1978 Supreme(Mad) 86
High Court of Judicature at Madras
THE HONOURABLE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. P GOVINDAN NAIR, THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SETHURAMAN & THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE V. RAMASWAMI
Additional Commissioner of Income Tax, Tamil Nadu I - Appellant
Versus
K. S. Sheik Mohideen - Respondent
Case No : Tax Case No. 398 of 1974
Decided On : 02 February 1978
P. GOVINDAN NAIR C.J.
In relation to the assessment year 1967-68, of an individual assessee, the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal has referred the following question to this court for our opinion :
"Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, it has been rightly held that there would be no liability to capital gains tax on the sale of import entitlement certificates in the assessee's case ?" *
The facts necessary for answering this question had been stated in paragraph 2 of the statement of the case which we reproduce.
The assessee made remittances under the National Defence Remittance Scheme and such remittances earned import entitlements which were sold by the assessee resulting in a profit of Rs. 19, 974. The Income-tax Officer assessed the entire amount of Rs. 19, 974 to capital gains tax. The decision was upheld in appeal by the Appellate Assistant Commissioner. But in further appeal before the Tribunal it was ruled that there was no capital gains liable to be taxed. The question is whether the view taken by the Tribunal is right in law.
The decision of the Tribunal is fully supported by two decisions of this court. The first one settling the principle dealing with goodwill has also considered the question of "capital gains" on the sale or transfer of "goodwill". The decision is in Commissioner of Income-tax v. K. Rathnam Nadar The identical question that is before us relating to "import entitlement" was considered by this court in Commissioner of Income-tax v. T. Kuppuswamy Pillai & Co. and following the earlier decision of this court it was held that unless the asset had cost something in terms of money for its acquisition, it was not possible to conceive of capital gains as envisaged by the statute, that though an asset of a capital nature had been transferred, capital gains as visualised by the statute had not resulted and that no tax on that basis was, therefore, leviable. The view taken by this court has been accepted and followed by a number of other decisions. A Full Bench of the Kerala High Court considered this question in some detail in Commissioner of Income-tax v. E. C. Jacob and followed the view taken by this court. The Delhi High Court has also accepted the view taken by this court in Jagdev Singh Mumick v. Commissioner of Income-tax The Karnataka High Court did the same thing in the decision in Commissioner of Income-tax v. B. C. Srinivasa Setty 1974 ITR 667.Both the decisions of the Kerala High Court and the Karnataka High Court have also adverted to the possibility of another view that can be taken in the matter and came to the conclusion, for the reasons stated in the judgments, which we will be referring to presently, that there is no need to take a different view from that which had been taken by the Madras High Court, followed by a number of other High Courts in India.
The Calcutta High Court, recently, though it had taken a different view earlier, and the Gujarat High Court have taken a different view from that taken by this court. The recent decision of the Calcutta High Court is K. N. Dftary v. Commissioner of Income-tax v. Mohanbhai Pamabhai.
Before we proceed to consider these conflicting views, one taken by a large majority of courts, which has stood the test of time in that it had remained without being overruled or without being not accepted by the Supreme Court for nearly ten years, and the other taken by the Calcutta High Court and the Gujarat High Court in the decisions referred to above, we would like to refer to the sections of the statute with which we are concerned. "Capital gains" is dealt with in section 45 of the Income-tax Act, 1961, which we shall refer to as the Act hereinafter, and is more or less a definition of the term, and the section reads thus :
"45. Capital gains. - Any profits or gains arising from the transfer of a capital asset effected in the previous year shall, save as otherwise provided in sections 53, 54, 54B, 54C and 54D, be chargeable to incom