2007 Supreme(Raj) 694
Rajasthan High Court
Honble PRAKASH TATIA, J.
Rajasthan Vikas Sansthan through its Chairman, Jodhpur - Appellant
Versus
Shri G.S. Sandhu,Secretary, Medical & Health Department, Jaipur & Anr. - Respondents
S.B. Civil Misc. Contempt Petition No. 195 of 2005
Decided On : May 07, 2007
M.R. Singhvi, for Petitioner R.P.S.Choudhary, Addl. Advocate General, for Respondents
Headnote:Contempt of Court Act, 1971, Sec. 10, 11, 17; Constitution of India, Art. 215 – Contempt Petition – Rejection of No objection Certificate granted for opening B.Sc. Nursing Course – High Court directed to decide the matter within three months – Not complied with – Held – N.O.C. was rejected ignoring the evidence on record in relation to the eligibility of his claim for N.O.C. from the State Govt. for opening B.Sc. Nursing Course – Deliberately, with oblique motive and to deny the relief to petitioner fresh evidence with clear intention to discard material available on record which were infavour of petitioner and that too on false and absolute frivolous grounds were collected – Justification submitted is nothing but action of deliberate act or not acting honestly and a clear act of misleading the Court by submitting wrong facts – Amounts to contempt of Court. (Paras 26 to 31)
(2). Brief facts of the case are that the petitioner society is registered society under the Societies Registration Act, 1958. The petitioner society wanted to open B.Sc. Nursing Course College. The petitioner society applied for No Objection Certificate from the State as required under the instructions issued by the Indian Nursing Council. The No Objection Certificate(for short "NOC" hereinafter) was granted by the Government of Rajasthan to the petitioner society on 24.4.2002 on condition of obtaining no objection by the petitioner from the Indian Nursing council, New Delhi for opening B.Sc. Nursing Course College. After obtaining NOC for opening B.Sc. Nursing Course College at Jodhpur, from the Government of Rajasthan, the petitioner sought no objection from the Indian Nursing Council, New Delhi by sending letter dated 3.5.2002. The petitioner also paid the fee of Rs.50,000/- by Demand Draft dated 1.5.2002 to the Indian Nursing Council, New Delhi. The Indian Nursing Council by letter dated 28.8.2002 (Annx.7) agreed to inspect the petitioners Nursing College on 3.9.2002 and it was communicated to the petitioner vide letter dated 28.8.2002 (Annx.7). Ultimately the petitioners institution was duly inspected by the Indian Nursing Council,New Delhi. The petitioner also applied for getting affiliation from the University of Rajasthan, Jaipur for its college vide letter dated 26.4.2002 and sent a draft of Rs.105000/- to the University of Rajasthan along with letter dated 26.4.2002. The University of Rajasthan vide communication dated 8.8.2002 (Annx.9), granted no objection to the proposal of the petitioner for opening the B.Sc. Nursing Course College subject to the condition that if such permission granted by the Indian Nursing Council also and with condition that no student shall be admitted to the said course unless and until approval of Indian Nursing Council, New Delhi is obtained as well as actual affiliation is obtained from the University of Rajasthan. It appears that some norms were changed and, therefore, the State Government vide letter dated 7.8.2002 (Annx.10) informed that no objection for opening B.Sc. Nursing Course College issued in favour of the petitioner for capacity of 100 seats shall be for 60 seats in place of 100 seats. The reducing the seats was though objected by the petitioner by letter dated 12.8.2002 but that is not very much relevant for the purpose of deciding this contempt petition.
(3). As per the facts pleaded in the writ petition, the controversy arose because of the reason that according to the petitioner, the then Health Minister without disclosing his identity, visited the petitioners institute and according to the petitioner, the Honble Minister misbehaved with employee of the petitioner-institute and forcibly proceeded to open the chamber of the petitioner institutes Director, and the chamber of the Director of the petitioners institute was opened forcibly and search was made. This incident happened on 4.9.2002 at about 4 p.m. and the petitioner-institute immediately submitted a criminal complaint in the court of Chief Judicial Magistrate, Jodhpur on 5.9.2002, copy of which has been placed on record by the petitioner in the writ petition as Annx.12. The complaint was sent to the concerned Police Station under Section 156(3), Cr.P.C. for investigation. Then just 20 days after the above incident, on 25.9.2002, the petitioner received a show cause notice asking the petitioner to explain why the NOC granted by the Government of Rajasthan for opening B.Sc. Nursing Course College to the petitioner may not be cancelled. By the same communication dated 25.9.2002 (Annx.13) the petitioners NOC dated 24.4.2002 was suspended. The petitioner, therefore, filed the writ petition which was registered as S.B.