SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2011 Supreme(Mad) 737

High Court of Judicature at Madras
G. RAJASURIA, J.
C.A. Ramasamty
Versus
Karuppana Gounder & Another
S.A.No.459 of 2010 & M.P.No.1 of 2010
Decided on : 11-02-2011

Subject

Property Law - Land Ownership

Act Referred

CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE : .

Headnote

CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE, 1908 - Order 26 - Dispute over boundary of property - Contention of appellant/plaintiff that instead of placing reliance on technicalities, it once again the Commissioner is directed to visit the suit property with the mission to demarcate the Old Survey No. 237, as per Ex.B1, then matter would come to an end. Plaintiff is not laying claim over any extent more than the extent which is covered under Old Survey No. 237, as per Ex.B1 - Submission accepted in Second Appeal - Held, matter should necessarily be remitted back to the first appellate court with a direction that the same Advocate Commissioner or some other Advocate Commissioner might be appointed to visit suit property, and demarcate with the help of a qualified Surveyor, the Old Survey No. 237 from other Survey Numbers situated to the South of it and also note down the physical features at the Southern boundary line of the Old Survey No. 237 and submit a report. Whereupon, the parties are at liberty to file necessary objections, if any Thereafter the first appellate court shall decide relating to the validity of such measurement etc and the lis, as per law - Second Appeal ordered accordingly.

Advocates Appeared:
For the Appellant:S. Parthasarathy, Sr. counsel for I.C. Vasudevan, Advocate.
For the Respondents:N. Manokaran, Advocate.

JUDGMENT :

1. This second appeal is filed by the plaintiff, inveighing the judgment and decree dated 30.11.2009 passed by the Principal Sub Court, Gobichettipalayam, in A.S.No.34 of 2009 confirming the judgment and decree dated 3.2.2009 passed by the District Munsif Court, Sathyamangalam, in O.S.No.368 of 1998, which was filed for declaration and permanent injunction.

2. The merits relating to the factual matrix lie within a narrow campus, which could succinctly and precisely be set out thus:

The appellant herein, as plaintiff, filed the suit seeking the following reliefs:

"to pass a judgment and decree

a) granting a permanent injunction against the defendants, their men and agents restraining them from interfering with the plaintiff's peaceful possession and enjoyment of the suit property in any manner.

b) awarding costs."(extracted as such)

(b) The respondents/defendants resisted the suit by filing written statement.

(c) Whereupon the trial Court framed the issues. The plaintiff on his side examined himself as P.W.1 along with P.W.2 to P.W.4 and marked Ex.A1 to A8. On the defendants' side, no one was examined, however Ex.B1 was marked. Exs.X1 to X11 were marked as 3rd party documents. Exs.C1 and C2 were marked as Court documents.

(d) Ultimately, the trial Court dismissed the suit, as against which, the appeal was filed for nothing but to be dismissed by the appellate Court, confirming the judgment and decree of the trial Court.

3. Challenging and impugning the judgments and decrees of the Courts below, this second appeal has been filed on various grounds, inter alia to the effect that without considering the well settled principles of law and the oral and documentary evidence on record, the Courts below simply dismissed the suit of the plaintiff.

4. Accordingly the following substantial questions of law are found suggested in the second appeal.

"1) Whether the court below is correct in holding that the appellant was not entitled to rely on the document Ex.B1, which is the parent document relating to the suit property, since it was not pleaded by the appellant especially when the appellant pleaded that it was the self acquired property of his father.

2. Whether the boundaries will prevail over the extent especially when there is no specific measurement of the length and breadth of the suit property mentioned in the sale deed?" (extracted as such)

5. On hearing both sides, I am of the considered view that the following substantial question of law could be framed for consideration.

1. Whether the Court appointed Advocate Commissioner demarcated with reference to Ex.B1-the sale deed dated 28.10.1963, the old Survey No.237 from other survey numbers situated towards South of it.

2. Whether there is any perversity or illegality in the judgments and decrees of the Courts below?

6. Heard both.

7. Substantial Questions of law (1) to (2): Both these substantial questions of law are taken together for discussion, as they are interwoven and interlinked, interconnected and entwined with each other.

8. The learned Senior counsel for the appellant/plaintiff would advance his arguments, the gist and kernal of them would run thus:

The plaintiff claims right over the suit property based on Ex.B1-the Sale deed dated 28.10.1963 and he does not have any intention to claim any extent more than what is contemplated in Ex.B1, but the Courts below failed to get demarcated the line supporting the Old Survey No.237 from the rest of the Survey Numbers situated to the South of it. Had it been done, the matter would have been settled once and for all. Over and above that, the defendants also are not claiming any right over the land in Old Survey Number 237.

Accordingly, the learned Senior counsel for the appellant/plaintiff prays for giving suitable direction to the lower Court to do the needful in the matter.


9. In an attempt to pulverise and torpedo the arguments as put forth and set forth on the side of the appellant/plaintiff, the learned counsel for the respo
















1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top