SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2008 Supreme(J&K) 191

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JAMMU AND KASHMIR AT JAMMU
Sunil Hali, J.
Gh. Ahmad Wani - Appellant
Versus
Bank Of India & Ors. - Respondent
Civil Revision No. 122/2007
Decided On : 26 May, 2008

Important Points

The executing court is not obligated to stay the execution of a decree solely because an application to set aside an ex parte decree is pending, and the party seeking to set aside the ex parte decree must show sufficient cause.

Subject

Civil Law - Execution of Decree

Act Referred

CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE : S.115, O.9 R.13

Headnote

Revision Petition - Execution of Decree - O. 9 Rule 13 CPC - O. 21 - [O. 9 Rule 13 CPC, O. 21]

Fact of the Case:

A decree was passed ex parte in 1996, and an application to set it aside was filed in 1997. The application was pending for a long time, and execution proceedings were initiated against the petitioner. The executing court ordered attachment of the property, and a separate application for restoration of the application to set aside the ex parte decree was filed. The petitioner challenged the order for attachment of property.

Finding of the Court:

The court found that the executing court had the authority to proceed with the execution of the decree despite the pending application to set aside the ex parte decree. The court also noted the delay in the trial court's decision on the application for restoration.

Issues: The main issue was whether the executing court could proceed with the execution of the decree while the application to set aside the ex parte decree was pending.

Ratio Decidendi: The court held that the executing court was not obligated to stay the execution of the decree solely because an application to set aside the ex parte decree was pending. It also emphasized the need for the party seeking to set aside the ex parte decree to show sufficient cause, especially when the application is filed after the expiry of the limitation period.

Final Decision: The court dismissed the revision petition and directed the trial court to decide the application for restoration of the application to set aside the ex parte decree within two months.

Advocates Appeared:
Advocate For Appellant: D.S. Thakur
Advocate For Respondent: C.L. Razdan

This revision petition has been preferred against an order passed by learned Additional District Judge (Bank Cases) Jammu. The said order has been passed by the court below in the course of seeking implementation of execution petition pending before the said court.

2. Brief facts of this case are that a decree was passed by the trial court on 8.4.1996. It was an ex parte decree. An application came to be filed by the present petitioner and other defendants in the year 1997. The ground taken in the application was that they had no knowledge about the pendency of the suit in the court below. It was averred that the defendants were served by publication in Daily Excelsior which had no circulation in village Bharat in District Doda. It was also pleaded that they had no knowledge of English. The said application is pending before the trial court from 1997. The petitioner again failed to appear before the trial court and his application for setting aside the exparte decree was dismissed in default on 27.7.2007.

3. After dismissal of his application the execution proceedings initiated against the petitioner-defendant got revived. In pursuance to the execution proceedings an order came to be passed by the trial court directing attachment of the property of the defendants. The order directs SDPO Bakshi Nagar, Jammu to effect the execution of the decree. It is this order of the executing court which is subject matter of challenge before the court. It is important to mention that on the same date the petitioner and other defendants filed an application for restoration of application for setting aside the exparte judgment and decree before the court below. On this application coming up before the court it was ordered that the petitioner should furnish a bank guarantee to the tune of the amount under execution and in case he does so the order passed by the executing court shall remain stayed. It is important to mention that both the execution proceedings and application for setting aside the exparte decree were pending before the same court.

4. After the application for setting aside exparte decree was dismissed on 31.7.2007 the court revived its order for seeking the execution of the decree by attachment of the property on 31.7.2007. This order was reiterated by this court on 29.8.2007. In the order dated 29.8.2007 the court records that the warrants of attachment issued have been received back unexecuted. It is this order which is subject matter of challenge before this court.

5. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.

6. Mr. D.S. Thakur states that the executing court could not have proceeded in the matter as application for restoration of his application for setting aside exparte decree was still pending before the court below. As a matter of fact he states that the court has failed to exercise its jurisdiction in not staying the operation of the decree. His other contention is that two contradictory orders have been passed by the court on 29.8.2007.

7. The first order seeks attachment of the property of the petitioner through SDPO Bakshi Nagar, Jammu and the other order stays operation of the decree subject to the furnishing of bank guarantee to the tune of decretal amount. Both the arguments are misconceived. Merely because an application for setting aside exparte decree is filed could not cast an obligation on the court below to stay the operation of the decree. As a matter of fact, the setting aside of exparte decree under O. 9 Rule 13 CPC is not to be done as a matter of course. The party seeking setting aside exparte decree has to show a sufficient cause before a decree can be set aside, more particularly when the application for setting aside exparte decree has been filed after the expiry of limitation. There is no legal mandate on the court to stay an execution of the decree without satisfying itself to the contents of the application.

8. In the present case after the application for setting aside the expa







1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top