2010 Supreme(Mad) 1972
High Court of Judicature at Madras
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE M. JAICHANDREN
The Food Corporation of India (South Zone) Employees Co-op. Society Ltd., Chennai & Another
Versus
J. Shanmugam Vice President The Food Corporation of India (South Zone) Employees Co-op. Society Ltd., Chennai & Others
C.R.P.(PD) No.3865 of 2009
Decided On : 29-04-2010
Important Points
Subject
Civil Law - Election Disputes
Headnote
Election - Multi-State Cooperative Societies Act - 2002 - Sections 84, 115, 117 - The court discussed the provisions of the Multi-State Cooperative Societies Act, 2002, including Sections 84, 115, and 117, and their applicability to the case. The court also considered the legal principles related to the election process and the scope of intervention by the court in such matters.
Fact of the Case:
The suit was filed to declare an election programme null and void and to restrain the returning officer from conducting the election for the Board of Directors of the society. The trial Court granted an ad interim injunction in favor of the respondents, which was challenged by the petitioners.
Finding of the Court:
The court found that the petitioners failed to show sufficient cause to interfere with the trial Court's order. It held that the order was only ad interim and the petitioners could approach the trial Court to vacate it or avail the appellate remedy. The court also stated that a civil revision petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India was not the appropriate remedy at that stage.
Issues: The issues included the maintainability of the suit, the applicability of Sections 84, 115, and 117 of the Multi-State Cooperative Societies Act, 2002, and the scope of intervention by the court in election matters.
Ratio Decidendi: The court held that the petitioners did not demonstrate sufficient cause to interfere with the trial Court's ad interim order and that a civil revision petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India was not the appropriate remedy at that stage.
Final Decision: The Civil Revision Petition was dismissed as devoid of merits and the court held that it was liable to be dismissed. No costs were awarded.
For the Petitioners:D. Rajagopal, Senior Advocate for K.G. Vasudevan, Advocate.
For the Respondents:R1 & R2, N. Jayabalan, Advocate.
1. This Civil Revision Petition has been filed against the order, dated 24.11.2009, made in I.A.No.22905 of 2009, in O.S.No.12081 of 2009, on the file of the V Assistant City Civil Court, Chennai.
2. The petitioners in the present Civil Revision Petition are the second and the third defendants in the suit, in O.S.No.12081 of 2009, filed by the first and the second respondents herein. The suit, in O.S.No.12081 of 2009, has been filed praying for a decree to declare the election programme, dated 13.10.2009, issued by the fourth respondent returning officer is null and void and that it is not in accordance with the provisions of the Multi-State Cooperative Societies Act, 2002, and the bye-laws of the food corporation of India (south zone) employees? cooperative societies limited. The plaintiffs in the suit had also prayed for a decree of permanent injunction restraining the returning officer from conducting the election for the Board of Directors of the society, based on the alleged resolution, dated 24.9.2009, and to direct the Central Registrar of Cooperative Societies, New Delhi, the first defendant in the suit, to conduct the election for the Board of Directors of the society, for the period 2010-2014, in terms of the byelaws of the society and the provisions of the Multi-State Cooperative Societies Act, 2002. The first and the second respondents had also filed an interlocutory application, in I.A.No.22905 of 2009, in O.S.No.12081 of 2009, praying for an order of interim injunction to restrain the returning officer, the fourth respondent in the civil revision petition, from proceeding with the election programme for the second respondent society, as per the notice, dated 30.10.2009, pending disposal of the suit, in O.S.No.12081 of 2009.
3. The trial Court, by its order, 24.11.2009, had stated that, prima facie, the balance of convenience was found to be in favour of the first and the second respondents, at that stage. It had also been stated that if an order of interim injunction is not granted the resultant injury, damage or loss caused to the first and the second respondents cannot be compensated. Since, the documents filed on behalf of said respondents clearly established the unfair practice in the process of election to the food corporation of India (south zone employees cooperative limited), an order of ad interim injunction had been granted in favour of the first and second respondents.
4. The petitioners have filed the present Civil Revision Petition against the order of the V Assistant City Civil Court, Chennai, dated 24.11.2009, under Article 227 of the Constitution of India.
5. The learned counsel appearing for the petitioners had submitted that the order of the trial Court, dated 24.11.2009, made in I.A.No.22905 of 2009, is opposed to the principles of law and amounts to jurisdictional error. The learned V Assistant Judge, City Civil Court, Chennai, had failed to note that, under Section 115 of the Multi-State Cooperative Societies Act, 2002, no suit shall be instituted against a Multi-State Cooperative Society or of any officers in respect of any act touching the constitution, management or the business of the society, until the expiration of 90 days after a notice, in writing, has been delivered to the Central Registrar or left at his office stating the cause of action and the other particulars relating to the plaintiff, including the reliefs sought for.
6. The learned counsel appearing for the petitioners had submitted that the learned Judge had lost sight of mandatory provisions before granting an order of interim injunction restraining the respondents from proceeding with the election process. The learned Judge had also failed to take into consideration the established legal position that once an election process has been set in motion, the court would not intervene and pass orders thereon.
7. The learned counsel appearing for the petitioners had submitted that the trial Court had erred in ignoring