SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

1974 Supreme(Mad) 23

Madras High Court
SOMASUNDARAM
C.R.Corera and Bros. - Appellant
Versus
Chief Secretary, Govt.of Pondicherry - Respondent
Decided On : 01/18/1974

Important Points

A decree passed under Order XVII, Rule 3, Civil P. C. is appealable and the remedy of the party aggrieved can be only by way of appeal.

Subject

Civil Law - DECREES AND ORDERS

Act Referred

CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE : O.9 R.13, O.17 R.3

Headnote

CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE - ORDER XVII, RULE 3 - DECREE PASSED UNDER - APPEAL IS THE ONLY REMEDY - ORDER IX, RULE 13 - NOT APPLICABLE.

Fact of the Case:

The petitioner, a firm, had taken on lease several units of machinery, instruments, godown, etc. from the Port Department attached to the Government of Pondicherry. The firm had to pay Rs. 27,495.74 as arrears in respect of the above leases. The Chief Secretary to the Government of Pondicherry filed a suit against the defendant in the year 1970, viz., O. S. No. 18 of 1970, for recovering this amount with interest. The petitioner denied his liability to pay the amount and pleaded set-off stating that by way of demurrage he was entitled to about Rs. 80,000.

Finding of the Court:

The court held that the decree passed on 21-8-1972 was one under Order XVII, Rule 3, Civil P. C. and not an ex parte decree attracting Order IX, Rule 13, Civil P. C. The court found that the petitioner had been granted several adjournments at his request for adducing evidence, but he had failed to do so. The court also found that the petitioner had not even chosen to deny its liability when notices of demand were issued by the Government of Pondicherry claiming the amount involved in the suit.

Issues: Whether the decree passed on 21-8-1972 was one under Order XVII, Rule 3, Civil P. C. or an ex parte decree attracting Order IX, Rule 13, Civil P. C.

Ratio Decidendi: The court held that the decree passed on 21-8-1972 was one under Order XVII, Rule 3, Civil P. C. because the suit was adjourned at the request of the petitioner for adducing evidence and he had failed to do so on the adjournment date. The court also found that the petitioner's advocate was present on the adjournment date and that the learned Additional District Judge had gone into the merits of the case and rightly decreed the claim.

Final Decision: The court dismissed the appeal with costs.

Advocates:
N. Srivatsamani and A. Nageswaran, for Appellant; Govt. Pleader, for Respondent.

JUDGMENT :- The appellant-firm had taken on lease several units of machinery, instruments, godown etc. from the Port Department attached to the Government of Pondicherry. The firm had to pay Rs. 27,495.74 as arrears in respect of the above leases. The Chief Secretary to the Government of Pondicherry filed a suit against the defendant in the year 1970, viz., O. S. No. 18 of 1970, for recovering this amount with interest. The petitioner denied his liability to pay the amount and pleaded set-off stating that by way of demurrage he was entitled to about Rs. 80,000.

2. The suit was posted for trial on 20-10-1970. The advocate who appeared for the petitioner filed an application for adjournment, producing medical certificate. The matter was adjourned to 2-12-1970. On that date, the representation was that the petitioner (partner representing the firm) had a heart attack. The suit was then adjourned to 21-12-1970. On further request it was adjourned to 8-1-1971 for trial. On that date, the petitioner's advocate reported no instructions and the petitioner being absent, was set ex parte. On 11-1-1971, P. W. 1 was examined on the side of the plaintiff for proving the claim, and the suit was decreed.

3. The petitioner then filed I. A. No. 35 of 1971 for setting aside this ex parte decree. This was done. The suit was restored to file on 5-4-1971. It was posted to 14-6-1971 for trial. Several adjournments were granted. Eventually, the suit stood posted to 19-6-1972 for trial. The petitioner then represepted to the court that he had approached the Government for settlement and on that ground he wanted ten days time. This was granted. The suit was posted to 3-7-1972 at the instance of the petitioner for getting on with the trial. On 3-7-1972, he again filed a petition for adjournment stating that he will get on with the trial on the next bearing. This petition was allowed on payment of costs of Rs. 20/-. On 7-8-1972 costs was paid, but the petitioner's advocate reported unreadiness. The suit stood posted to this day for producing evidence. Since the petitioner defaulted, the learned Second Additional District Judge, Pondichery, took up the matter for consideration and reserved orders till 21-8-1972. On that date, on a consideration of the evidence and materials which were available, he observed that the plaintiff had filed six demand notices calling upon the petitioner to pay the amount and that the latter had not even chosen to send a reply denying liability. Holding that there was no merit in the counter-claim and stating that the petitioner had not produced any evidence for substantiating it, the learned District Judge decreed, under Order XVII, Rule 3, Civil P. C. the claim as made by the plaintiff.

4. Subsequently, the petitioner filed I. A. No. 926 of 1973 under O. IX, R. 13, Civil P. C. requesting the Court to set aside the ex parte decree passed against him on 21-8-1972. The learned Judge heard the counsel and rejected this application, stating that the decree passed on 21-8-1972 was one under Order XVII, Rule 3, Civil P. C.

5. The correctness of this order is now canvassed by the petitioner in this revision.

6. Mr. Srivatsamani learned counsel appearing for the petitioner, contends that the decree passed on 21-8-1972 is not one under Order XVII, Rule 3, Civil P. C. but only an ex parte decree attracting Order IX, Rule 13, Civil P. C. This matter has had chequered career from the year 1970. On the move of the petitioner, the court had adjourned the suit on several occasions for adducing evidence. Once before, the suit was decreed ex parte on 11-1-1971. P. W. 1 was examined on that date for proving the claim. Thereupon the petitioner filed I. A. No. 35 of 1971 for setting aside the ex parte decree. This was allowed. The suit was posted to 19-6-1972. Several adjournments were granted at the request of the petitioner. On 3-7-1972, the petitioner filed an application for adjournment requesting for time for getting on with the trial. This w







1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top