The 2nd defendant has filed the appeal. According to the respondents, they belong to a Hindu undivided family and the suit property belongs to them and they were enjoying it under the old patta no.227 new patta no.504. Both the pattas were in the name of the 1st respondent as the Manager of the Joint family. They were also paying kist and nobody else but the respondents have any right in the suit property. They have also enjoyed it for over 45 years and have perfected title by adverse possession. According to the respondents, originally this property belonged to one Appurangan in patta no.286. He sold the property under an oral sale for Rs.75/- in 1920 to one Veeraja Naidu and handed over possession to Veeraja Naidu. Veeraja Naidu's wife was one Thirumalai Ammal and they had a daughter called Andal and a son by name Narayanasamy. Narayanasamy's widow Thayarammal is residing with the respondents. She had no issue. The respondents are the sons of Narayanasamy's sister Andalammal. Andalammal's husband Ramanuja Naidu had some property and on 29.1.1943, Veeraja Naidu's wife Thirumalai Ammal, Thayarammal and Andalammal's husband Ramanuja Naidu executed a settlement deed in fa