SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Judicial Analysis Court Copy Headnote Facts Arguments Court observation
Listen Audio Icon Pause Audio Icon
judgment-img

1980 Supreme(Raj) 55

Rajasthan High Court, Jaipur Bench
G.M. Lodha, J.
Ashok Kumar Sharma - Appellant
Versus
State of Rajasthan - Respondents
S.B. Cr. Misc. Bail Application No. 170 of 1980
Decided On : March 07, 1980

Advocates Appeared:
N.L. Tibrewal, for Applicants; K.N. Garg, Public Prosecutor, for State.

Headnote:Criminal P.C.—Sec. 438—Anticipatory Bail—When to be granted—Malafide design patent—Arrest sought in false and concocted case to defame and Humiliate or black mail —Accused to show bonafides on his part—Where accused remained absconding after case was registered bail refused. (Paras 8&9)

       

G.M. LODHA, J.—Dowery hungry vultures, having failed, in getting T.V., Frieze, Scooter and coins of Rs. 25,000/- (price for selection as Tehsildar) started teasing, taunting, insulting and creating untolerable torture, resulting in severe mental agoney, apathy for such digraceful beastly life, and nervous break down of an innocent, beautiful educated yet help less newly married girl, who was thus forced to commit suicide by burning herself alive—such is the tragic, pathetic, harassing, heart breaking, nerve cracking, conscious shocking and society rocking, one line prosecution story of Urmilla the deceased, and crime of abetement of suicide by husband Ashok Kumar and his dowery starving family members. Yet the prayer is for extraordinary, exceptional judicial favour of bail without jail by the alleged dowery devils. Urmilas "death will" is as under—(Reproduced from police Diary):

^^eq>s Hkyk ugha irk vki yksxksa ds tsgu esa bruk fo"k Hkjk iM+k gSA vki ,d ,d djds eq> ij vkjksi yxkrs jgs ysfdu vkius ;s Hkh lkspk fd eq>s fdruk nq[k gksxkA ughaA tc ls ;s ckrsa vki yksxksa us mBkbZ gS rc ls vkt rd ftruk ekufld nq[k eSaus mBk;k gS] Hkxoku u djsa fdlh vkSj yM+dh dks mBkuk iMs+A vki eEehth vkidh ckrksa ls vkuss ;s tkfgj fd;k fd eq>s u rks mudh ;kn vkrh gS u vki lcls viukiu gS dkk eSa viuk g`n~; [kksy dj fn[kk ldrhA dkk ,d ,slk dEI;wVj foKku us cuk;k gksrk ftlls Hkkoukvksa dk irk pyrkA rc vkidks ekywe gksrk fd esjh Hkkouk;sa D;k gSA eq>s vQlksl gS fd vki yksxksa ds fnekx esa ,slh xyr ckrsa dSls vkbZA ;gkW ifjfLFkfr;kW gh ,slh cu xbZA dqN vkidh n`f"V Hkze Hkh gSA Hkxoku tkurk gS fd esjk fdruk dlwj gS vki tSls balkuksa ds lkeus eSa lQkbZ nsuk Hkh ugha pkgrhA bZoj ds vkxs dksbZ ijnk ugha gSA mldks vlfy;r dk lc irk gSA vr% eq>s nq[k dqN de gSA ysfdu vki yksxksa ds fnekx esa tks ckr cSB xbZ mls flQZ eSa ej dj gh lkQ dj ldrh gwWA ;fn fQj Hkh vki dks esjs Åij fookl ugha gks rks vkids deZ vkids lkFk gSa vkSj esjs deZ esjs lkFkA vki vkSj nhnh esjs lkSan;Z dk ckj&ckj o.kZu dj jgs gSaA bZoj tkurk gS fd eSaus dHkh vius dk lqUnj le>kA ysfdu vkids eqrkfcd lkSUn;Z iznkZu djrh gwWA ml lkSUn;Z dks geskk&geskk ds fy;s feVk jgh gwWA vc rks vki lc [kqk gksukA eSa fdlh dks dksbZ nq[k nsus ugha vkÅaxhA vki lg"kZ [kqkh thou ;kiuk djukA esjs ckbZ&ckcwth] nknh] HkkbZ lkgc] cguk dks nq[k vo; gksxkA Hkxoku mudks ml nq[k dks lgu djus dh kfDr nsA ;s i= mudks t:j&t:j i<+ok nsukA ejus dh cgqr fnuksa ls lksp jgh FkhA ysfdu ekSr us Hkh esjk lkFk NksM+ fn;kA 29-11-79 dh jkr dks eSaus pwgksa okyk tgj [kk fy;k Fkk ysfdu ekSr Hkh eq>ls ukjkt FkhA flok; xys psgjs ds lwtu ds tgj us esjk dqN u fcxkM+kA tc cqjs fnu vkrs gSa rc dksbZ lkFk ugha nsrkA ekSr Hkh eqWg eksM+ xbZA ojuk vkt rd esjk dke reke gks x;k gksrkA oks lwtu ,e-lh- dh otg ls ugha FkhA tSls vius nhnh ykMdh gS oSls vius ekW cki dh ykMdh csVh FkhA eq>s Hkh I;kj dh vko;drk FkhA vkSipkfjd I;kj ds flok; dqN ugha feykA eSa cgqr gh vlfg".kq LoHkko dh yM+dh Fkh ysfdu irk ugha bruh ckrs MkaVuk ;s lc eSaus brus fnuksa rd lgu fd;kA esjh ,d lkM+h] CykÅt isVhdksV ls cDl nc jgh FkhA ;fn ;s bruh gh lkjh gks xbZ oks vkidks vius csVs dh kknh ugha djuh pkfg, FkhA ckrsa rks fny eSa cgqrA lkjh ckrsa fy[k ugha ldrhA eSa viuh bPNk;sa yksxksa us esjh Hkkoukvksa dks le>k gh ughaA [kSj esjh cnfdLerh FkhA dHkh eq>s le>us dh dksfkk ugha dhA gs bsoj] vkils izkFkZuk gS fd vc vkxs ls ,slh lh/kh yM+dh iSnk u djuk tks bruh nCcw LoHkko dh gks] vius vf/kdkjksa ds fy, Hkh u yM+ ldsA esjh ekSr dh ftEesnkj eSa [kqn gwWA

g-mfeZyk



2. The case has been registered under section 306 I.P.C. against the petitioners Ashok Kumar, husband of the deceased and Kumari Nirja, sister of Ashok Kumar Sharma in addition to mother-in-law and father-in-law on the allegation that the accused used to torture the deceased Urmila for not having brought sufficient dowery. Thus mental torture of the deceased Urmila as per the prosecution allegation become unbearable and as a result of this she committed suicide, after an oarler attempt to suicide has failed. The suicide note sh
















Click Here to Read the rest of this document

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
logo-black

An indispensable Tool for Legal Professionals, Endorsed by Various High Court and Judicial Officers

Please visit our Training & Support
Center or Contact Us for assistance

qr

Scan Me!

India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!

For Daily Legal Updates, Join us on :

whatsapp-icon Back to top