IN THE HIGH COURT OF RAJASTHAN
Gopal Krishan Vyas, Manoj Kumar Garg, JJ.
Subhash Chandra Kandara – Petitioner
Versus
State of Rajasthan & Ors. – Respondents
D.B. Habeas Corpus No. 59 of 2017
Decided On : 14-07-2017
Prevention of corruption act 2006 - Section 3 – Criminal Procedure Code, 1973 - Section 110, 107, 12 - Constitution of India, 1950- Article 22(5) - Arms Act, 1959 – Indian Penal Code, 1860 - Section 143, 323, 308 and 341, 395 - Wild Life (Protection) Act, 1972 Sub-section (1), Sub-sec. (1-A) of Section 51- Information Technology Act, 2000 Section- 67 - Order of detention – Challenged - Dangerous person – Consideration of amount – Habitual offender – Punishment – Voluntarily causing hurt - As per facts of the case vide communication a complaint was filed by the respondent no. 4 SHO Police Station Nagori Gate, Jodhpur before the respondent no. 3 Commissioner of Police, Jodhpur proposing the proceedings against the detenue Kishan Kumar @ Montu under Section 3 of the Act of 2006 wherein it has been stated that the detenue Kishan Kumar @ Montu is a dangerous person because several criminal cases registered and pending against him, therefore, to check his criminal activities steps may be taken against him. On the basis of the said communication, the Commissioner of Police, Jodhpur while exercising powers conferred. Held, It is true that mere registration of number of cases cannot be treated a ground to pass an order of detention, it is the duty of the competent authority to assess the criminal activities of the detenue on the basis of the facts stated in the cases registered against him. In the present case, it is obvious that all provisions of Cr. P.C. were taken into consideration to check the criminal activities of the detenue Kishan Kumar @ Montu, but it is very strange that all the efforts failed, therefore, it was felt necessary by the Police Commissioner, Jodhpur to pass an order for detention while exercising powers under Sec. 3 of the Act of 2006. Petition dismissed.
GOPAL KRISHAN VYAS, J.
In this Habeas Corpus writ petition filed by Subhash Chandra Kandara, father of the detenue Kishan Kumar @ Montu, the petitioner has challenged the order of detention dated 2.3.2017 (Annex. 2) passed by the Commissioner of Police, Jodhpur and affirmed by the State Government vide orders dated 8.3.2017 (Annex. 3) and 19.4.2017 (Annex. 4) whereby the detenue Kishan Kumar @ Montu has been detained for one year w.e.f. 2.3.2017 to 1.3.2018.
2. As per facts of the case vide communication dated 2.3.2017 a complaint was filed by the respondent no. 4 SHO Police Station Nagori Gate, Jodhpur before the respondent no. 3 Commissioner of Police, Jodhpur proposing the proceedings against the detenue Kishan Kumar @ Montu under Section 3 of the Act of 2006 wherein it has been stated that the detenue Kishan Kumar @ Montu is a dangerous person because several criminal cases registered and pending against him, therefore, to check his criminal activities steps may be taken against him. On the basis of the said communication, the Commissioner of Police, Jodhpur while exercising powers conferred under Section 3 of the Act of 2006 passed order on 2.3.2017 so as to detain the detenue Kishan Kumar @ Montu and send the matter for approval. The State Government vide order dated 8.3.2017 approved the order passed by the Commissioner of Police, Jodhpur dated 2.3.2017 and placed the case before the advisory board for seeking approval. Ultimately, the State Government passed an order dated 19.4.2017 directing to detain the detenue Kishan Kumar @ Montu for a period of one year.
3. Upon issuing notice to show cause the respondents, a reply has been filed by the respondents in which it is specifically pleaded that due to criminal character and activities of the petitioner's son Kishan Kumar @ Montu a panic the society and there is also law and order situation in the Jodhpur city. It is stated that his criminal activities have been around almost all the area covered by Police Stations Udai Mandir, Mahamandir, Sardarpura, Ratanada, Pratap Nagar, Chopasani Housing Board, Kanda Falsa of Jodhpur metro as well as in the district Jalore. In the reply it is stated that as many as 24 cases under the IPC and under the Arms Act were registered against the detenue Kishan Kumar @ Montu and after investigation challan was filed. It is also stated that in 9 cases, though the detenue Kishan Kumar @ Montu was acquitted but he has been acquitted on the basis of the compromise arrived at between the parties but in remaining 15 cases, the trial is going on before the learned courts. It is submitted that the criminal activities of the detenue Kishan Kumar @ Montu are in continuance and involves attack with deadly weapons, causing injury to the property by subjecting them ablaze, attempt to commit homicidal deaths, committing forgery and fraud and keeping arms and ammunitions. In the reply it was also stated that the detenue Kishan Kumar @ Montu is a history sheeter of Police Station Nagori Gate, Jodhpur and has remained engaged in the criminal activities which have been continuous from the year 2006. Apart from aforesaid from time to time proceedings under Section 110, 1073 and 151 Cr. P.C. were also initiated against him but despite being bound down to maintain good behavior, the detenue Kishan Kumar @ Montu went on to commit the criminal activities causing eminent danger to the public order. Thus, it was submitted that the orders impugned were rightly passed by the respondents.
4. Learned counsel for the petitioner vehemently argued that the order of detention passed by the Police Commissioner, Jodhpur is based upon 24 cases registered against the detenue Kishan Kumar @ Montu out of which in 9 cases, the detenue Kishan Kumar @ Montu has been acquitted and only 4 cases are pending trial before the learned Addl. Sessions Judge and remaining 8 cases are of Magistrate trial and two cases are under investigation. Thus, it is submitted that no case is regis
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.