SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2009 Supreme(Mad) 4372

High Court of Judicature at Madras
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE S. PALANIVELU
Thirumalai Ammal & Others
Versus
Sakuntala Ammal & Others
C.M.P (NPD).No.2225 of 2007 & M.P.No.2 of 2007
Decided on: 23-10-2009

Important Points

The importance of impleading all co-sharers in a partition suit and the interest of every co-owner in a joint family property in a partition suit.

Subject

Civil Law - Property Law

Act Referred

CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE : S.115

Headnote

Non-joinder of Parties - Partition Suit - Section 151 of CPC - [Section 151 of CPC] - The court allowed the petitioners to raise additional grounds as to non-joinder of parties in the appeal, emphasizing the importance of impleading all co-sharers in a partition suit and the interest of every co-owner in a joint family property in a partition suit. The court highlighted the cardinal principle of law that every co-owner in a joint family property has an interest in every infinitesimal particle of the property covered by a partition suit.

Fact of the Case:

The petitioners, defendants in a partition suit, filed an appeal seeking permission to raise additional grounds as to non-joinder of parties, namely, their daughters, in the appeal.

Finding of the Court:

The court allowed the petitioners to raise the additional grounds as to non-joinder of parties in the appeal, stating that the nature of further proceedings will be decided by the appellate court in accordance with the law.

Issues: Non-joinder of parties in a partition suit, entitlement to raise additional grounds in an appeal, and the importance of impleading all co-sharers in a partition suit.

Ratio Decidendi: The court emphasized the importance of impleading all co-sharers in a partition suit and the interest of every co-owner in a joint family property in a partition suit.

Final Decision: The civil revision petition stands allowed, and the order challenged before the court is set aside.

Advocates appeared:
For the Appellants:S. Shyamala, Advocate.
For the Respondents:R1, R2, R4 & R6 S. Srinivasan, R3 & R5, Siva Subramaniam, Advocates.

Judgment :-

The petitioners are defendants 1, 3 and 4 in O.S.No.4086 of 1997 on the file of the City Civil Court, Madras. The respondents 1 and 2 and one Gowri filed the said suit for partition and separate possession. A preliminary decree was passed in the suit in favour of the plaintiffs. Hence, the petitioners preferred appeal in A.S.No.232 of 2004 on the file of the V Additional Judge, City Civil Court, Chennai.

2. Pending the hearing of the said appeal, they filed C.M.P.No.2320 of 2005 under Section 151 of CPC praying the Court to permit them to raise additional grounds in the appeal. In the affidavit filed by these petitioners, it is stated as follows:-

1. The plaintiffs filed the suit without impleading the defendants daughters. The petitioner is not all aware of the legal proceedings. she met her Counsel last week to prepare the documents and in the course of the conversation, she mentioned about her daughters. Then only, her Counsel came to know that they were not impleaded in the suit. It is stated that Lalitha, Kalyani and R. Padmavathy are the daughters of the petitioner. In a suit for partition, all the co-sharers must be impleaded and on the ground of non-joinder of parties, the suit is liable to be dismissed. She had not raised plea either in the written statement or in the grounds of appeal. Hence, she may be permitted to raise the plea by way of additional grounds of appeal that the suit is liable to be dismissed on the ground of non-joinder of parties, namely, her daughters above-mentioned.

3. In the counter filed by the respondents / plaintiffs, it is alleged as follows:-

1. The partition suit was filed by the legal heirs of one P.C. Shanmuga Achari against the defendants 1 to 4 in respect of the suit properties, which had been jointly purchased and each of them having half share. In respect of half share of the said P.C. Shanmuga Achari, the suit properties were bequeathed in favour of the plaintiffs. Therefore, after notice, on 012. 1995, to the defendants, the suit was filed for partition. The present allegation that the daughters were also available was not pleaded, on the earlier point of time. It is false to state that the petitioner is not aware of the legal proceedings. The application is intended only to delay the disposal of the appeal and hence, the same may be dismissed.

4. The learned V Additional Judge, City Civil Court, Cheenai, has dismissed the application by observing that the respective claims of the parties have been settled in the preliminary decree passed by the trial Court and none of the questions settled by the preliminary decree will be allowed to be re-agitated on the ground that the persons now sought to be impleaded were not before that Court at the time of passing of preliminary decree. It is not denied that the first plaintiff is the wife of Munusamy Achari and their daughters are Lalitha, Kalyani and R. Padmavathy. It is true that the present plea as to non-joinder of necessary parties was not raised as a defence by these petitioners in the suit proceedings. It is also true that the rights of the parties to the suit have been ascertained by means of preliminary decree. But the fact remains that the three daughters of the first plaintiff, who are very much available in the family were not impleaded in the suit, even though the plaintiffs might have had knowledge. It is not their case that they do not know about the existence of other heirs of Munusamy Achari.

5. The findings of the trial Court that the rights of the parties settled in the preliminary decree may be correct. But when it is unearthed that some other co-sharers or persons interested in the properties are also available, without whose presence, no final adjudication could be made in a lis, then it is the matter for consideration to bring them to array of the parties. It is well settled law that in a partition suit all the parties have to be presumed to be plaintiffs. When one of the parties to the suit, namely, the





1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top