SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

1996 Supreme(Mad) 343

High Court of Judicature at Madras
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE S.S. SUBRAMANI
Pappammal (Died) and Others
Versus
Valiammai (Died) and Others
S.A.No.1924 of 1982
Decided On : 08-03-1996

Important Points

Burden of proof lies on the defendant to prove adverse possession over entire property.

Subject

Property Law - Adverse Possession

Act Referred

CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE : O.20 R.12

Headnote

Adverse Possession-Defendant being in possession of a portion of the property can not claim possession over entire property-Burden of proof lies on the defendant.

       

       

Advocates:
E.Padmanabhan, for Appellants. V.K.Muthuswami and Peppin Fernando, for Respondents.

Judgment :

Plaintiff who filed O.S. No. 256 of 1966, on the file of the District Munsif s Court, Karur, died during the pendency of the suit, and plaintiffs 2 to 5 were impleaded as additional plaintiffs. Of them, after the filing of this second appeal, plaintiffs 2 and 3 died and appellants 5 to 7 herein have been impleaded.

2. The suit was one for declaration of title and recovery of possession of C Schedule property, mentioned in the plaint. A plan is also appended.

3. Relevant facts which are necessary for the proper disposal of this second appeal are as follows: Plaint A Schedule Property is having an area of nearly 3 acres. The said property along with other properties were purchased by the original plaintiff under Ex.A-1, dated 11. 1946. The original plaintiff paid a consideration of Rs.25,000. It is said that he obtained physical possession of the entire property. The plaint C Schedule property is a portion of A Schedule, which is situated on the north western portion of the entire A Schedule property. As per allegations in the plaint, the C Schedule property has got an extent of 20 x 18 sq. ft. It is also stated that B and D Schedule items are portions of A Schedule. It is said that in so far as the D Schedule item is concerned, which is situated on the southern side of C Schedule, the defendants trespassed 17 years back and have put up a construction. In so far as B Schedule is concerned, plaintiffs allege that they are in physical possession. It is also averred that sometime in October, 1959, a suit notice was issued by the original plaintiff stating the illegal acts committed by the defendants and wanted them to surrender the trespassed area. At that time, there was some mediation through panchayat. Then, the defendants had also trespassed into the C Schedule property. That was in the year 1959. The mediation was accepted by both the parties, and the defendants agreed that in so far as C Schedule Item was concerned, they will pay a monthly rent of Rs.10 and that they were paying that amount till December, 1962. Thereafter, they committed default in paying the rent. Finally suit notice was issued in 1964 seeking possession of C Schedule property. The defendants also sent a reply denying the mediation and also the rental arrangement insofar as the C Schedule property was concerned.. They also denied the title of the plaintiff. Therefore, the plaintiff filed the suit for declaration of plaintiff’ s title over C Schedule and for recovery of possession with mesne profits.

4. In the written statement filed by the defendant, he contended that the plaintiff had no title over A Schedule property. He also denied the alleged mediation in 1959. Insofar as the notice issued in 1959, he did not answer the same, but said that he does not remember to have sent any reply to the notice dated 10. 1959. He also denied the rental arrangement. In paragraphs 7 and 10 of the written statement, he said that he had been and continues to be in possession of the entire A Schedule, long before 1949 and he has perfected his right, title and interest and possession to the suit property by adverse possession and prescription. He further said that the plaintiff is not entitled to recovery of possession.

5. On the above pleadings, the parties went on trial.

6. Before the trial court, Exs. A-1 to A-8 were marked and the 5th plaintiff was examined as P.W.I. Three other witnesses were also examined, on the side of the plaintiffs, including the Commissioner who was deputed during trial, and also the Karnam of the Village. On the side of the defendant, two witnesses were examined and Exs.B-1 to B84 were marked. D.W. 1 is the brother of the defendant and D.W.2 is a Block Extension Educator.

7. After evaluating the entire evidence, the trial court came to the conclusion that the plaintiff has proved his title to the property, and that the defendant has not proved his prescriptive right over the C Schedule property, and the suit was decreed appending t
















































1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top