RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT
Staya Prakash Pathak, J.
Jarnail Singh and Anr. - Appellant
Versus
State of Rajasthan - Respondent
S.B. Criminal Appeal No. 317 of 2002.
Decided On : 3-08-2005
Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 – S. 8/18, 55 and 57 – Appeal against conviction of the accused for the offence under – S. 8/18, 55 and 57 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act – opium recovered – during investigation, the samples were taken out and kept back in the Malkhana – the entries in the Malkhana register show that the sealed Art. were taken out on 27th and 28th April, 2000 but PW – 5 stated that he took the Art. on 28th April, 2000 – the prosecution version was also not supported by two independent witnesses (PW – 1 and PW – 2) and it is only based on the statements of the raiding party – weight of the contraband when weighed in FSL was found to be 89.93. g and the samples taken were 50 g each – S. 55 and 57 were not fulfilled and the testimony of the police witnesses also lacked any independent corroboration – prosecution case is weak and no reliable evidence was produced to prove that the recovered samples were kept intact, sealed and were not meddled with – allowing the appeal, the court acquitted the accused.
1. On 1.4.2000, at about 9 AM, PW13 Kailash Chandra, SHO, Police Station, Chhoti Sadri, the Investigating Officer of the case, received a secret information Ex.P/33A to the effect that from a red coloured Maruti Car, coming from Pratapgarh and approaching towards Chittorgarh, opium could be recovered.
2. PW 13 Kailash Chandra after recording the information, sent it for compliance under Section 42 of the Act . to the S.R Chittor and Additional S.R Pratapgarh. This was taken by Constable PW 9 Narsingh on 1.4.2000.
3. The raiding party consisting of PW 13 Kailash Chandra, ASI Baktharam, PW 6 ASI Gopal Das and PW 3 Bharat Singh, PW 14 Head Constable Sikandar Khan and Constable Shivram and other witnesses made Nakabandi near Pratap Nagar Police Station at about 9.30 AM.
4. As per the secret information Ex.P/33A, a red Maruti car was seen coming, which was stopped by PW 13 Kailash Chandra. In the car, two persons namely Jarnail Singh and one Suresh were found. Accused Jarnail Singh was driving the car whereas accused Suresh was sitting on the back seat of the car.
5. On inquiry being made from accused Jarnail Singh in relation to a brief case, which was lying by his side, it was stated by accused Jarnail Singh that the brief case contained his clothings.
6. The accused were given notice for their personal search and the search of the vehicle, who gave consent for the search and the search was conducted.
7. In the meantime, the Motbirs PW 1 Yudhishtra and PW 2 Ranglal were arranged.
8. On opening the brief case, it was found that there was a double polythene bag beneath the clothes. When it was opened then a black liquid material was found therein, which gave smell of opium and on testing it was found that the same was opium. The polythene bag recovered was weighed. It was of two kgs. Two samples of 50 grams each were taken and two more samples as control samples were also taken.
9. Another accused, who was sitting at the back seat of Maruti, was also searched. Near to him, a brown bag was found. On making inquiry as to what was in the bag, accused Suresh replied that it contained his clothings. On opening the bag, there also a double polythene bag was found and on opening the same it was found to contain black liquid material, which also gave smell of opium and after testing it was found to be opium. The weight of this bag was also two kgs. Two samples of 50 grams each were taken from this material also and necessary marking was done.
10. On further inquiry made form the driver of the car, the driver Jarnail Singh told that still there was contraband material below the mudguard of the car and when mudguard was seen, (t was found that below that there were two polythene bags. The same were opened and were found to contain opium. On weighing, each bag was found of one kilogram. Two samples of 50 grams each were taken from each of the bags and they were marked.
11. On inquiry from accused Suresh Kumar, he also informed that at the backside of the car near the back - light of car there was opium. The back - light was got opened and two polythene bags were recovered from there. After weighing the same, those bags were found to be of one kilogram each. Two samples of 50 grams each were taken from those bags and the recovered material and the samples were seized and sealed then and there. The car was also
SupremeToday
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.