SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2019 Supreme(HP) 909

IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT SHIMLA
TARLOK SINGH CHAUHAN, J.
Harbans Singh — Appellant
Versus
Kundan Lal (deceased) through his lrs. And another — Respondent
Regular Second Appeal No. 201 of 2003, 87, 92 of 2011, 133 of 2013
Decided on : 22-07-2019

Important Points

The main legal point established in the judgment is the application of adverse inference and the redundancy of substantial questions of law in property dispute cases.

Subject

Property Law - Property Disputes

Act Referred

CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE : O.7 R.11, S.10, O.2 R.2
HIMACHAL PRADESH LAND REVENUE ACT : S.171

Headnote

adverse inference - Property Dispute - H.P. Land Revenue Act - [Section 171 of H.P. Land Revenue Act, Order 2 Rule 2 CPC] - The court dismissed the suit filed by the plaintiff based on adverse inference drawn against the plaintiff for not stepping into the witness box and failing to prove the plea of exchange. The court also held that the substantial questions of law raised in the appeals were rendered redundant as the issues had already been decided in previous cases.

Fact of the Case:

The plaintiff filed multiple suits related to property disputes against the defendants. The court dismissed the suits based on adverse inference drawn against the plaintiff and the redundancy of the substantial questions of law raised in the appeals.

Finding of the Court:

The court found that the plaintiff failed to prove the plea of exchange and drew adverse inference against the plaintiff for not stepping into the witness box. The court also held that the substantial questions of law raised in the appeals were rendered redundant as the issues had already been decided in previous cases.

Issues: The issues included the plea of exchange, adverse inference, jurisdiction of the civil court, and the redundancy of substantial questions of law raised in the appeals.

Ratio Decidendi: The court's decision was based on the adverse inference drawn against the plaintiff and the redundancy of the substantial questions of law raised in the appeals.

Final Decision: The court dismissed the appeals and the pending application(s), leaving the parties to bear their own costs.

Advocates:
Advocate Appeared:
G.D. Verma, Adv., B.C. Verma, Adv., Suneet Goel, Adv., Virender Singh Rathour, Adv.

JUDGMENT :

Tarlok Singh Chauhan, J.

This bunch of appeals was taken up together for consideration and is being disposed of by common judgment as it involves overlapping issues.

2. The parties are ad idem that the fate of other appeals virtually would be dependent on outcome of RSA No. 201/2003, therefore, the same is taken up as the lead case. The parties shall be referred to as the "plaintiff" and "defendants".

3. The plaintiff filed a suit for declaration and permanent prohibitory injunction on the ground that the plaintiff and defendants are sons of Tulsi Ram and being real brothers are co-owners in possession of the suit land. It was alleged that in the recent settlement, the suit land was assigned new Khasra numbers whereas in the year 1973, the plaintiff and defendant No.1, Kundan Lal (since deceased) had agreed to exchange the suit land with the understanding that defendant No.1 would relinquish his entire 1/3rd share in the suit land in his favour and the plaintiff would give him equal land to the extent of the share of defendant No.1 in Mauja Dochi. He therefore, purchased land measuring 15 bighas 6 biswas from one Kaka Ram through a registered sale deed No.91, dated 1.10.1973 and out of this land, 1/2 share of the land was transferred in favour of defendant No.1 by way of said sale showing him to be the purchaser and owner of 1/2 share i.e. 7 bighas 13 biswas despite the fact that the said land was exclusively purchased by the plaintiff from said Kaka Ram. It was further averred that at that time, defendant No.1 was un-employed having no source of income and thus, by way of purchase in the name of defendant No.1, the plaintiff had performed his part of the agreement and defendant No.1 was required to relinquish his 1/2 share of the land situated in Mauja Dhariyan, i.e. the suit land in favour of the plaintiff. Since the plaintiff had been cultivating the suit land, therefore, he had made lot of improvements by raising an orchard, but defendant No.1 started demanding his share in the land relying upon wrong revenue entries and threatened to seek partition. Hence, the suit.

4. Defendant No.1 contested the suit by filing written statement, wherein he raised preliminary objections regarding locus standi, estoppel and claimed that the suit land had already been partitioned inter se the parties as per orders passed by the Assistant Collector, 1st Grade, Kandaghat on 3.6.1995 in partition case No. 30/S-A of 1994, titled as Kundan Lal vs. Harbans Lal etc and the instrument of the partition had also been prepared and only mutation remained to be entered. On merits, defendant No.1 denied factum of exchange and the payment of entire consideration by the plaintiff with respect to the land purchased on 1.10.1973 from Kaka Ram.

5. In replication, preliminary objections were denied by the plaintiff and on merits, he re-affirmed and reiterated the averments made in the plaint.

6. On the pleadings of the parties, the learned trial court on 30.7.1997 framed the following issues:-

1. Whether the defendant No.1 had relinquished his share by way of exchange in the suit land, in favour of the plaintiff, as alleged ? OPP

2. If issue No.1 is answered in affirmative, whether the plaintiff has become owner-in possession of 2/3rd share in the suit land, as alleged? OPP

3. Whether the plaintiff has no locus standi to file the present suit? OPD

4. Whether the plaintiff is estopped from filing the suit, as alleged ? OPD

5. Whether the suit land has already been partitioned by metes and bounds qua parties, if so its effect? OPD

6. Whether the suit is not maintainable in the present form? OPD.

7. Relief.

7. After recording the evidence and evaluating the same, the learned trial court vide judgment and decree dated 5.10.2002 dismissed the suit filed by the plaintiff. The appeal against the judgment and decree dated 5.10.2002 also came to be dismissed by the learned first appellate court vide judgment and decree dated 17.3.2003 constraining the plaintiff to file t

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top