2008 Supreme(Mad) 3247
High Court of Judicature at Madras
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A.C. ARUMUGAPERUMAL ADITYAN
Padmavathi & Others
Versus
P.M. Muni Reddy & Others
S.A.No.224 of 1999
Decided on: 06-09-2008
Important Points
Subject
Property Law - Dispute over Title and Possession
Act Referred
Headnote
Title - Property Dispute - Tamil Nadu Minor Inams (Abolition and Conversion) into Ryotwari Act of 1963, Order 39 Rule 1 of CPC - S.No.373/8 - 0.10.5 hectares - 26 ½ cents - Plaintiffs claimed title and possession - Defendants disputed - Settlement patta issued in favor of 8 persons including plaintiffs and defendant - Plaintiffs claimed 20 cents in possession - First appellate Judge decreed the suit in part - Second appeal allowed and matter remanded for fresh disposal
Fact of the Case:
The plaintiffs filed a suit for declaration of title and possession in respect of a property in S.No.373/8, claiming 0.10.5 hectares = 26 ½ cents. The defendants disputed the plaintiffs' claim, stating that settlement patta was issued in favor of 8 persons, including the plaintiffs and the defendant. The first appellate Judge decreed the suit in part, granting relief for 20 cents in possession. The second appeal was allowed, and the matter was remanded for fresh disposal.
Finding of the Court:
The trial Judge dismissed the suit, finding that the plaintiffs failed to establish their title and possession. The first appellate Judge decreed the suit in part, relying on the report of an ex-parte commission, which was found to be inadmissible in evidence. The second appellate Judge set aside the decree and judgment of the first appellate Judge and remanded the matter for fresh disposal.
Issues: The main issues were the identification of the suit property, establishment of title and possession by the plaintiffs, and the admissibility of the report of an ex-parte commission.
Ratio Decidendi: The plaintiffs' claim for declaration of title and possession was based on a partition deed and an updating survey patta. However, the existence of the updating survey patta in favor of the defendant raised doubts about the plaintiffs' exclusive entitlement to the property. The first appellate Judge's reliance on an ex-parte commission report was found to be erroneous, leading to the setting aside of the decree and judgment.
Final Decision: The second appeal was allowed, and the matter was remanded to the lower appellate Court for fresh disposal in accordance with law, allowing both parties to adduce further evidence.
For the Petitioners:C.R. Muralidharan, Advocate.
For the Respondents:R. Poornima, Advocate.
1. This second appeal has been directed against the decree and judgment in A.S.No.1 of 1997 on the file of the Court of Subordinate Judge, Hosur, which had arisen out of the decree and judgment in O.S.No.5 of 1988 on the file of the Court of District Munsif, Hosur. The plaintiff has filed the suit for declaration of his title and also for possession in respect of the plaint schedule property which is 0.10.5 Ares = 26 ½ cents in S.No.373/8 in Nanthimangalam Village, Hosur Taluk, Dharmapuri District.
2. The case of the plaintiff was totally dismissed by the learned Trial Judge. Aggrieved by the findings of the learned Trial Judge, the plaintiffs had preferred an appeal in A.S.No.1 of 1997 before the learned Subordinate Judge, Hosur, who had partly allowed the appeal and granted the relief of declaration and injunction in respect of 20 cents in Plot NO.1, 2, 3 & 4 as shown in Ex.C.3-Commissioners plan and has dismissed the suit in respect of other relief’s (recovery of possession). Aggrieved by the findings of the learned first appellate Judge in A.S.No.1 of 1997, the defendants 1 & 3 to 8 have preferred this second appeal.
3.The short facts of the amended plaint sans irrelevant particulars are as follows:-
The plaint schedule property is comprised in S.No.373/8 with an extent of 30 cents in the larger area of 7 acres 60 cents in Perumalpalli Village, Hosur Taluk. The great grand-father of plaintiffs 1 to 3 was Muniyappa @ Gounevari Muniyappa, who died leaving behind only one son Munegowdu @ Gounevari Muniyappa @ Gowdu Munipayya. The said Gounevari Muniyappa also died leaving behind two sons viz. Abbaiah Reddy and Jagganna @ J.M.Muniyappa. The said Abbaiah Reddy also died leaving behind two sons viz. Marga Munireddy and A.Muni Reddy, who are plaintiffs 2 & 3. The said Jaganna @ J.Muniyappa died leaving behind only one son by name P.M.Muni Reddy, who is plaintiff No.1. Muniyappa is the great grand-father of the plaintiffs 1 to 3. He Had purchased various extents covered in S.No.373 under 4 registered sale deeds viz., sale deed dated 09.06.1910, 22.09.1910, 17.03.1926 and 08.08.1928. The said Muniyappa, after the purchase of the properties under the above said four sale deeds, was in possession and enjoyment of the same till his death. After this death, his successors in interest including the plaintiffs were/are in possession and enjoyment of the same. To confirm the title of the plaintiffs, the plaintiffs also relied on the sale deed dated 010. 1917 executed by Anumaiah in favour of Muniswamy and Munivenkatadu, gift deed dated 02.03.1917 executed by Anumapa in favour of Meeyasaheb and sale deed dated 03.02.1934 executed by Munivenkatadu in favour of Muniyamma. The plaintiffs 2 and 3 are the brothers being the sons of one Abbaiah Reddy. The 1st plaintiff is the cousin of the plaintiffs 2 and 3. The total extent of S.No.373 is 7 acres 60 cents. The said land was originally classified as Brahmodayam Land, which is covered under T.D.No.62. The entire Survey No.373 has been under the possession of the plaintiffs and their ancestors and also some other co-owners from a very long time and the same has been enjoyed by the family members of the plaintiffs from generation to generation. The plaintiffs are entitled to an extend of 30 cents in S.No.373 and the rest of the area was being enjoyed by the other co-owners by seperating their lands by putting ridges and fences for a very long time. The original suit S.No.373 being Brahmodayam Land survey settlement was conducted in respect of the suit land under the provisions of the Tamil Nadu Minor Inams (Abolition and conversion) into Ryotwari Act of 1963, and under the provisions of the said Act, enquiries were conducted by the settlement Tahsildar, Salem under Section 11(2) of the above said Act and after enquiry as it was found that the suit land S.No.373 was being enjoyed by the plaintiffs and other co-owners with Iruvaram rights and that as they were in possession and enjoyment