SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2011 Supreme(Mad) 2516

High Court of Judicature at Madras
V. DHANAPALAN
K. Renuka
Versus
The Director of School Education, College Road, Chennai & Others
W.P.No.2468 of 2011 & M.P.Nos.1, 2 and 3 of 2011
Decided On: 12-05-2011

Act Referred

CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE : S.92(1), S.92
CONSTITUTION OF INDIA : Art.226
HINDU SUCCESSION ACT : .
INDIAN PENAL CODE : .
TAMIL NADU RECOGNISED PRIVATE SCHOOLS REGULATION ACT : S.53, S.53(a)(1)
TAMIL NADU RECOGNISED PRIVATE SCHOOLS REGULATION RULES : R.13(5), R.13(3), R.13(2), R.13(1), R.13

Headnote

Trustee Inclusion - Trust Dispute - Tamil Nadu Recognised Private Schools (Regulation) Act, 1973, Rules 1974 - The court discussed the provisions of the Trust Deed, the appointment and succession of Trustees, and the authority to conduct an enquiry before granting approval to the extension of the term of office for the present office bearers of the Trust. The court highlighted the bar of jurisdiction of the Civil Court under Sections 53 and 53-A(1) of the Act, and the remedy available to the parties to move the Civil Court for resolution of the dispute.

Fact of the Case:

The petitioner sought inclusion as a Trustee in the Trust Board, claiming to be one of the grand daughters of the Founder-Trustee. The dispute arose from the non-inclusion of family members in the Trust Board and alleged misfeasance by the present office bearers.

Finding of the Court:

The court found that the dispute regarding inclusion of the petitioner as a Trustee and the approval of the extension of the term of office for the present office bearers of the Trust is not within the realm of the extraordinary writ jurisdiction of the Court. The Court directed the parties to move before the appropriate Civil Court of competent jurisdiction to decide the issue raised in the Writ Petition.

Issues: The main issue was the inclusion of the petitioner as a Trustee and the approval of the extension of the term of office for the present office bearers of the Trust, and the jurisdiction of the Civil Court to decide the matter.

Ratio Decidendi: The Court held that the dispute is not within the realm of the extraordinary writ jurisdiction of the Court and directed the parties to move before the appropriate Civil Court of competent jurisdiction to decide the issue raised in the Writ Petition.

Final Decision: The Writ Petition was disposed of with the direction for the parties to move before the appropriate Civil Court of competent jurisdiction to decide the issue raised in the Writ Petition.

Advocates Appeared:
For the Petitioner:R. Thiyagarajan, Senior Counsel, S. Giridharan, Advocate. 3
For the Respondents: R1 to R3 - S. Gopinathan, Addl. G.P., R4 - Nalini Chidambaram, Senior Counsel, G. Thilagavathi,

Judgment :-

1. By consent of learned counsel appearing for the parties, the Writ Petition itself is taken up for disposal.

2. The petitioner who claims to be one of the grand daughters of Late W.T.Masilamani Mudaliyar, the Founder-Trustee of Ambalavanar Araporrupu Ayam (for short, 'the Trust'), has sought for a direction to the third respondent, namely the District Educational Officer, Kanchipuram, to conduct an enquiry before granting approval to the extension of the term of office for the present office bearers of the Trust at Walajabad, Kanchipuram, for a further period of three years, i.e. from 2011 to 2014.

3. In the affidavit filed in support of the Writ Petition, it is stated as follows:

(a) The petitioner is one of the grand daughters of Late W.T.Masilamani Mudaliyar, who founded the Trust called "Ambalavanar Araporuppu Ayam" at Walajabad, Kanchipuram in 1963 with the object of providing education to the local people who are socially and educationally backward. The Trust started various schools in and around the area, for the benefit of the people in Walajabad Village and surrounding areas, who are all depending on the Schools to give best education to their children. Many children also do part-time work at home for their livelihood and then attend the school.

(b) Originally, the members of the Trust Board were (1) Thiru.T.Manikkam Chettiyar, (2) Thiru.W.T.Masilamani Mudaliyar, (3) Thiru.W.D.Nataraja Mudaliyar, (4) Thiru.N.P.Thanigaiarasu, (5) Tmt. Rajeswari Vedhachalam Ammayar, (6) Thiru.W.T.Kannappa Mudaliyar and (7) Dr.Vaithiyanathan. All were continued as Trustees till their lifetime. In the Trust Deed, it is clearly stated that any vacancy that arises due to resignation or death should be filled up by majority of votes of the other Trustees in the Trust. It is also clearly stated that after the death of W.T.Masilamani Mudaliyar, his family member must be included in the Trust Board as a Trustee. The Trust Deed also prescribes the qualification to become a member of the Trust.

(c) The petitioner claims that she is one of the grand daughters of the said Late

Thiru.W.T.Masilamani Mudaliyar and she has fulfilled all the required qualifications prescribed in the Trust Deed. No one from the family of Late Thiru.W.T.Masilamani Mudaliyar was appointed or elected as a Trustee after his death and the said fact was brought to the knowledge of the earlier Trust Board on several occasions by her and her brother, but to her shock and surprise, no action has been taken by the earlier Trust Board and also the present Trust Board to include the family members of Late Thiru.W.T.Masilamani Mudaliyar as Trustee.

(d) While so, the Director of School Education, in his proceedings dated 26.10.1977, inter-alia stated that it is not known that whether the family members of W.T.Masilamani Mudaliyar has been elected as a Trustee and when that is the position, the fourth respondent-Secretary of the Trust, and also the Secretary of W.T.Masilamani Mudaliyar Higher Secondary School, Walajabad, Kanchipuram (for short, 'the School'), suppressing the above fact that the family members of the said W.T.Masilamani Mudaliyar were not included as a Trustee, sent the proposal to the District Educational Officer for approval of his appointment as Secretary. The third respondent-District Educational Officer, based on the proposal, granted the approval of his appointment as Secretary of the Trust Board, by proceedings, dated 6.2.2008 from 6.3.2008 to 5.3.2011.

(e) In the present Trust Board, the family members of the above said Late Thiru.W.T.Masilamani Mudaliyar, were not included as Trustees in the Trust Board. In the present Board, there are seven trustees and they are as follows:

(1) Thiru.B.Kandasamy - President

(2) Thiru.P.Radhakrishnan - Secretary

(3) Thiru W.N.Thirunavukarasu - Assistant Secretary-cum-Treasurer

(4) Thiru.S.Rajendran - Member

(5) Thiru.Lakshmanan - Member

(6) Thiru.S.L.N.S.Vijayakumar - Member

(7) Thiru.Dr.M.S.Amarasan - Member

The ab

























































































1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top