1998 Supreme(Mad) 959
High Court of Judicature at Madras
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE K. GOVINDARAJAN
S.Rajini and another
Versus
The idol of Arulmigu Panchavaneswaraswamy Koil Devasthanam, rep. by its Executive Officer, Woriyur, Tiruchirapalli 620003 and another.
C.R.P.S.R. No. 42039 of 1998 and C.M.P.S.R. Nos. 42041, 42042 and 43080 of 1998
Decided On : 21-07-1998
Important Points
Subject
Civil Law - ARTICLE 227 - MAINTAINABILITY OF REVISION PETITION
Act Referred
Headnote
CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE - ARTICLE 227 - MAINTAINABILITY OF REVISION PETITION - IMPLEADING LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES - NULLITY OF DECREE - JURISDICTION OF HIGH COURT - SUO MOTU EXERCISE OF POWER.
Fact of the Case:
Petitioners filed a revision petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India to set aside a judgment and decree passed in a suit, alleging that the decree was a nullity as all the legal representatives of the deceased defendant were not impleaded.
Finding of the Court:
The court held that the revision petition was not maintainable as the petitioners had not filed a certified copy of the judgment and decree, and also on merits, as the decree was not a nullity since one of the legal heirs of the deceased defendant had been impleaded.
Issues: 1. Whether the revision petition was maintainable without filing a certified copy of the judgment and decree? 2. Whether the decree was a nullity due to non-impleadment of all the legal representatives of the deceased defendant?
Ratio Decidendi: 1. The court relied on the Supreme Court decision in Surinder Singh v. Central Govt., which held that it is mandatory to produce the impugned orders when seeking to quash them, and that without producing the same, a writ cannot be issued. 2. The court also relied on the Supreme Court decisions in Mohd Sulaiman v. Mohd.Ismail, Dolai Maliko v. Krushna Chandra, and Harihar Prasad V.Balmiki Prasad, which held that where a plaintiff or an appellant after diligent and bona fide enquiry ascertains who the legal representatives of a deceased defendant or respondent are and brings them on record within the time limited by law, there is no abatement of the suit or appeal, and the decision obtained with them on record will bind not merely those impleaded but the entire estate including those not brought on record.
Final Decision: The court dismissed the revision petition as not maintainable and rejected the connected miscellaneous petitions.
Mr.R.Karuppan, Advocate for Petitioners.
1. The Petitioners have filed the above C.R.P.S.R.No.42039 of 1998 to set aside the judgment and decree in O.S.No.2094 of 1984, dated 8. 1996. The said C.R.P.S.R.Number was filed on 26. 1998. The Registry returned the papers to clarify the doubt about the maintainability. The following reasons are given by the Registry:-
(1) It may be stated how C.R.P. under Article 227 of Constitution filed by the petitioners herein, who are not parties in the lower court, without availing appeal remedy in the lower/appellate court, is maintainable in High Court?
(2) It may be stated against which proceedings the C.R.P. has been filed; preamble portion needs correction in this regard;
(3) certified copy of decree and judgment in C.C.No.2094 of 1984 not filed;
(4) certified copy of petition in E.P.No.818 of 1997 not filed;
(5) prayer needs revision in C.M.P.S.R. No.42041 since two proceedings may not be stayed in one stay petition.
2. The learned counsel appearing for the petitioners has clarified the position with respect to the doubts raised by the Registry. Not satisfied with the said clarification, it is posted before the Court to decide about the maintainability of the revision.
3. The first doubt that has been raised by the Registry is, since the petitioners want to set aside the judgment and decree in O.S.No.2094 of 1984, they cannot file the revision without even filing the copy of the same. The learned counsel has submitted that the petitioners are not parties to the said judgment and decree and so they cannot be expected to file the same. Further he has submitted that the petitioners applied for the judgment and decree but, so far, they have not been furnished to them, and, in view of the urgency they have filed the above revision. I am not able to accept both the submissions. It is well settled that without even filing the judgment and decree, they cannot maintain the Revision.
4. The Apex Court has held that it is mandatory on the part of the petitioner to produce the impugned orders when the petitioner is seeking to quash the impunged orders. Without producing the same, writ cannot be issued. The Apex Court in Surinder Singh v. Central Govt., 1986 (4) S.C.C. 670 has held as follows:
"Normally whenever an order of Government or some authority is impugned before the High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution, the copy of the order must be produced before it. In the absence of the impugned order it would not be possible to ascertain the reasons which may have impelled the authority to pass the order. It is therefore improper to quash an order which is not produced before the High Court in a proceeding under Article 226 of the Constitution."
In view of the above settled law the objection that has been raised by the office has to be sustained. Without even producing the copy of the judgment and decree, the petitioners cannot maintain the revision.
5. The petitioners have filed C.M.P.S.R. No.43080 of 1998 to dispense with the certified copy of the judgment and decree. In the affidavit filed in support of the petition it is not even stated that the petitioners have applied for the same and the court below has not furnished the same. Without taking any steps to get the certified copy of the judgment and decree, which the petitioners want to set aside, the petitioners cannot be allowed to file the above Revision. Further, to appreciate the case of the petitioners, those documents are absolutely necessary. Without producing the same, the correctness of the contentions cannot be looked into.
6. On merits the learned counsel appearing for the petitioners has submitted that the petitioners are the heirs of the deceased defendant Subramania Pillai. He died on 30.1.1985, pending the suit. The plaintiff filed an application to implead one son Kadirvelu as his legal heir. Since no objection was raised for the same, that petition was ordered. Subsequently the suit was decreed ex parte. At this stage, the petitioners have