1996 Supreme(Mad) 405
High Court of Judicature at Madras
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE M. KARPAGAVINAYAGAM
Harichandran - Appellant
Versus
State, Rep. By The S.I. of Police - Respondents
Crl.R.C. No. 843 of 1993 and Crl.R.P. No. 841 of 1993
Decided On : 22 March 1996
Important Points
Subject
Criminal Law - PROCEDURE
Act Referred
INDIAN PENAL CODE : S.379, S.427
TAMIL NADU MINOR MINERAL CONCESSION RULES : R.21
Headnote
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE - SECTION 239 - DISCHARGE - WARRANT CASE - ACCUSED ENTITLED TO FILE APPLICATION FOR DISCHARGE UNDER SECTION 239 CR.P.C., BEFORE FRAMING OF CHARGES - WRONG QUOTING OF SECTION WOULD NOT DISENTITLE THE PETITIONER IN GETTING DISCHARGE FROM THE CRIMINAL CASE TO WHICH HE IS OTHERWISE ENTITLED UNDER SECTION 239 CR.P.C.
Fact of the Case:
The petitioner was charged with offences under Sections 427 and 379 IPC, and Rule 21 of the Tamil Nadu Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 1959. The petitioner filed an application for discharge under Section 258 Cr.P.C., which was dismissed by the lower court on the ground that it was not maintainable. The petitioner challenged the order of the lower court in revision.
Finding of the Court:
The High Court held that the lower court erred in dismissing the discharge petition without going into the merits of the case. The court held that the petitioner was entitled to file an application for discharge under Section 239 Cr.P.C., before framing of the charges, even though he had wrongly quoted Section 258 Cr.P.C. in his application. The court also held that there was no material to prove the charges under Sections 379 and 427 IPC, and therefore, the learned Magistrate was directed to go on with the case against the accused, in respect of the offence under Rule 21 of the Tamil Nadu Minor concession Rules 1959, alone.
Issues: 1. Whether the petitioner was entitled to file an application for discharge under Section 239 Cr.P.C., before framing of the charges, even though he had wrongly quoted Section 258 Cr.P.C. in his application? 2. Whether there was material to prove the charges under Sections 379 and 427 IPC?
Ratio Decidendi: 1. The court held that the petitioner was entitled to file an application for discharge under Section 239 Cr.P.C., before framing of the charges, even though he had wrongly quoted Section 258 Cr.P.C. in his application. The court relied on the fact that the petitioner had prayed for 'discharge' in his petition, and that the wrong quoting of the section would not disentitle him from getting discharge from the criminal case to which he was otherwise entitled under Section 239 Cr.P.C. 2. The court held that there was no material to prove the charges under Sections 379 and 427 IPC, as the prosecution had admitted that the land in question belonged to the petitioner and that he was in possession of the same.
Final Decision: The High Court partly allowed the revision petition and directed the learned Magistrate to dispose the matter as expeditiously as possible, since the matter relates to the year 1990.
This revision has been directed against the order passed in Crl.M.P. No. 4685/1992 in C.C. No. 382 of 1992, on the file of Judicial Magistrate No. 1, Kuzhithurai.
2. The Petitioner Harichandran, son of Joseph is the accused in CC No. 382 of 1992, on the file of Judicial Magistrate No. 1, Kuzhithurai on the charge sheet filed by the respondent/Police, Kaliakkavilai Police Station, Kanyakumari district, for the offences under Section 427 and 379 I.P.C. and Rule 21 of the Tamil Nadu Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 1959.
3. Copies of documents were furnished to the petitioner/accused. Thereafter an application has been filed by the petitioner in CC No. 382 of 1992, for discharge, contending that he is the absolute owner of the Six acres of patta land in S. Nos. 507/1, 507/2, and 507/3 in Vilsvancode village, Edapilankad, Madichal, Kanyakumari District, and that he is an agricuturist, doing agricultural work and of the six acres only three acres are cultivable and the rest of the area could not be cultivated, in view of the density of rocks and that these rocks were removed from the area and used as fencing material. He also contended in the said petition, that the petitioner has taken loan from the agricultural Co-operative Society, for land reclamation and for agricultural production in the above said lands and that the petitioner owns properties in Nullicoud and Pedamthalamoodu in Old S. No. 1064 and 1152 and when the petitioner tried to remove rocks and for using it for his own purpose, the respondent filed the said criminal case and that the charge sheet along with the papers filed by the police itself would show that the property belonged to the petitioner and as such, removal of rocks from his own lands would not be said to be the offences under Sections 427 and 379 I.P.C., and Rule 21 of Tamil Nadu Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 1959.
4. This application in the lower Court was objected to by the prosecution on the ground that application filed under Section 258 Cr.P.C. is misconceived, since Section 258 Cr.P.C. will be applicable only to summons case, that too, for stopping the proceedings, whereas this is a warrant case and the police has filed the charge sheet and as such, the application could not be entertained.
5. On the basis of the above objection, the learned Judicial Magistrate No. 1, Kuzhithurai, with out going through the merits of the case, simply dismissed, it on the ground that the application was not maintainable.
6. I have heard the learned Counsel appearing on either side.
7. One important aspect has been over looked by the Court below viz., in warrant cases, where police filed chargesheet the accused/petitioner is entitled to file an application for discharge under Section 239 Cr.P.C., before framing of the charges. A perusal of the petition filed by the petitioner before the lower court would show, that his prayer in the petition is only 'discharge'. But instead of putting the appropriate Section, viz. Sec. 239 Cr.P.C. he has put a wrong Section viz. Sec. 258 Cr.P.C. which relates to summon cases. Wrong quoting of Section would not got disentitle the petitioner in getting discharge from the criminal case to which he is otherwise entitled under Section 239 Cr.P.C. So, I am of the view, that the petition filed for discharge by the petitioner, before the lower court is to be considered on merits and the order of the lower Court, accepting the contention of the prosecution cannot be said to be valid.
8. The next question that arises for consideration is whether there are any materials to show that charges could be framed for the offences under Sections 427 and 379 I.P.C., and Rule 21 of the Tamil Nadu Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 1959. The facts of the case are that on and before 17-8-1990, at Edapanamkala, the petitioner/accused Harichandran with an intention to cause wrongful loss to Government, without obtaining permission from the Government, illegally quarried from his land and transported rocks