SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Judicial Analysis Court Copy Headnote Facts Arguments Court observation
Listen Audio Icon Pause Audio Icon
judgment-img

2018 Supreme(Raj) 1078

IN THE HIGH COURT OF RAJASTHAN, JAIPUR BENCH
MOHAMMAD RAFIQ, GOVERDHAN BARDHAR, JJ.
Kamlesh Kumar Meena - Appellant
Vs.
State of Rajasthan, Department of Education, Chief Secretary - Respondent
Special Appeal (Writ) No. 1064 of 2018; Civil Writ Petition No. 4521 of 2018
Decided On : 19-09-2018

Advocates Appeared:
S.N. Kumawat, Adv., N.M. Lodha, Adv., Kunal Jaiman, Adv., Anoop Dhand, Adv.

Headnote:

Indian penal code – 1860 - Section 120B - Entire examination - Leakage paper – Investigation - Appellant in writ petition prayed for issuance of a writ of mandamus to respondents to get leakage question paper of examination investigated by Central Bureau of Investigation or Special Operation Group any other equivalent premier investigating agency with further prayer for direction to respondent Board Secondary Education for Rajasthan Ajmer short respondent-Board not declare result of examination till completion of investigation – Held, Material that has been placed on record by appellant or otherwise collected by police applying test of Wednesbury principle of unreasonableness as also doctrine of proportionality is not so convincing and compelling as to justify such an extreme step – Court thus answer all questions posed above accordingly - In view of aforesaid discussion although court differ with reasons given by Single Judge in dismissing writ petition filed by appellant but agree final conclusion arrived at by him in dismissal of writ petition - Consequently appeal fails and is hereby dismissed - This also disposes of stay application – Appeal dismissed

JUDGMENT

Mohammad Rafiq, J.

This special appeal seeks to challenge the judgment of the learned Single Judge dated 31.07.2018, whereby the writ petition filed by writ-petitioner/appellant Kamlesh Kumar Meena (hereinafter referred to as 'the appellant') has been dismissed.

2. The appellant in the writ petition prayed for issuance of a writ of mandamus to the respondents to get the leakage of question paper of the REET-2017 Level-II examination investigated by the Central Bureau of Investigation or Special Operation Group or any other equivalent premier investigating agency, with the further prayer for a direction to respondent no.3 Board of Secondary Education for Rajasthan, Ajmer, (for short, 'the respondent-Board') not to declare the result of REET-2017 Level-II examination till completion of investigation. Further prayer was made that the said examination be cancelled and the respondent-Board, which was entrusted with the task of conducting REET-2017 Level-II examination-2017, be directed to conduct fresh examination.

3. Mr. S.N. Kumawat, learned counsel for the appellant, has submitted that the appellant received a message on WhatsApp (a messenger app) of his cell-phone number 9785937091 at 09:05 AM on 11.02.2018 while he was proceeding towards his examination center at Shaheed Amit Bhardwaj Senior Secondary School, Manak Chowk, near Badi Chopar, in front of Hawamahal, Jaipur, from a WhatsApp group named 'Namo-Lakhya', containing 37 pages of the question paper of G-Series. He did not pay any heed to the same and proceeded to timely reach the examination center as the candidates were required to reach latest by 09:00 AM. However, when the appellant was served with the question paper of H-Series at 10:00 AM in the examination center, he was shocked to see that several questions therein were from the same paper he received on his WhatsApp. When the appellant made enquiry from other candidates after examination, he learnt that eight more candidates received similar WhatsApp message of G-Series question paper on their cell-phones. Their names with cell-phone number were mentioned by the appellant in the rejoinder to the reply of the respondents filed in the writ petition. This clearly proves that the question papers of the REET examination was leaked and the sanctity of the examination became doubtful. Many undeserving candidates, by virtue of such leakage, were able to steal a march over genuine and deserving candidates.

4. The learned counsel for the appellant argued that the learned Single Judge has erred in law in attaching too much significance to the fact that Yashwant Kumar Saini, in whose name the complaint was made, in his statement before the committee of the respondent-Board, has denied having made such complaint and even disputed his signature on such complaint. The learned Single Judge as also three-member-committee of the respondent Board has read only one part of the statement of Yashwant Kumar Saini and ignored the other part. The earlier part of his statement that has been relied by the learned Single Judge to dismiss the writ petition is that Yashwant Kumar Saini has denied that he made the complaint dated 11.02.2018 to the respondent-Board and that the complaint was not in his handwriting. The complaint did not even contain his signature. His name and cell-phone number have been misused by someone and further that he did not receive any WhatsApp message on his cell-phone number. But in latter part of the statement of the said Yashwant Kumar Saini, he stated that such message was received by his companion Kamlesh Kumar Meena, i.e., the appellant herein, who informed him about the leaked paper, has been completely ignored. The said Yashwant Kumar Saini also stated that after the examination, the appellant came to him and they compared the paper of G-Series received on WhatsApp group with the virtual question paper, which substantially matched and they got its print out and informed the media persons about it.

5. The le



































Click Here to Read the rest of this document

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
logo-black

An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers

Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance

qr

Scan Me!

India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!

For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :

whatsapp-icon Back to top