IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT SHIMLA
MS. SABINA, SATYEN VAIDYA, JJ.
Chander Prakash, S/o Sh. Pritam Singh – Appellant
Versus
State Of Himachal Pradesh - Respondent
Criminal Appeal No. 312 of 2017
Decided on : 24-03-2022
Narcotic Drugs & Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 - Section 20, 42, 57 – Criminal Procedural Code, 1973 - Section 313 – Appeal - Appellant was charged for commission of offence punishable under Section 20 of ND&PS, Act to which he pleaded not guilty and claimed trial.
Findings of the Court:
Court has carefully scrutinized statements of police witnesses. As far as, sequence of events that had taken place on spot has been unanimously narrated by PW-1, PW-2, PW-3 and PW-10 in one voice - All these spot witnesses have stated in unison that they had laid a "Nakka" on Kirti road - Appellant appeared on the spot with a bag in his hand - On suspicion, bag was searched and charas weighing 1.5 Kgs was recovered - All these witnesses have been subjected to detailed cross-examination but no material could be elicited benefiting defence - In fact, no material contradiction in statements of all spot witnesses could be pointed out on behalf of appellant - Only test to check veracity of a witness is his cross examination - Court have no hesitation to say that all above spot witnesses have successfully undergone test of cross-examination - Thus, Court do not find any material on record to disbelieve version given by these witnesses - Another unsuccessful attempt has been made by learned counsel for appellant to discredit prosecution case by inviting our attention towards photograph Ext. PW2/A-2 - As per him, kind of weighing scale visible in photograph is not usually available with police and this proves that police have brought this weighing scale from nearby shop and thus independent witnesses could also be easily associated - Court do not find any substance in this argument also as there is no rule that provides that police station cannot have traditional type of weighing scale as shown in photograph i.e PW-2/A-2 - However, defence could have discharged this burden by leading cogent evidence - No inference can be drawn from assumptions in a criminal trial.
Result: Appeal dismissed
JUDGMENT :
By way of instant appeal, appellant has assailed his conviction and sentence recorded by the learned Special Judge-II, Kinnaur at Rampur Bushahr, H.P., vide judgment dated 06.06.2016 in Sessions Trial No. 28-R/3 of 2016, whereby the appellant has been convicted for commission of offence punishable under Section 20 of the Narcotic Drugs & Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985(for short ‘ND& PS’ Act) and has been sentenced to undergo rigorous imprisonment for ten years and to pay a fine of Rs. 1,00,000/- and in default of payment of fine to undergo further simple imprisonment of six months.
2. The case as set up by the prosecution was that a police party of Police Station Kumarsain, District Shimla, H.P. including SI/SHO Virochan Negi, HC Rakesh Kumar, ASI Krishan Lal and Constable Mool Chand, while on patrol had laid a "Nakka" on the "Kirti road".At about 10:15 P.M. appellant approached the spot of "Nakka" from Kirti side. PW-10, SI/SHO Virochan Negi stopped the appellant, who was carrying a red colour bag in his left hand. On suspicion, the bag carried by the appellant was checked. The red colour bag contained another bag of dark brown colour and inside such bag black coloured substance in the shape of balls was found. The black colour substance was discovered to be the "Cannabis". The place where the accused was apprehended was secluded and no independent witness was immediately available. PW-1, H.C. Rakesh Kumar, PW-2, ASI Krishan Lal were associated as witnesses. The "Cannabis" was weighed and found 1 Kg 500 grams. The contraband was placed firstly in the dark brown bag which in turn was placed inside the red colour bag. This bag was further placed in a cloth parcel Ext. PA, which was sealed with six seals having impression “N”. Sample seal was drawn on a separate piece of cloth Ext.PW1/A.NCB form Ext.PW6/B was filled up by PW-10, SI/SHO Virochan Negi. Seal after use was handed over to PW-1, HC Rakesh Kumar. Seizure memo Ext. PW1/B was prepared. The spot proceedings were photographed by PW-2, ASI Krishan Lal. Photographs PW2/A-1 to Ex. PW2/A-6 were later developed. Rukka Ext. PW3/A was prepared and handed over to PW-3, C. Mool Chand for being taken to police station for the purposes of registration of FIR. PW-3, C. Mool Chand took the Rukka to the police station, on the basis of which FIR Ext. PW3/B was recorded. PW-10, SI/SHO Virochan Negi prepared special report Ext. PW4/A, under Section 57 of the Act and sent the same to S.D.P.O. Rampur, where it was received by the concerned police officer and handed over to PW-4, HC Tara Chand to be kept in record. The accused was formally arrested on spot. The case property alongwith accused were brought to police station. The case property was handed over to PW-6, MHC Sita Devi alongwith relevant documents for safe custody in "Malkhana". On 08.02.2016, the recovered contraband was sent for chemical analysis to S.F.S.L. Junga through PW-5, HHC Roshan Lal No. 413. On chemical analysis, such substance was confirmed to be cannabis, vide report Ext. PX. The contraband and report Ext. PX were brought from S.F.S.L. Junga to Police Station Kumarsain on 29.02.2016 by PW-8, HHC Roshan Lal No. 372. After investigation, challan was prepared and presented in the Court. Appellant was charged for commission of offence punishable under Section 20 of the ND&PS, Act to which he pleaded not guilty and claimed trial.
3. Prosecution examined total ten witnesses. PW-1, HC Rakesh Kumar, PW-2, ASI Krishan Lal, PW-3, C. Mool Chand and PW-10, SI/SHO Virochan Negi were examined as spot witnesses. PW-9, LC Chetna proved the transit of special report Ext. PW-4/A from police station to the office of S.D.P.O. Rampur on 08.02.2016. PW-4, HC Tara Chand proved the receipt of special report. PW-5, HHC Roshan Lal No. 413 proved the transit of contraband from police station Kumarsain to S.F.S.L. Junga on 08.02.2016 and PW-8, HHC Roshal Lal No. 372 proved the transit of contraband from S.F.S.L. Junga to Police Statio
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.