2013 Supreme(Raj) 151
RAJASTHAN HIGH COURT
Jaipur Bench
New India Assurance Co. Ltd. Vs. Panchu & Ors. (Sharma, J.)
HON'BLE ALOK SHARMA, J.
New India Assurance Co. Ltd. (The)
Versus
Panchu & Ors.
S.B. Civil Misc. Appeal No. 831 of 2008, decided on 05.04.2013
Subject
Motor Accident Claim - Compensation for Loss of Dependency
Act Referred
HINDU SUCCESSION ACT : S.8
MOTOR VEHICLES ACT : S.166
Headnote
Appeal allowed.
eksVj ;ku vf/kfu;e] 1988] /kkjk 166 lifBr fgUnw mRrjkf/kdkj vf/kfu;e] 1956] /kkjk 8 & nkok ;kfpdk nk;j djuk & l{ke O;fDr & fgUnw mRrjkf/kdkj vf/kfu;e ds rgr e`rd ds dksbZ Js.kh 1 okfjl ugha Fks & ^^fof/kd izfrfuf/k** dh O;kfIr & nkokdrkZ HkkbZ dh mez 35 o"kZ tks izfrfnu 100@- #- dekrk gS & vfHkfu/kkZfjr & e`rd ds fof/kd izfrfuf/k ds :i esa nkok ;kfpdk is'k djus gsrq nkokdrkZ gdnkj ugha Fkk D;ksafd og dsoy ,d f}rh; Js.kh dk okfjl Fkk rFkk og ;g LFkkfir djus esa foQy jgk fd e`rd ds dksbZ izFke Js.kh dk okfjl ugha Fkk & nkokdrkZ tks izfrfnu 100@- #- dekrk gS mls vkfJrrk dh gkfu gsrq izfrdkfjr fd;s tkus ds fy, ,d vkfJr gdnkj gksus gsrq fopkj ugha fd;k tk ldrk & nkokdrkZ dk e`rd dk fof/kd izfrfuf/k gksus dk rkRif;Zr iks"k.kh; ughaA ¼in la[;k 12 o 13½
vihy Lohdkj dhA
S.R. Joshi with Ganesh Joshi, for Appellant-Insurance Company;
Anoop Dhand, for Claimant-Respondent No.1
2. A claim petition under Section 166 of the Act of 1988 was filed stating that on 06.01.2006, the claimant's brother Chhotu, since deceased, was riding his bicycle from Madanganj, Kishangarh back to his village after selling milk. A truck bearing registration No.RJ.19-G-6527 being driven rashly and negligently by the non-claimant, Sawai Ram (respondent No.2 before this Court), hit the bicycle of Chhotu from behind and crushed him under the wheels of the truck. Chhotu died on the spot due to the injuries sustained. It was further stated that the offending vehicle No.RJ.19-G-6527 was in the ownership of one Anada Ram (respondent No.3 before this Court) and was insured with the appellant – New India Assurance Co. Ltd, Branch Jodhpur also arrayed as a party in the claim petition.
3. On notice being served of the claim petition, the Insurance Company in its written statement submitted that the claim petition itself was not maintainable inter alia on the ground that the claimant was not entitled to file the same under the provisions of Section 166(1)(c) of the Act of 1988 in view of the fact that he was not the legal representative of the deceased Chhotu and was merely the brother of the deceased. It was submitted that until a succession certificate was filed by the claimant or it otherwise established that the deceased Chhotu had no class I heir under the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 (hereinafter 'the Act of 1956'), the claim petition at his instance was not maintainable. It was further submitted that even otherwise the claimant at the time of laying the claim petition was 35 years of age working man and therefore he could not conceivably be taken to be a dependant on the deceased Chhotu. Other grounds also taken in defence by the Insurance Company but negatived by the Tribunal are not being pressed in this appeal.
4. On the basis of the pleadings of the parties before it, the learned Tribunal framed five issues. Issue No.1 related to the factum of incident; issue No.2 was on the question as to whether the driver of the offending vehicle was an employee of the owner of the offending vehicle in issue; issue No.3 related to the quantum of compensation, if any payable; and issue No.4 pertained to the effect of the objections taken by the Insurance Company to the very maintainability of the claim petition and also to the entitlement of the claimant as 35 years old brother of the deceased Chhotu to be granted compensation under Section 166 of the Act of 1988. Issue No.5 pertained to the relief the claimant would finally be entitled to.
5. On the basis of the evidence before it, the learned Tribunal decided issue Nos.1 & 2 jointly in favour of the claimant and against the Insurance Company. In respect of issue No.3 as framed, the learned Tribunal was of the view that even though there was no proof of the income of the deceased Chhotu, it be taken at the minimum of Rs.3,000/- per month and after deduction of 1/3 of the assumed income towards the personal expenses of the deceased Chhotu, the dependency of the claimant be taken to be at Rs.2,000/- per month, which entailed an annual dependency of Rs.24,000/-. Applying to the multiplicand so arrived the multiplier of 13 in view of the deceased being 50 years of a