2003 Supreme(Mad) 478
High Court of Judicature at Madras
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE P. SATHASIVAM
Kodaikanal International School - Appellant
Versus
Minor Nihal Ghosh - Respondents
Civil Revision Petition (P.D) No. 268 of 2003 and C.M.P.No. 2053 of 2003
Decided On : 21 March 2003
Important Points
Subject
Education Law - Student Discipline
Act Referred
CONSTITUTION OF INDIA : Art.227
Headnote
The above Revision under Article 227 of the Constitution of India is directed against the order dated 6-2-2003 of the learned District Munsif-cum-Judicial Magistrate, Kodaikanal in I.A.No. 31 of 2003 in O.S.No. 17 of 2003.
2. Heard Mr. N.S. Sivam, learned counsel for the petitioner and Mr. Sridhar, learned counsel for the respondent.
3. Kodaikanal International School through its Principal is the petitioner in the above Revision. The case of the petitioner school is briefly stated hereunder:
The respondent-student Nihal Ghosh studied in the petitioner school upto 8th Grade along with his elder brother. In 2001, his parents shifted Nihal Ghosh from Kodaikanal International school. In 2001, the parents of Nihal Ghosh requested Kodaikanal International School to re-admit their son Nihal Ghosh. By showing latitude, Nihal Ghosh was admitted in the petitioner school in July, 2001 in Grade 10 (Tenth Standard) signing Code of Conduct prescribed for the students. In February, 2002, the school staff Mirdula Bardhan reported that Nihal Ghosh was often disrupting the classes and his behaviour distracts other students and spoils the sobriety of the school room environment and his slang and vulgarity suggest obsession with thoughts of sex. The examination by the school Doctor revealed that Nihal Ghosh has developed the habit of using Marijona and only half a packet of marijona now produces effect on him. He was advised to come for periodical counselling. On 28-8-2002 the school doctor reported that the boy has admitted that he is in the habit of using Heroine and Horse tranquilisers. The Dean of the student on seeing these Medical Reports caused surprise visit to the dormitory and on 30-08-2002 wherein he found Nihal Ghosh was smoking cigarette and his eyes were dilated. Again on 01-09-2002 on another surprise visit, the Dean found packet of cigarettes hidden under computer. Immediately the school by letter dated 03-09-2002 advised the parents of Nihal Ghosh to come and take charge of the boy immediately and give adequate medical help to enable the boy to get out of the drug addict habits and only when medical tests show that the boy has got out of these habits he could be allowed to study in the school.
4. The National Institute of Mental Health and Neuro Sciences and De additional Centre (in short 'NIMHANS') examined Nihal Bhosh. The medical tests revealed that the blood of Nihal Ghosh contains strains of Cannabis. Even though sufficient opportunity of six weeks was given to enable the parents to make Nihal Ghosh get out of these habits of using Narcotic drugs, there was no positive improvement. They failed to produce medical certificate from NIMHANS certifying that strains of Cannabis were removed totally from his blood and vein. After 6 weeks lapsed, the Discipline Committee of the school on 17-10-2002 resolved to offer the parents of Nihal Ghosh to suo motu remove him from the school, if they found to do, to send the certificates to them. The school also informed the parents that they could not continue their son in the school for his drug addict and their claim seeking arbitration was not permissible in law. While so, the respondent instituted a suit in O.S.No. 17 of 2003 before the District Munsif-cum-Judicial Magistrate, Kodaikanal for declaration declaring the order of expulsion of the student-plaintiff from the defendant school by a oral order dated 4-9-2002 is illegal, void and unenforceable in law. The plaintiff also prayed for an order of mandatory injunction directing the defendant to permit the plaintiff to attend his 11th grade classes in the defendant's school with all attended benefits. The respondent herein also filed I.A.No.31 of 2003 along with the said suit for mandatory injunction, directing the Kodaikanal International school to admit him in Grade 11 of the school and allow him to continue his education. The learned District Munsif by order dated 6-2-2003, issued a mandatory injunction as claimed. Questionin