SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

1971 Supreme(Mad) 543

Madras High Court
RAMANUJAM
Papammal (died) - Appellant
Versus
K.Kuppuswamy - Respondent
Decided On : 08/10/1971

Important Points

A devise in favour of a person with powers of alienation will be construed as an absolute interest, while a devise in favour of a person without powers of alienation will be construed as a life interest.

Subject

Property Law - WILLS

Act Referred

SUCCESSION ACT : S.124, S.88

Headnote

WILL - CONSTRUCTION - VESTED INTEREST - DEVISE IN FAVOUR OF GRANDDAUGHTERS - ABSOLUTE INTEREST - DEVISE IN FAVOUR OF DAUGHTER-IN-LAW - LIFE INTEREST - DIFFERENCE IN PHRASEOLOGY - INTENTION OF TESTATOR.

Fact of the Case:

The plaintiff filed a suit for a declaration that his mother had acquired a vested interest in the suit properties under the terms of the will executed by his maternal grandfather, Ramana Gounder, and that he had inherited the said vested right on the death of his mother. The defendants resisted the suit contending that the will gave an absolute right to the first defendant in the suit properties and that the plaintiff had not acquired any vested interest in the suit properties under the will of Ramana Gounder.

Finding of the Court:

The court held that the plaintiff acquired a vested interest in the suit properties under the will of Ramana Gounder dated 12-12-1929. The court found that the testator used a different phraseology in respect of the two devises which he had made in favour of the daughter-in-law and the other in favour of the granddaughters. While referring to the daughter-in-law the testator says that she is to enter into possession of the properties and enjoy the same. But while referring to the rights which the granddaughters are to get he expresses the intention that they should enjoy all the properties with powers of alienation.

Issues: Whether the plaintiff acquired a vested interest in the suit properties under the will of Ramana Gounder dated 12-12-1929.

Ratio Decidendi: The court held that the devise in favour of the first defendant was not an absolute one. The court relied on the following principles in reaching its decision: * The intention of the testator is to be found from the language used by him and all the parts of the will are to be considered with reference to each other so as, if possible, to form one consistent whole. * Where two kinds of dispositions are found, the first creating an absolute estate and the second a gift over after lifetime of the donee of the estate, the language of the will has to be considered to find out the predominent intention of the testator. * The death of the first defendant is a certain event and its reference does not import any contingency as it is only a euphuism to denote the time of the first defendant's death.

Final Decision: The court dismissed the second appeal and upheld the decree of the lower appellate court.

Advocates:
S. Ramalingam, for Appellants; T. R. Ramachandran and T. R. Rajagopal, for Respondent.

JUDGMENT :- The defendants in O. S. No. 278 of 1964 on the file of the Sub-Court, Coimbatore, are the appellants. The respondent-plaintiff filed the suit for a declaration that his mother Poovathal had acquired a vested interest in the suit properties under the terms of the will dated 12-12-1929 executed by his maternal grandfather, one Ramana Gounder, that he has inherited the said vested right on the death of his mother and that the will dated 4-8-1964 executed by the first defendant in favour of the second defendant as though she had an absolute right over the property was not valid and binding on him.

2. The defendants resisted the suit contending that the will dated 12-12-1929, executed by Ramana Gounder gave an absolute right to the first defendant in the suit properties, that the first defendant could dispose of the same by her will dated 4-8-1964, and that the plaintiff had not acquired any vested interest in the suit properties under the will of Ramana Gounder.

3. The trial court held that the plaintiff did not acquire any vested interest under the will of Ramana Gounder dated 12-12-1929. The lower appellate court, however, disagreed with the trial court and passed a decree in favour of the plaintiff upholding his case that he acquired a vested interest in the suit properties under the said will.

4. In this second appeal the defendants contend that the view taken by the lower appellate court is erroneous and that the view taken by the trial court is the correct one.

5. The suit properties originally belonged to the family of Ramana Gounder. He had an only son, Chinnappa Gounder. The first defendant is the wife of the said Chinnappa Gounder. Chinnappa Gounder had two daughters, the second defendant Pappammal and the plaintiff's mother Poovathal. The third defendant is the husband of the second defendant. After the death of Chinnappa Gounder, Ramana Gounder executed a will dated 12-12-1929. According to the plaintiff under the will the first defendant was given a right to enjoy the suit properties, with a vested remainder in favour of the plaintiff's mother and the second defendant, each being entitled to a half. According to the defendants the will had given an absolute right in favour of the first defendant with no vested interest in favour of the daughters. The properties covered by the will dated 12-12-1929 are about 15 acres of garden lands with electric meter and pump set etc. in addition to houses and sheds. The same properties have been bequeathed by the first defendant under her will Ex. B-1 dated 4-8-1964 in favour of her daughter, the second defendant, purporting to deal with the property as an absolute owner. Thus the main question relates to the construction of the will Ex. A-1 dated 12-12-1929.

6. A perusal of the will shows that the testator has addressed the will to his widowed daughter-in-law, Kaliakkal, the first defendant. It recites that after the death of the testator, Kaliakkal should enter into possession and enjoy the properties that she should discharge the debts of the testator, if any, that she should continue to maintain a thanneer pandal dharmam in the local Pilliar koil at a cost of not less than Rs. 100 per year from the income of the properties, that that 'thanneer pandal dharmam' should continue even after her lifetime and that whoever gets the properties after her lifetime and whoever may be in possession of the properties by virtue of any alienation, are bound to continue the dharmam as aforesaid. The will further directs that after the lifetime of Kaliakkal her daughters. Pappammal and Poovathal, should get the properties absolutely. The devise in favour of the first defendant is as follows:

* * * * *

Regarding the devise in favour of the two granddaughters the terms are as follows :

* * * * *

Thus, it is seen that the testator used a different phraseology in respect of the two devises which he had made in favour of the daughter-in-law and the other in favour of the granddaughters. While refe



















1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top