1992 Supreme(J&K) 18
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU AND KASHMIR AT JAMMU
B.A. Khan, J.
Harbans Lal & Ors. - Appellant
Versus
Charanjit Singh & Ors. - Respondent
Civil Revision Petition No. 42/1990
Decided On : 06 March, 1992
Important Points
Subject
Civil Law - SERVICE OF SUMMONS
Act Referred
Headnote
CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE - ORDER V, RULES 2 AND 17 - SERVICE OF SUMMONS - IRREGULARITY OR ILLEGALITY - DISTINCTION - EFFECT ON EXPARTE DECREE.
Fact of the Case:
Petitioners sought to set aside an ex parte decree against them, arguing that the trial court had committed procedural violations of Order V, Rules 2 and 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) in serving the summons.
Finding of the Court:
The court held that the petitioners' refusal to acknowledge the summons rendered the service of summons irregular, but not illegal. The court found that the petitioners had knowledge of the claim against them and failed to appear before the trial court without sufficient cause.
Issues: 1. Whether the service of summons was irregular or illegal due to non-compliance with Order V, Rules 2 and 17 of the CPC? 2. Whether the ex parte decree should be set aside due to the irregularity or illegality in the service of summons?
Ratio Decidendi: 1. Order V, Rule 2 of the CPC requires a copy of the plaint or a concise statement to accompany the summons. However, non-compliance with this provision may not have the same consequences where the defendant refuses to acknowledge the summons and Order V, Rule 17 comes into play. 2. Order V, Rule 17 provides the procedure for service of summons when the defendant refuses to accept service or cannot be found. Affixing a copy of the summons on the outer door of the defendant's house is considered sufficient service in such cases. 3. The distinction between irregularity and illegality is based on the degree of compliance with the prescribed requirements. Irregularity contemplates a defect in procedure or non-compliance with a prescribed formality that may not be substantial. Illegality, on the other hand, connotes contravention of a statute, which can make an action void. 4. In the present case, the petitioners' refusal to acknowledge the summons rendered the service of summons irregular, but not illegal. The court found that the petitioners had knowledge of the claim against them and failed to appear before the trial court without sufficient cause.
Final Decision: The revision petition was dismissed, and the ex parte decree was upheld.
Advocate For Appellant: P.C. Sharma
Advocate For Respondent: R.S. Thakur
2. Petitioners were defendants in a suit brought against them by respondent No.1. The suit was for restraining them from interfering in the possession and use of plot measuring 6 marlas comprising Khasra No: 422, situate at Shakti Nagar, Jammu. Summons were issued to them. In case of petitioner No.1 it was affixed on the walls of his house and in case of petitioners 2 and 3 it was tendered to them by process server which they refused to acknowledge.
3. Petitioners approached trial court on November 1,(988, praying for setting aside of the exparte decree. Their prayer was, however, rejected. vide order dated Sept, 4, 1988. They went in appeal against the order but again failed. In a last ditch effort they have filed this revision petition calling in question orders passed by two courts below.
4. The main thrust of petitioners, case is that they were not duly served in the face of procedural violation committed in service of summons. According to them, since summons was not accompanied by copy of plaint or a concise statement thereof and process-server had failed to affix summons on the house of defendants 2 and 3 even when they had refused to acknowledge the same, service of summons was not in accordance with mandate of law. They bring their grievance within the provisions of Order V, Rules 2 and 17 and urge that failure to satisfy requirements of these provisions vitiates service of summons constituting basis for setting aside exparte decree passed against them.
5. Relevant provisions require to be extracted to examine the contention, which read as under: -
Order V, Rule 2 : Copy or statement annexed to summons.- Every summons shall be accompanied by a copy of the plaint, or, if so permitted, by a concise statement."
Order V, Rule 17 : Procedure when defendant refuse to accept service, or cannot be found. - Where the defendant or his agent or such other person as aforesaid refuses to sign the acknowledgement, or where the serving Officer, after using all due and reasonable diligence, cannot find the defendant (the words who is absent from his residence at the time when service is sought to be effected on him at his residence and there is no likelihood of his being found at the residence within a reasonable time) and there is no agent empowered to accept service of the summons on his behalf, nor any other person on whom service can be made, the serving Officer shall affix a copy of the summons on the outer door of some other conspicuous part of the house in which the defendant ordinarily resides or carries on business or personally works for gain, and shall then return the original to the court from which it was issued, with a report endorsed thereon or annexed thereto stating that he has so affixed the copy, the circumstances under which he did so, and the name and address of the person ( if any ) by whom the house was identified and in whose presence the copy was affixed,"
6. It is true that Order V, Rule 2 requires to be accompanied by a copy of plaint or a concise statement of facts to enable the defendant to know the nature of suit against him. Non-compliance of this provision can have varying consequences depending upon the facts of a case. It may prove fatal in a case where defendant acknowledges the summons and pleads prejudice caused in the absence of copy of plaint. But it may not have the same consequences where defendant refuses to acknowledge summons and Rule 17 comes into play. In the former case it does prejudice a defendant who is eager to resist the claim, but is handicapped in deciding whether to de