Vikramaditya Prasad, J.

1. Heard both the sides.

2. The petitioners husband had died in harness then she applied for her appointment to Class IV post on compassionate ground. By Annexure 2 she was appointed on the recommendation of the District Establishment Committee by the District Animal Husbandry Officer, Dhanbad. This letter was issued on 31.3.1994.

3. A letter of department regarding compassionate appointment, as contained in Annexure 3 was issued on 12.4.1994, which reads as follows :--

"Sankhya 13 Stha-176/93, P.Ma. 2693 Pashupalan Vibhag, Bihar, Patna

Preshak. Dr. Ram Raj Ram, Nideshak, Pashupalan Vibhag, Bihar, Patna

Sewa Me, Sabhi Kshetriya Nideshak, Pashupalan

Sabhi Zila Pashupalan Padadhikari

Bishaya : Anukampa ke aadhar per keshtriya padadhikari dwara ke ja rahi niyukti ke sabandhya me.

Mahashya,

Upyukta bishaya ke ore aapka dhyan akrishta kartey huya kahana hai ki kshetriya padhadhikari dwara anukam-pa per verge 3 awang verg 4 ke path per zila striya anukampa samiti se anushansha pratra kar niyukti ke kar-wari ke jati hai jo aniyamit pratit hota hais. Gatbya ho ki vibhag me rajya stariya anukampa samiti gatidh hai es-liyae vabishya me koi bhi anukampa ke aadhar per niyukt