SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2014 Supreme(Raj) 423

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN AT JODHPUR
SANDEEP MEHTA, J.
Nemichand – Appellant
Vs.
State of Rajasthan – Respondent
CRIMINAL MISC. II BAIL APPLICATION NO.8109/2014
Decided On : 11.11.2014

Act Referred

CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE : S.438, S.3(19)
EXCISE ACT : S.49, S.47
RAJASTHAN EXCISE ACT : S.19, S.54, S.44, S.47, S.67(1)(a)
Judgement Key Points

Key Points: - The second anticipatory bail application is considered in connection with F.I.R. No.91/2014 for offences under Sections 19/54 of the Rajasthan Excise Act. (!) - The search and seizure in this case was conducted by a Head Constable on a scooter at a public place, with seizure of liquor from the scooty. (!) - The petitioner’s first anticipatory bail application was dismissed by this Court by order dated 22.7.2014, noting the bar contained in Section 49 of the Excise Act. (!) - Section 3(19) defines "Place" to include vehicle among other things. (!) - Section 47 permits entry and search of a place by an officer of a specified rank without a warrant, but limits to entry and search from inside a place. (!) (!) - The 1961 notification authorizes police and revenue officers to exercise search and seizure powers under Section 45, including constables, broadening who can perform searches. (!) - The argument that search on a vehicle (public road) falls under Section 47 (entry into a place) is rejected; Section 45 applies to public-place seizures, making the Head Constable’s actions valid under the notification. (!) (!) - The Court ultimately holds the bail application to be without merit and rejects it. (!)

How to determine the validity of search and seizure under Section 47 of the Rajasthan Excise Act where a vehicle is involved?

What is the scope of "place" under Section 3(19) of the Rajasthan Excise Act and whether vehicles fall within it after amendment?

What are the circumstances under which anticipatory bail under Section 438 Cr.P.C. can be granted or denied in Excise Act cases?


Advocates:
Advocate Appeared:
Mr. N.K.Bohra, for the petitioner. Mr. V.S.Rajpurohit, Public Prosecutor.

JUDGMENT:

The instant second application for anticipatory bail under Section 438 Cr.P.C. has been preferred on behalf of the petitioner in connection with F.I.R. No.91/2014 registered at Police Station Nagori Gate, District Jodhpur for the offences under Sections 19/54 of the Rajasthan Excise Act.

Phusa Ram, Head Constable posted at Police Station Nagori Gate, Jodhpur received an information through his informer on 6.7.2014 at 5.30 AM that the petitioner would be carrying illicit liquour on his white coloured scooty and would be going towards his house. If a trap is laid, the accused could be apprehended with heavy quantity of illicit liquour. The Constable took the information down in writing and thereafter proceeded to lay a cordon at the Hanuman Chowk for trapping the accused. At about 6.10 AM in consonance with information received by the Constable, the accused was seen coming from Bheel Basti towards Hanuman Chowk on his white coloured scooty. Seeing the Police cordon, the accused left his scooty bearing registration No.RJ19.MS.9365 on which some stuff was loaded and started running towards the lane No.7 of Kalal Colony. He was pursued but managed to escape from between the houses. The scooty left by the accused at the road was inspected. It was seen that a gunny bag was tied on the pillion seat of the scooter and some cartons were lying at its footrest. Witnesses from the nearby locality were requested to participate in the seizure proceedings but as the accused is a known liquour smuggler and is an influential man, nobody from the locality agreed to participate in the seizure proceedings. Accordingly, two Constables from the Police party were appointed as Panch witnesses and search was initiated. From inside the bag tied on the seat of the scooty, two cartons of Royal Stag liquour having 12 bottles each meant for sale in Haryana and one carton containing 28 quarters of Moonwalk Premium Dry Gin were found. The three cartons lying on the footrest of the scooty were of Officers Choice Superior Whisky containing 48 quarters of liquour each. The illicit liquour was seized. The Constable prepared the search and seizure memo and thereafter, proceeded to the Police Station Nagori Gate and lodged an FIR No.91/2014 against the petitioner accused for the offence under Section 19/54 of the Rajasthan Excise Act. The accused earlier approached this Court by way of an anticipatory bail application No.6608/2014. This Court dismissed the bail application by order dated 22.7.2014 observing that the same was not maintainable in view of the bar contained in Section 49 of the Excise Act. Now, he has preferred the second prearrest bail application.

Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the first anticipatory bail application preferred on behalf of the petitioner was dismissed in absence of the petitioner and his counsel and thus, the instant second bail application has been preferred under changed circumstances. Learned counsel submits that the validity of the search and seizure proceedings undertaken in this case are hit by a statutory bar as Police Constable, who conducted search and seizure was incompetent to perform such functions. Thus, he urged that the petitioner deserves to be granted anticipatory bail. He contends that the search and seizure in this case was undertaken by a Police Head Constable from a scooter, which is covered in the definition of a place within the meaning of Sections 3(19), and 47 of the Act. As per Section 47 of the Excise Act, search and seizure proceedings from inside a place can only be undertaken by an officer not below the rank of an Excise Officer, SHO or Sub Inspector of the Police Station. He urged that since the search and seizure proceedings of this case were conducted by the Head Constable, who is not empowered to do so, such proceedings are wholly illegal and vitiated. He thus prayed that





















1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top