1980 2 MLJ 398
S. Padmanabhan, J.
K.M. Madhavakrishnan
Versus
S.R. Sami And Ors.
Decided on: 5/2/1980
App. No. 928 of 1975
S. Padmanabhan, J.
1. The Additional plaintiff in O.S. No. 71 of. 1968, who is the son and legal representative of Paramayee Animal, the deceased first plaintiff, is the appellant. Paramayee Ammal having died pending suit, her son the appellant was brought on record as her legal representative. Paramayee Ammal filed the suit for a declaration that the agreement of sale executed by her in favour of defendants 1 and 2 on 17th June, 1967 was void and inoperative and for other reliefs. The suit was dismissed by the trial Court and consequently the present appeal has been filed.
2. The facts of the case may be briefly set out as follows : One Marimuthu Pillai, the husband of Paramayee Animal was the owner of an extent of 4.04 acres of land comprised in T.S. No. 1332 in Erode Town. Marimuthu Pillai died in 1953 leaving two widows one of whom was Paramayee Ammal and two sons Venugopal and Rajagopal through his first wife and a son Madhavakrishnan, the appellant herein and a daughter Lakshmi though his second wife Paramayee Ammal. On the death of Marimuthu Pillai disputes arose between the first plaintiff on the one hand and her son, the second plaintiff and step-sons on the other. The deceased first plaintiff was living separately in Vellala Street in Erode while her sons were living in Kaveri Street. The second plaintiff filed O.S. No. 111 of 1954 on the file of the Sub-Court, Coimbatore for partition and recovery of his share in the suit property. In that suit a preliminary decree was passed and pursuant to the preliminary decree an interim final decree was passed on 19th November, 1954, by which the suit property was allotted to the deceased first plaintiff Paramayee Ammal. Purusuant to the interim final decree, the deceased first plaintiff took possession of the suit property. On 14th May, 1966 the deceased first plaintiff leased out the suit property to defendants 3 and 4 under Exhibit B-16. Pursuant to the lease, defendants 3 and 4 were enjoying the property. Besides the suit property, the deceased first plaintiff had other properties which were yielding considerable income. While so, the second defendant who was a relation and employee under Marimuthu Pillai pretended that he was very much interested in the welfare of the deceased first plaintiff and taking advantage of the strained relationship between her and her sons, gained her confidence. The result was that he was put in charge of the collection of rents, letting out the properties etc., on behalf of the deceased first plaintiff and she was acting as per his suggestions and instructions in routine matters for nearly fifteen years. While so, defendants 3 and 4 were not paying rents properly to the deceased first plaintiff and they fell into heavy arrears. They were not willing to surrender possession either. At the same time, they had inducted a number of persons as subtenants. The second defendant therefore informed the deceased first plaintiff that the first defendant who owned a turmeric mandi and a theatre was a very influential man of the locality. He further suggested that if a document was created in trust in the name of the first defendant with suitable recitals it would intimidate and induce defendants 3 and 4 and their sub-tenants to surrender possession of the property. The second defendant is said to have further stated that if the fact of the execution of such document is circulated in the locality, her son, step-sons and other members of the family would come forward to take effective steps to get defendants 3 and 4 evicted from the suit property. The deceased first plaintiff, without realising the import and impact of the, suggestion of the second defendant and placing great reliance on the confidence she had in him, agreed to the proposal. Accordingly, on 17th June, 1967 an agreement purporting to convey the suit property of an extent of 4.04 acres in T.S. No. 1232 in Erode Town to defendants 1 and 2 was got up by the second defendant. The agreement
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.