SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

1996 Supreme(Mad) 1071

High Court of Judicature at Madras
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE P. SATHASIVAM
M/s.R.R. Techno Mechanicals (P) Ltd. and another
Versus
Democratic Labour Union
C.R.P.Nos.2005 of 1995 and 2024 of 1995 and C.M.Ps. Nos.11119, 11120, 11247 and 11248 of 1995
Decided On : 18-10-1996

Important Points

Where a dispute relates to enforcement of rights or obligations created under the Industrial Disputes Act, the only remedy is under the Act to get adjudicated and the Civil Court is barred from going into such proceedings. An interim injunction cannot be granted without recording reasons as per Order 39, Rule 3, C.P.C.

Subject

Industrial Disputes - JURISDICTION OF CIVIL COURT

Act Referred

CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE : O.39 R.3

Headnote

INDUSTRIAL DISPUTES ACT - JURISDICTION OF CIVIL COURT - ENFORCEMENT OF RIGHTS AND OBLIGATIONS CREATED UNDER THE ACT - REMEDY LIES ONLY IN THE ACT - INTERIM INJUNCTION - MANDATORY PROVISIONS OF ORDER 39, RULE 3, C.P.C. - REASONS FOR GRANTING INJUNCTION WITHOUT NOTICE TO BE RECORDED - NON-COMPLIANCE - ORDER LIABLE TO BE SET ASIDE.

Fact of the Case:

Defendant in O.S.No.430 of 1995 and O.S.No.127 of 1995 on the file of District Munsif, Poonamallee, aggrieved by the orders granting interim injunctions, filed C.R.P.Nos.2005 of 1995 and 2024 of 1995 respectively under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.

Finding of the Court:

1. Where a dispute relates to enforcement of rights or obligations created under the Industrial Disputes Act, the only remedy is under the Act to get adjudicated and the Civil Court is barred from going into such proceedings. 2. An order of injunction without recording the reasons, the injunction would be in violation of the procedure under Order 39, Rule 3, C.P.C.

Issues: 1. Whether the Civil Court has jurisdiction to entertain a suit relating to enforcement of rights or obligations created under the Industrial Disputes Act? 2. Whether an interim injunction can be granted without recording reasons as per Order 39, Rule 3, C.P.C.?

Ratio Decidendi: 1. If the industrial dispute relates to the enforcement of a right or an obligation created under the Act, then the only remedy available to the suitor is to get an adjudication under the Act. 2. Order 39, Rule 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure contains a specific provision that after it is proposed by the Court to grant an injunction without giving notice of the application to the opposite party, the court shall record the reasons for its opinion that the object of granting the injunction would be defeated by delay.

Final Decision: Both C.R.P.Nos.2005 of 1995 and 2024 of 1995 were allowed. The impugned orders granting interim injunctions were set aside. The court below was directed to consider the maintainability of the suits before passing any further orders.

Advocates:
Rita Chandrasekaran, Advocate for Petitioner

Judgment :

1. Defendant in O.S.No.430 of 1995 on the file of District Munsif, Poonamallee, aggrieved by the Order in I.A.No.1956 of 1995 granting interim injunction, has filed C.R.P.No.2005 of 1995 before this court under Article 227 of the Constitution of India. Likewise, defendant in O.S.No.127 of 1995 on the file of District Munsif, Poonamallee, aggrieved by the order of extension of interim injunction, granted in I.A.No.623 of 1995, has filed C.R.P.No.2025 of 1995 under Article 227 of the Constitution of India before this court.

2. I shall take the first C.R.P., namely, C.R.P.No.2005 of 1995. The respondent herein/plaintiff, namely, Democration Labour Union represented by its Secretary filed the said suit for permanent injunction restraining the defendant, management, its men, servants and agents from removing ‘B’ schedule properties from the ‘A’ schedule factory premises during the pendency of the conciliation proceedings. In order to understand the case of the plaintiff, it is useful to refer some of the averments made in the pl aint. It is averred that workers numbering 38 employed in the defendant company are the members of the plaintiff union. The plaintiff has raised a industrial dispute with defendant on 14. 1995 seeking increasing the wages for the workers. The present wage structure is below the minimum wage fixed by the State of Tamil Nadu. The defendant with a view to coerse the workers to give up a claim for improvement in their service condition had announced closure notice dated 16. 1995. The decision of the management is illegal. The procedure contemplated under the Industrial Disputes Act was not complied with by the management. The plaintiff Union had started conciliation by filing an application before the Conciliation Officer-cum-Assistant Commissioner of Labour No.2, Kuralagam, Madras. Now the industrial dispute is pending before the forum created under the Industrial Acts. Further it is alleged that the threaten action is in violation of the valuable statutory rights of the workers under section 33 of the Industrial Disputes Act, for security of tenure of service. In the cause of action paragraph, the plaintiff has alleged that the plaintiff had filed an application before the Assistant Commissioner of Labour No.2, Madras 108, seeking conciliation of the Industrial Dispute. In the light of the above pleadings, they also filed an application I.A.No.1956 of 1995 in O.S.No.430 of 1995 under Order 39, Rules 1 and 2 C.P.C., for an order of interim injunction restraining the defendants from removing ‘B’ schedule properties from ‘A’ schedule factory premises till the disposal of the suit. The impugned order dated 26. 1995 reads as follows:-

“Heard, perused the Records. He has a prima facie case. Ad interim injunction relating only to machineries not relating to other aspects till 27. 1995 Excluding those machineries which are serviceable to get revised vent the composing contigency within the period of injunction granted in favour and Notice by then.”

Against the said order granting ex parte injunction, the defendant has filed the present revision before this court under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.

3. Mrs.Rita Chandrasekaran, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner, raises the following submissions:-

.(1) On the basis of the various averments made in the plaint, the court below has no jurisdiction to entertain the suit. If so it has equally no jurisdiction to grant interim order. In other words, she submits that where a dispute relates to enforcement of rights or obligation created under the Industrial Disputes Act, then the only remedy is under the Act to get adjudicated and the Civil Court is barred from going into such proceedings.

.(2) The order of the court below is contrary to the mandatory provisions of Order 39, Rule 3, C.P.C.

For the above said proposition, she relied upon the following decisions reported in:-

.(a) Premier Automobiles Ltd, v. K.S. Wadke, 1975 II L.L.J. 445




















1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top