SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

1919 Supreme(Mad) 110

IN THE HIGH COURT OF MARAS
Periya Goundan
Versus
Kuppa Goundan
Decided On : 2 April, 1919

Important Points

The person who furnishes false information to the police, leading to a prosecution, can be held responsible and sued for damages for malicious prosecution.

Subject

Criminal Law - Malicious Prosecution

Headnote

Malicious Prosecution - Criminal Law - Chapter XVII of the Criminal Procedure Code, Chapter XIV of the Criminal Procedure Code, Section 45 of the Cr.P. Code, Section 170 of the Cr. P. Code, Section 200 of the Cr. P. Code, Section 202 of the Cr. P. Code, Section 204 of the Cr. P. Code, Section 173 of the Cr.P. Code, Section 211 of the Indian Penal Code

Fact of the Case:

Appellant sued respondent for damages for malicious prosecution. The District Judge set aside the decree for damages on the ground that the respondent could not be said to have prosecuted appellant, as the police conducted the prosecution for theft based on a report made by the respondent to the village Munsif.

Finding of the Court:

The Court disagreed with the District Judge's interpretation and held that the person who furnished the false information to the police, whether directly or through the village Headman, is responsible for the prosecution and can be sued for damages for malicious prosecution.

Issues: The main issue was whether the respondent could be held liable for damages for malicious prosecution based on the report made to the village Munsif, which led to the police conducting a prosecution for theft against the appellant and his father.

Ratio Decidendi: The Court emphasized that the responsibility for the prosecution should be fixed based on the false information provided, and it is irrelevant whether the prosecution was instituted and conducted by the police. The Court also referred to the applicability of Section 211 of the Indian Penal Code to cases of maliciously false information.

Final Decision: The Court set aside the decree of the District Judge and directed him to restore the appeal to file and dispose of it in the light of the Court's remarks.

JUDGMENT

1. Appellant sued respondent for damages for malicious prosecution. He got a decree for Rs. 100 in the Munsifs Court. The District Judge set it aside on the ground that the respondent could not be said to have prosecuted appellant, because he only made a report to the village Munsif as a result of which the police after investigation launched and conducted a prosecution for theft against appellant and his father. The authority relied on is the ruling of this Court in Narasinga Rao v. Muthaya Pillai (1902) I.L.R. 26 Mad. 362

2. Any person desirous of setting the Criminal Law in motion against another in respect of an act amounting to a cognizable offence can do so in three ways:

1. He can present a complaint to a Magistrate having Jurisdiction, who will thereupon take action under Chapter XVII of the Criminal Procedure Code.

2. He may give an information to an officer in charge of a Police Station, who will take action under Chapter XIV of the Criminal Procedure Code.

3. He may (in the cases of all non-bail-able and certain other offences) give information to the Headman of his village, who is bound under Section 45 of the Cr.P. Code to forthwith communicate the information to the nearest Magistrate, and to the officer in charge of the nearest Police Station. It then becomes the duty of the Police Officer to investigate the case as laid down in Chapter XIV.

3. Method (3) in fact only differs from method (2) in that the village Headman, being the officer presumably most accessible to the person giving information, is made the channel of communication to the Police officer. It was the method adopted in the present case; and, as the District Judge himself recognized the fact that this indirect method of communicating with the Police was resorted to makes no difference to the defendants liability for damages. The contention is that whenever the prosecution in Court is instituted on a Police report under Section 173 of the Cr.P. Code, the person who furnished the original information to the Police, whether directly or through the village Headman, is not responsible for the act of the Police and cannot be sued for damages for malicious prosecution.

4. This certainly seems to me to be the meaning of the learned Judges in Narasinga Rao v. Muthayya Pillai (1902) I.L.R. 26 Mad. 362, but with all respect. I am unable to agree. If it be conceded that a person is liable for damages in respect of a prosecution on the ground that it was instituted on maliciously false information communicated by him to the court in the shape of a complaint under Section 200 of the Cr. P. Code, why should he not be equally liable where he induces the Police by maliciously false information to send the case to the Magistrate under Section 170 of the Cr. P. Code. No doubt it is the duty of the Police to hold an investigation as laid down in Chapter XIV before sending the case to the Magistrate with a view to verifying as far as possible the truth of the information furnished to them. But a similar duty is cast on the Magistrate receiving a complaint; he must examine the complainant on oath (Section 200) and if not satisfied of the truth of the complaint he may hold or direct a preliminary enquiry (Section 202) and he only takes action against the accused person by the issue of process under Section 204 of the Cr. P. Code if he is of opinion that there is sufficient ground for proceeding. The fact that some officer whether Policeman or Magistrate has to form an opinion on the apparent truth of the informants information before the prosecution proceeds is no more reason in the one case than in the other for exonerating the informant from liability for what follows. It is in each case his false information, out of which the prosecution arises; and it makes no difference whether the person led astray in the first instance is the Police officer or the Magistrate. The Police, or as the form usually runs, the King Emperor may be the nominal prosecutor; but the person






1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top