1969 Supreme(Mad) 104
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
M.M. Ismail, J.
V. Devaraj Applicant.
Versus
Jayalakshmi Ammal (decsd.).
C.S. No. 159 of 1965 and Applications Nos. 122 and 181 of 1969.
Decided On : 28 February 1969
Important Points
Subject
Hindu Law - Joint Family Property
Act Referred
Headnote
S.V. Rama Iyengar and K.V. Rajagopalan, for Applicant.
A.N. Rangaswami, for Respondents.
The plaintiff is the first son while the second defendant is the second son of one M. Venkatesam Chettiar, who died on 17th June, 1965. The said Venkatesam Chettiar, in 1937 or 1940, started a business under the name and style of Doraikannu and Company with a small capital coming out of his own earnings. Out of the income from the said business, the said Venkatesam Chettiar, purchased a large number of items of properties. The plaintiff herein instituted C. S. No. 399 of 1954, on the file of this Court impleading his father as 1st defendant, the 2nd defendant herein as the 2nd defendant and the 1st defendant herein (mother of the plaintiff and the 2nd defendant) as the 3rd defendant, for partition of certain properties. In that suit, he prayed that an account may be taken of what the joint properties of the said family were, that an account may be taken of the profits of the business referred to above and also prayed for partition of his one-third share in the said properties. In that suit the deceased Venkatesam Chettiar, contended that the business was his own business and the properties acquired out of the income from the said business constituted his self-acquisitions and therefore the plaintiff herein was not entitled to claim partition of the said properties and allotment of one-third share to him. The second defendant and the third defendant in the said suit, namely, the 2nd and the 1st defendants herein adopted the written statement of the deceased Venkatesam Chettiar. The said suit was transferred to and disposed of by the City Civil Court, Madras, as O.S. No. 1669 of 1065 on 17th May, 1956. The learned Additional Judge of the City Civil Court, Madras, accepted the case of the deceased Venkatesam Chettiar, that the business and the properties acquired out of the income from the business were the self-acquisitions of Venkatesam Chettiar and therefore the plaintiff herein had no right to claim partition of the said properties and dismissed the suit. Against this judgment of the City Civil Court the plaintiff herein preferred C.C.C.A No. 12 of 1957 and the Bench of this Court by its judgment and decree dated 9th September, 1960, allowed the appeal in part. The learned Judges disposing of the appeal found that the deceased Venkatesam Chettiar, did not inherit any ancestral property and that there was no nucleus of joint family property, the business of Doraikannu and Company was started by the deceased Venkatesam Chettiar as his own with a small capital coming out of his own earnings and the said business and the properties purchased out of the income from the said business were acquired without any detriment to any ancestral nucleus. However, the learned Judges on an appreciation of the evidence and on considering the law on the question came to the conclusion that the father, namely, the deceased Venkatesam Chettiar, intended to deprive the business of its separate character and convert it into a joint family business. The learned Judges concluded:
“We are, therefore, unable to agree with the learned Counsel for the respondents that the appellants’ participation in the business from 1948 onwards was not such as would be sufficient to convert the separate business into a joint family one.......... was not disputed that the suit properties were all acquired out of the income from the business in question. Disagreeing with the trial Court, we hold that such of the suit properties as were acquired between January, 1948 and the end of 1953, are joint family properties and that the appellant is entitled to partition and separate possession of an one-third share in the joint family properties. The appellant will not be entitled to any share in the other suit properties which were acquired prior to 1948.
The result is, there will be a preliminary decree in favour of the appellant for partition and separate possession of an one-third share in the properties which we have held to be joint family properties and in the pro