2016 Supreme(HP) 2437
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT SHIMLA
P.S.RANA, J.
Smt. Davinder Parmar wd/o late Sh.Balbir Singh and another - Plaintiff
Versus
Sh. Kulbir Singh s/o late Sh.Avtar Singh & Others - Defendant
C.S. No. 96/2009
Decided on : 06-10-2016
Important Points
Subject
Civil Law - Property Law
Act Referred
Headnote
Partition Suit - Property - H.P. Land Revenue Act 1954 - The court found that the plaintiffs were entitled to a preliminary decree of partition of their shares in the suit property. The court also held that the suit for partition was maintainable and competent, and that it was not bad for non-joinder of necessary parties. The court further decided that the suit had not been properly valued for purposes of court fee and jurisdiction. The court rejected the defendants' claims that the plaintiffs were estopped by their acts, deeds, conduct, and acquiescences to file and maintain the suit, and that the plaintiffs had not come to court with clean hands and suppressed material facts. The court also rejected the defendants' claim that the plaintiffs were out of possession of the suit property.
Fact of the Case:
The present civil suit was filed for the partition of a structure and vacant land situated in Shimla. The plaintiffs claimed to be joint owners of the suit property and sought a decree for partition. The defendants raised various objections, including non-joinder of necessary parties, improper valuation of the suit, and estoppel by the plaintiffs.
Finding of the Court:
The court found in favor of the plaintiffs, granting them a preliminary decree of partition and rejecting the defendants' objections. The court held that the suit was maintainable, properly valued, and not bad for non-joinder of necessary parties. The court also rejected the defendants' claims of estoppel and lack of clean hands on the part of the plaintiffs.
Issues: The issues included the entitlement of the plaintiffs to a preliminary decree of partition, the maintainability and competence of the suit, non-joinder of necessary parties, proper valuation for court fee and jurisdiction, estoppel by the plaintiffs, lack of clean hands, and the possession of the suit property by the plaintiffs.
Ratio Decidendi: The court's decision was based on the evidence presented, including the ownership records, the absence of evidence of joint funds for the purchase of the property, and the lack of evidence of adverse possession by the defendants. The court also considered the provisions of the H.P. Land Revenue Act 1954 in reaching its decision.
Final Decision: The court granted a preliminary decree of partition in favor of the plaintiffs, determining the shares of the parties and ordering further inquiries and proceedings for the final partition of the suit property.
Advocate Appeared:
For the Plaintiff :Mr. G.C. Gupta, Sr. Advocate with Ms. Meera Devi, Advocate
For the Defendant :Mr. G.D. Verma, Sr. Advocate with Mr. B. C.Verma, Advocate Mr. Bhupinder Gupta, Sr. Advocate with Mr. Neeraj Gupta Advocate Mr. Satyen Vaidya, Sr. Advocate with Mr. Vivek Sharma, Advocate
JUDGMENT :
P. S. Rana, J.
1. Present civil suit is filed for partition of structure and partition of vacant land situated over suit land comprised in khata No.129 khatoni No. 138 khasra Nos. 1439, 1440, 1441, 1442, 1443, 1444, 1445, 1446, 1447, 1448, 1449, 1450, 1451, 1452, 1458 & 1460 kita 16 measuring 11902.41 situated in Up Mohal Lakkar Bazar (Market) Ward Bara Shimla Tehsil and Distt. Shimla (H.P.) as shown in jamabandi for the year 2010-2011 Ext.DW-4/D placed on record. It is pleaded that plaintiffs are joint owners of suit property and defendants are also joint owners of suit property. It is pleaded that plaintiffs intend to partition their share. It is further pleaded that plaintiffs requested the defendants to partition the suit property but despite requests defendants did not partition the suit property. Prayer for decree of civil suit by way of partition sought.
2. Per contra written statements filed on behalf of co-defendants No.1, 2 & 4 to 6 pleaded therein that plaintiffs deliberately did not include joint land situated in villages Basiala and Binjon Tehsil Garhshankar Distt. Hoshiarpur (Punjab) in the present suit. It is further pleaded that suit is bad for non-joinder of necessary parties. It is further pleaded that correct name of co-defendant No.2 is Mrs. Inderjit Parmar and not Indu Parmar. It is further pleaded that suit has not been properly valued for purposes of Court fee and jurisdiction. It is further pleaded that plaintiffs are out of possession of suit land and they have no cause of action to file the partition suit. It is further pleaded that plaintiffs are estopped by their acts, deeds, conduct and acquiescences to file and maintain the present suit. It is further pleaded that plaintiffs have not approached the Court with clean hands. It is further pleaded that status of parties as co-sharers is not disputed. It is further pleaded that suit for partition of one property situated at Shimla is not maintainable on the ground of partial partition of joint property inter se parties.
3. Separate written statement filed on behalf of co-defendant No.7 Smt. Chander Kanta pleaded therein that suit is filed for partial partition of joint property and same is not maintainable. It is further pleaded that suit has been filed relating to immovable property situated at Shimla town. It is further pleaded that joint property situated at villages Basiala and Binjon Tehsil Garhshankar Distt. Hoshiarpur (Punjab) have not been included in the present partition suit. It is further pleaded that suit has not been properly valued for purposes of Court fee and jurisdiction. It is further pleaded that plaintiffs are estopped by their acts, deeds, conduct and acquiescences to file and maintain the present suit. It is further pleaded that plaintiffs did not approach the Court with clean hands. It is further pleaded that khasra Nos. 1439, 1443, 1451, 1458 and 1460 cannot be partitioned and same should be kept joint because area under above khasra numbers is land in relevant record but factually thick forest is situated at spot. It is further pleaded that area of khasra No.1452 is in the shape of path and same cannot be partitioned in accordance with law. It is further pleaded that area mentioned in khasra No.1445 is in the shape of apple orchard and same cannot be partitioned by the civil Court and same will be partitioned under H. P. Land Revenue Act by Assistant Collector Ist Grade of area. It is further pleaded that co-defendant No.7 Smt. Chander Kanta has carried out annual maintenance and repair of building situated over suit land and spent expenditure to the tune of Rs.30,000,00/- (Thirty lac) in connection with maintenance and repair work of the building situated over suit land and is entitled to annual maintenance and repair charges in accordance with law. It is further pleaded that present suit property cannot be divided on the basis of shares recorded in the record of right placed on record prepared by revenue official unde