1988 Supreme(Mad) 272
High Court of Judicature at Madras
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SRINIVASAN
Rajapalayan Industrial and Commercial Syndicate Ltd. and Another - Appellant
Versus
K.A. Vairaprakasam and Another - Respondent
Case No : C.R.P. 1514 of 1988
Decided On : 19 July 1988
Important Points
Subject
Civil Law - Injunctions
Act Referred
Headnote
INJUNCTION - ORDER XXXIX RULE 3 C.P.C. - ORDER XXXIX RULE 3-A C.P.C. - SUMMARY
Fact of the Case:
The petitioner challenged an ad interim ex parte injunction order passed by the trial court without recording reasons for granting the injunction without notice to the opposite party, in violation of Order XXXIX Rule 3 C.P.C. The injunction had the effect of paralysing the work of a company.
Finding of the Court:
The court found that the trial court had failed to comply with the provisions of Order XXXIX Rule 3 C.P.C., which requires the court to record reasons for granting an injunction without notice to the opposite party. The court also noted that the injunction had the effect of paralysing the affairs of the company and affecting the interests of third parties.
Issues: Whether the trial court erred in granting an ad interim injunction without recording reasons for doing so, in violation of Order XXXIX Rule 3 C.P.C.
Ratio Decidendi: The court held that the trial court had erred in granting the injunction without recording reasons, in violation of Order XXXIX Rule 3 C.P.C. The court further held that the injunction had the effect of paralysing the affairs of the company and affecting the interests of third parties.
Final Decision: The court dismissed the revision petition, but directed the subordinate judiciary to adhere strictly to the provisions of the Civil Procedure Code in future in the matter of granting orders of injunction.
This revision petition is against an order passed on 26-5-1988 by the Vacation Civil Judge in I.A. 697 of 1988. It is, no doubt, an ad interim ex parte order and a revision petition is not ordinarily maintainable in this court. Normally, this court does not entertain a revision petition against an ad interim injunction, when the court below has passed the same and has ordered notice to the other side. The normal course open to the opposite party in such a case is to approach the same court for vacating the injuction order or passing appropriate order as laid down by a Division Bench of this court in Abdul Shukoor Sahib v. Umachandran 1976 AIR(Mad) 350.
2. However, learned counsel for the petitioner points out that the order of interim injunction made by the trial court in this case is in complete violation of the provisions of Order XXXIX Rule 3, C.P.C. When the Civil Procedure Code was amended in 1976 by Act 104 of 1976, a proviso was introduced in Order XXXIX Rule 3, whereby when a court proposes to grant an injunction without giving notice of the application to the opposite party, the Court shall record reasons for its decision that the object of granting the injunction would be defeated by delay and require the applicant to comply with certain conditions set out therein.
3. Unfortunately, the members of the Subordinate judiciary do not take care to adjure to the rule contained either in the proviso to Rule 3-A. Recently, I had an occasion to interview certain temporary District Munsiffs for the selection of District Munsifs. I had questioned each one of the persons who had acted as temporary District Munsif, whether he was aware of Order XXXIX Rules 3 and 3-A C.P.C. and I found to my dismay, that none was able to answer that question. None of them was aware of the contents of these two rules. That position seems to be prevailing even with the subordinate Judges. The proceeding from which this revision has arisen is dealt with by a Subordinate Judge who has functioned as vacation civil Judge.
4. In this case, he has ordered an ad interim injunction till 21-6-1988 without recording any reason for granting the temporary injunction without giving notice to the opposite side or hearing the opposite side. This is in violation of the procedure prescribed by Order XXXIX Rule 3 C.P.C. It is very unfortunate that a Subordinate Judge should ignore the provisions of the Civil Procedure Code, while passing orders in a matter like this. Particularly in this case, the order of interim injunction has the effect of paralysing the work of a company. The allegations made in the affidavit filed in support of the application for injunction are to the effect that defendants 2 and 3 in the suit had ceased to be Directors of the Company somewhere in 1986 or 1987. The suit has been filed only on 25-5-1988. The cause of action for the suit is said to be a notice dated 2-5-1988 calling for an annual general meeting of the company to be held on 27-5-1988. The notice was admittedly received by the plaintiff on 4-5-1988. The suit is filed by a shareholder. The suit is filed 21 days after the receipt of the notice of the annual general meeting and by the application for interim injunction the plaintiff prayed for a direction restraining respondents 2 and 3, who are two of the three directors of the company, not only from convening the general body, meeting on 27-5-1988 but also from operating the Bank account or acting is directors. On 26-5-1988 the learned Subordinate Judge passed an order granting ad interim injunction. By granting that injunction, he had restrained defendants 2 and 3, who are two of the three directors of the company, from not only calling for the General Body meeting but also from operating Bank account or in any way acting as directors of the first defendant company. Even assuming that the holding of the General Body meeting should have been stopped without issuing notice to the defendants, there was no justification for p