IN THE HIGH COURT OF RAJASTHAN
Dinesh Mehta, J.
Rehmat Bibi - Appellant
Versus
State Of Rajasthan - Respondent
Civil Writ Petition No. 355 of 2019
Decided on : 06-04-2021
divorcee - Teacher Grade-III Level 2 subject-Urdu - The court affirmed the rejection of the petitioner's candidature as a divorcee due to the absence of a valid decree of divorce at the time of submitting the application form. The court emphasized the importance of a decree of divorce granted by a competent court and rejected the petitioner's claim based on certificates and pension status.
Fact of the Case:
The petitioner's candidature as a divorcee for the post of Teacher Grade-III Level 2 subject-Urdu was rejected due to the absence of a valid decree of divorce at the time of submitting the application form. The petitioner had applied for declaration of dissolution of marriage under the provisions of the Dissolution of Muslim Marriage Act, 1939, but the final decree was issued after the application deadline.
Finding of the Court:
The court affirmed the rejection of the petitioner's candidature as a divorcee, emphasizing the requirement of a valid decree of divorce granted by a competent court. The court rejected the petitioner's claim based on certificates and pension status, stating that the petitioner's legal status as a married woman persisted until she obtained a valid decree of divorce.
Issues: The main issue was whether the petitioner's candidature as a divorcee could be accepted without a valid decree of divorce at the time of submitting the application form.
Ratio Decidendi: The court held that a candidate must have a valid decree of divorce granted by a competent court at the time of submitting the application form to claim candidature as a divorcee. The court emphasized the importance of legal documentation and rejected the petitioner's claim based on certificates and pension status.
Final Decision: The court affirmed and approved the rejection of the petitioner's candidature as a divorcee, leading to the dismissal of the writ petition.
JUDGMENT
Dinesh Mehta, J. - Feeling aggrieved of rejection of her candidature as a divorcee' candidate, petitioner has approached this Court by way of filing a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
2. The facts appertain are that the petitioner applied for the post of Teacher Grade-III Level 2 subject-Urdu, pursuant to recruitment notification dated 31.07.2018. Petitioner submitted her application form as a divorcee' candidate on 22.08.2018, while the last date of furnishing application form was 25.08.2018.
3. The respondents rejected petitioner's candidature as a divorcee', because she did not have a decree of divorce till last date of submitting application form.
4. The decree of divorce, however, came to be issued on 19.09.2018 by Family Court, Dungarpur.
5. Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that, when the petitioner had furnished her application form, she had already applied for declaration of dissolution of marriage under the provisions of the Dissolution of Muslim Marriage Act, 1939 but the final decree came to be issued on 19.09.2018 - only 25 days after submitting the application form and thus, petitioner's candidature as a divorcee' could not have been rejected.
6. Learned counsel invited Court's attention towards various documents filed with the writ petition, more particularly the certificate dated 05.07.2013 issued by Panch Modasiyan, Mohallah Ghanti, Dungarpur (Rajasthan) and certificate issued by Municipal Councilor, Dungarpur to establish that petitioner was divorced by her husband in the year 2013 itself.
7. Learned counsel also invited Court's attention towards Annex.4 to show that the petitioner has been receiving pension since July, 2013 and argued that since the petitioner has been receiving pension from the State Government, rejection of her candidature is erroneous.
8. Mr. Choudhary, learned counsel for the respondents vehemently opposed the submissions so made by the petitioner and highlighted that the pension which the petitioner has been receiving since 2013, is being paid to her as "ifjR;drk" destituted/deserted woman and not as a divorcee' and emphasised that considering difference between expression "destitute woman" and a "divorcee'", petitioner cannot be given reservation meant for a divorcee' or widow.
9. It was also argued that the purported certificates issued by Panch Modasiyan, Mohallah Ghanti, Dungarpur (Rajasthan) and Municipal Councilor cannot be treated to be valid documents for the purpose of divorce and unless a candidate has a decree of divorce granted by a competent Court, she cannot claim her candidature as a divorcee'.
10. Inviting Court's attention towards condition relating to reservation appended in point No.(vii) and (viii) of Para 11.2 of the subject advertisement, learned counsel argued that the said condition is very specific and thus, a candidate who does not have a decree of divorce as on the date of submitting application form cannot claim to be considered as a divorcee'.
11. The relevant portion of the advertisement reads thus-
12. Heard.
13. In the opinion of this Court, the documents at Page No.38 and 39 issued by the Panch Modasiyan, Mohallah Ghanti, Dungarpur and Municipal Councilor cannot be considered as an evidence or a valid documents to prove dissolution of marriage.
14. Argument of the petitioner that, she had been divorced by her husband according to the prevailing custom, is not well founded inasmuch as neither by way of pleadings nor otherwise, the petitioner has brought forth any particular date on which her husband had given her divorce by way of "instant divorce" (Talaqe-biddat).
15. In absence of any assertion as to the date of customary divorce, even presumption of divorce cannot be drawn. The fact that petitioner is getting pension as a destituted/deserted woman further fortifies that her legal status as a married woman persisted till she got legally separated.
16. A perusal of the decree of divorce dated 19.09.2018 clearly shows th
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.