:

The Court held that the Jaipur Development Authority has no power to allow conversion of residential colony into a commercial colony under Section 73-B of the Urban Improvement Trust Act, 1959 after coming into force of JDA Act, 1982. The Court further held that the permission granted by the JDA for change of user from residential colonies to commercial colonies by invoking power under Section 73-B of the Urban Improvement' Trust Act. 1959 is illegal and without Jurisdiction and the use of such establishment is liable to be closed and the user is liable to face consequences as provided under the Act of 1982.

Issues: Whether the Jaipur Development Authority has got power to allow conversion of residential colony into a commercial colony under Section 73-B of the Urban Improvement Trust Act, 1959 after coming into force of JDA Act, 1982?

Ratio Decidendi: The Court held that the Jaipur Development Authority has no power to allow conversion of residential colony into a commercial colony under Section 73-B of the Urban Improvement Trust Act, 1959 after coming into force of JDA Act, 1982. The Court further held that the permission granted by the JDA for change of user from residential colonies to commercial colonies by invoking power under Section 73-B of the Urban Improvement' Trust Act. 1959 is illegal and without Jurisdiction and the use of such establishment is liable to be closed and the user is liable to face consequences as provided under the Act of 1982.

Final Decision: The Court allowed the writ petition and directed the Jaipur Development Authority to stop the user of the commercial establishments forthwith which are essentially residential houses but the commercial activities are going on contrary to the provisions of Section, 17(5) of the Act 1982.

JUDGMENT

1. - The petitioner-Rinesh Gupta who is a practicing Advocate of the Rajasthan High Court has approached this Court through this writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, in the nature of public interest litigation, inter-alia with the prayer to direct the State Government and its functionaries including the Jaipur Development Authority. Rajasthan Housing Board and Municipal Corporation to take strict and firm action thereby stopping, closing/removing, the commercial establishments and commercial centres viz;. fast food centres, hotels, hospitals, marriage lawn/homes, restaurants, small scale industries which are actively going on in the residential areas, inasmuch as, they are being run illegally and without seeking proper permission under the Urban Improvement (Change of use, of residential land or premises for commercial purpose) Rules, 1974. (hereinafter referred to as the `Rules, 1974'); to direct the Secretary PHED and Rajasthan State Electricity Board not to give water and electricity connections in the existing commercial establishments in the residential areas; to direct the Finance Secretary that he should direct the Commercial Taxes Department to get the survey conducted by the independent authority or a team of higher officers in the matter of tax evasion; to direct the Home Secretary and the Excise Commissioner to take proper and firm action under the Excise Act and Rules against persons who are running wine shops/beer bars in the residential areas; to direct the secretary Medical and Health Department to initiate action against the runners of hospitals, nursing homes etc. which are being run in the residential areas without proper sanction and to close the same.

2. The writ petition was filed on 27.11.96 and it came to be listed before this Court for admission for the first time,on 29.11.96 and this Court issued show cause notices to the 'respondents. Notices of stay application were also issued end by an interim older the respondents were restrained from granting permission to any person or group of persons for changing use of residential purpose to that of commercial purpose till the disposal of the writ petition. The notices have ;been served and the replies have been filed on behalf of the respondents.

3. On 7.5.97, it was brought to the notice of the Court that most of the localities of Jaipur City which were allotted for residential purpose have been converted into commercial purpose in the form of shops, hotels,etc. which is causing much hardships and inconvenience to the residents of the localities and that the Rajasthan Housing Board and Jaipur Development Authority have failed in performing their statutory duties in preventing the conversion oP residential building into commercial buildings, in these circumstances, it was considered proper that a public notice be issued to the general public intimating them about the hearing of the case in order to void multiplicity of litigation. The Court directed the JDA to get a public notice published to this effect in daily newspapers; Rajasthan Patrika, Danik Navoyoti, Danik Bhaskar, Statesmen, Rashtradoot, Indian Express and Hindustan Times within three days. It was also ordered that the persons interested may file objections before this Court by 16.5.97 and the case was ordered to be listed for final disposal on 21.5.97. Since-the notice could not be published in English newspapers therefore, on the request of Mr.A.K. Gupta appearing on behalf of the petitioner, the Jaipur Development Authority was further directed to get the notice published in some English newspaper which is circulated in Rajasthan stating therein that any person interested may appeal before the Court and present their presences by 27.5.97. On 28.5.97 arguments were heard at length but could not be concluded. Meanwhile, Mr. Jagdeep Dhankad. Sr. Counsel filed an undertaking on behalf of the applicant Udaikant Mishra, Director Abhishek Estate Pvt. Ltd., Jaipur to the




















































































































Click Here to Read the rest of this document
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
logo-black

An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers

Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance

qr

Scan Me!

India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!

For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :

whatsapp-icon Back to top