SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2014 Supreme(Raj) 224

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN BENCH AT JAIPUR
Mohammad Rafiq, J.
Chandra Pal Gupta
Vs.
The State of Rajasthan and Others
Civil Writ Petition No. 4495/1998 With Stay Application No. 3701/1998
Decided on: 04.04.2014

Act Referred

CONSTITUTION OF INDIA : Art.309
RAJASTHAN EDUCATIONAL SUB-ORDINATE SERVICES RULES : .

Headnote

Service Matters - Withdrawing the benefits of selection scale on foregoing promotions - Granted benefits of 2nd and 3rd selection grades in 1990 and 1994 - Granted promotion vide order dated 7.8.90, 23.11.92, 7.8.93 and 15.12.94 which were foregone - After issuance of circular dated 4.12.96, he was again offered promotion vide order dated 27.2.97 which was declined to accept - Held - Such refusal taken place prior to issuance of last circular dated 31.12.2009, therefore, his case would be governed by circular dated 4.12.96 and respondents were right in withdrawing the third selection grade w.e.f. 27.2.97, the date when the petitioner was offered fifth time promotion. (Paras 21 to 23)

       Writ petition partly allowed.

        lsok ekeys & inksUufr R;kxus ij p;fur osru eku dk izR;kâr djuk & o"kZ 1990 o 1994 esa Øe'k% f}rh; o r`rh; p;fur osrueku dk ifjykHk fn;k x;k & vkns'k fnukad 7-8-90] 23-11-92] 7-8-93 ,oa 15-12-94 ds }kjk inksUufr iznku dh ftudk R;kx fd;k & ifji= fnukad 4-12-96 tkjh gksus ds ckn mls iqu% vkns'k fnukad 27-2-97 ds tfj;s inksUufr dk izLrko fn;k x;k ftls Lohdkj djus ls badkj fd;k & vfHkfu/kkZfjr & ,slh eukgh vfUre ifji= fnukad 31-12-2009 ds tkjh gksus ls iwoZ ?kfVr gqbZ vr% mldk ekeyk ifji= fnukad 4-12-96 ls fofu;fer gksxk vr% izR;FkhZx.k }kjk 27-2-97 ls r`rh; osrueku izR;kâr djus dh dk;Zokgh lgh Fkh] tc izkFkhZ dks ikapoh ckj inksUufr dk izLrko fn;k x;k FkkA ¼in la[;k 21 ls 23½

       ;kfpdk va'kr% Lohdkj dhA

Advocates Appeared:
Shri Sachin Mehta, counsel for petitioner Shri Sanjay Kumar Sharma, Government Counsel, for respondents

JUDGMENT : -

This writ petition has been filed by Chandra Pal Gupta, who is since dead and is represented by his son Kavindra Gupta. Petitioner has assailed the orders dated 04.12.1996, 19.06.1998 and 24.07.1998 and has prayed that they may be declared illegal, arbitrary and irrational and unconstitutional. He has further prayed that if any order prejudicial to the interest of the petitioner is passed during pendency of the writ petition, the same may also be quashed and set aside.

Facts of the case are that petitioner was appointed as Assistant Teacher vide order dated 12.12.1963. He joined as such on 24.12.1963. According to the petitioner, his appointment was made against permanent and clear vacancy on recommendation of the selection committee in regular pay scale of Rs.75-160. Petitioner was later on confirmed on the said post as Assistant Teacher vide order dated 31.01.1969 with effect from 01.04.1968. Petitioner was provided benefit of opening/acquiring efficiency bar in the pay scale as well as benefit of revised pay scale as and when revision of pay scales took place. He was provided benefit of selection grade on completion of 15 years of services and was also provided benefit of selection grade in lieu of promotion pursuant to the government circular dated 25.01.1992, which provides for grant of selection grades in lieu of promotions to those employees, who could not get promotion after putting in number of years of service, in that first, second and third selection grades are provided in lieu of first, second and third promotion on completion of 9, 18 and 27 years of service.

Petitioner completed his 27 years of service in the year 1990. Since petitioner was not granted any promotion upto mid of 1990, he was provided benefit of first, second and third selection grades From the date of initial appointment, the petitioner completed 9 years of service in the year 1972, 18 years of service in the year 1981 and 27 years of service in the year 1990. As per the circular dated 25.01.1992, petitioner was allowed the benefit of first selection grade in the pay scale of 1400-2600, second selection grade in the pay scale of 2000-32000 and third selection grade in the pay scale of 2000-3500, vide order dated 14/15.01.1994.

It is contended that the petitioner was provided first promotion of his career vide order dated 07.08.1990 as Teacher Gr.II in the pay scale of 14002600 and posted at Government Secondary School, Veer, vide order dated 26.09.1990. Petitioner submitted representation on 11.10.1990 stating therein his inability to materialize the promotion accorded to him on the ground that his wife is suffering from mental disorder for a long time and she is under regular treatment at Jawahar Lal Nehru Hospital, Ajmer and that there is no one to look after her and to take her to the doctor for advice, prescription and precaution to be taken for treatment. The Head Master of the Government Secondary School, Gulab Badi, forwarded his representation to the Joint Director, Education (Boys), Ajmer Circle, Jaipur. Thereafter vide order dated 23.11.1992 the petitioner was again promoted on the post of Teacher Gr.II and posted at Government Secondary School, Nalu (Kishangarh). Petitioner then submitted representation on 05.12.1992 requesting his posting in Ajmer city on the aforesaid grounds. However, the department did not press the petitioner to materialize his promotion. Thereafter petitioner was promoted vide order dated 07.08.1993 and posted at Government Secondary School, Khajpura, Kishangarh. He submitted representation dated 13.08.1993 pointing out his aforesaid grievance, which was forwarded to the higher authorities recommending that looking to the mental ailment of the wife of the petitioner, he may be posted in Ajmer city on promotion. The recommendation were sent vide letter dated 17.08.1993. Petitioner again provided promotion vide order dated 15.12.1994 and posted at Government Secondary School, Karkedi. Petitioner yet aga






























1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top