SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2002 Supreme(Mad) 901

High Court of Judicature at Madras
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE K. GNANAPRAKASAM
P.Chandrasekaran - Appellant
Versus
A.S.Chinnamuthu and Others - Respondents
C.R.P.(P.D.)No.618 OF 2002 and C.M.P.No.5150 of 2002
Decided On : 04 September 2002

Important Points

The court has the discretion to condone delay in filing an application if the explanation for the delay is reasonable and sufficient. The court must consider the acceptability of the explanation and the interests of justice. The court should also consider the plight of the opposite party and may compensate them for their loss.

Subject

Civil Law - Revision Petition

Act Referred

LIMITATION ACT : S.5

Headnote

Limitation Act - Section 5 - The defendant filed an application under Section 5 of the Limitation Act to condone the delay in filing the application to set aside the exparte decree. The court considered the defendant's explanation for the delay and found it to be reasonable and sufficient. The court also referred to the Supreme Court case of N.Balakrishnan vs M.Krishnamurthy, which stated that the length of delay is not the only criterion for condonation of delay.

Fact of the Case:

The first defendant in a partition suit filed an application to set aside the exparte decree, but there was a delay in filing the application. The defendant claimed that he had engaged an advocate who did not properly defend his case, resulting in the delay. The trial court dismissed the application, but the defendant appealed the decision in a Civil Revision Petition.

Finding of the Court:

The court considered the defendant's claim that he was not properly advised by his advocates and that he only became aware of the exparte decree after it was passed. The court found that the defendant had not taken diligent steps to set aside the decree, but also noted that the defendant had raised certain defenses in his written statement that required consideration. In the interest of justice, the court decided to give the defendant an opportunity to defend the case.

Ratio Decidendi: The court held that the condonation of delay is a matter of discretion and that the length of delay is not the only criterion. The court must consider the acceptability of the explanation for the delay. If the delay is not due to mala fides or a dilatory strategy, the court should show utmost consideration to the litigant. However, the court should also consider the plight of the opposite party and may compensate them for their loss.

Result: The Civil Revision Petition was allowed, and the defendant was directed to pay costs. The trial court was instructed to dispose of the suit as expeditiously as possible.

Advocates Appeared:For the Petitioner:Mr.S.Nicholas, Advocate. For the Respondent:Mr.K.Selvaraj, Advocate.

Judgment :-

This Civil Revision Petition is directed against the fair and decretal order dated 15.10.2001 passed by the Additional Subordinate Judge, Salem, in I.A.No.484/2001 in O.S.No.524/1993.

2. The respondent/plaintiff filed a suit for partition and the revision petitioner is the first defendant in the suit. The first defendant was set exparte on 31.7.1997. Hence, he filed an application to set aside the exparte decree but there is a delay in filing the said petition and application under Section 5 of the Limitation Act was filed to condone the delay and the same was dismissed by the Court below by order dated 15.10.2001 and the same is challenged in this Civil Revision Petition.

3. The petitioner has filed an affidavit in support of the petition to condone the delay wherein he has stated that he had engaged an advocate to defend his case. He has been under the bonafide impression that he is defending the case diligently but the said advocate has shifted his practise to Madras and he was not defending the case of the defendant. Only in August 1999, the first defendant came to know that he was set exparte on 31.7.1997 itself and preliminary decree was passed. An application to pass a final decree was also filed; that thereafter he has engaged another advocate who expressed his inability to file an application to set aside the preliminary decree on the ground that back case papers were not available and therefore he has filed an application in the final decree proceedings to set aside the exparte order passed in the final decree and the said application was dismissed on 18.8.2000; that thereafter the first defendant filed application to set aside the exparte decree passed on 31.7.1997 and there was a delay of 1397 days and application under section 5 of the Limitation Act was filed to condone the delay.

4. The respondent/plaintiff resisted the said application on the ground that the petitioner/first defendant had knowledge about the passing of the preliminary decree at least in 1999 and instead of filing an application to set aside the exparte preliminary decree, he has filed an application to set aside the exparte in the final decree and the same was dismissed; that thereafter only, the defendant filed an application to set aside the exparte preliminary decree and there is absolutely no bonafide on the part of the defendant in not having filed the petition in time. The plaintiff has also stated that only with a view to protract the proceedings, the defendant has filed the petitioner at the belated stage without assigning good and valid reasons.

5. The Trial Court after taking into consideration all the aspects of the case took a view that the defendant remained exparte not only at the time of passing of preliminary decree but also at the time of passing of the final decree and he has not taken any diligent steps to set aside the said decrees. As the reasons offered by the defendant were not sufficient, the trial court dismissed the petition. Aggrieved by the same, the defendant has preferred this Civil Revision Petition.

6. Learned counsel for the petitioner/defendant would contend that he had entrusted the entire matter in the hands of the advocates and the first advocate had shifted his practise to Madras and did not defend the suit diligently and therefore he was set exparte and the preliminary decree was passed on 31.7.1997 but he came to know of the same only in August 1999. The advocate engaged subsequently has also not advised the defendant properly and he has filed an application to set aside the exparte order passed in final decree without filing an application to set aside the exparte decree passed in the preliminary decree. Hence, the application in I.A.No.553/99 came to be dismissed on 18.8.2000; that thereafter only the defendant was advised to file an application to set aside the exparte preliminary decree passed on 31.7.1997 and accordingly an application was filed. In such circumstances, there was a delay in fi






1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top