Honble BALIA, J.–Appellant in this appeal is an Engineer employed in the Central Public Works Department. While he was working as Superintending Engineer, Jodhpur Central Circle, CPWD, Jodhpur, the appellant was ordered to be transferred as Superintending Engineer, (Valuation) Bhopal vide order dated 19.7.99, which was communicated by the Deputy Director (Administration), New Delhi, from the office of the Directorate General of the Central Public Works Department. The order was at the instance of the Director General of the Central Public Works Department. By the same order Mr. R.P. Mathur, respondent No. 5 in this appeal who was then working as Superintending Engineer, P&A, North Zone III, Jaipur was posted vice appellant. The order dated 19.07.1999 in all contained 4 transfers including of the appellant and said Mr. R.P. Mathur. According to that order, one Lalit Mohan, S.E. (Valuation), Bhopal has been transferred as S.E. (P&A) North Zone III Jaipur vice Mr. R.P (2) Mathur and one Vipin Chand, who was S.E. (Parliament Library Project, New Delhi was transferred as S.E. (Planning) IBBZ, Siliguri. While the transfers of Mr. O.P. Purohit and Mr. R.P. Mathur and Mr. Lalit Mohan were

Click Here to Read the rest of this document