SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

1999 Supreme(Mad) 118

High Court of Judicature at Madras
S.S. SUBRAMANI
The Deputy Manager, Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd., Regional Office, United India Life Building, Chennai & Another
Versus
K. Veerasamy
C.R.P.No. 3864 of 1998 & C.R.P.No.3865 of 1998
Decided On : 05-02-1999

Important Points

Grant of ad-interim injunction set aside.

Subject

Injunction - Ad-Interim Injunction

Headnote

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908-Order 39, Rules 1 and 3-In an application for grant of interim injunction ad-interim injunction granted-Held, impugned order not satisfying legal requirements hence set aside.

Advocates Appeared:
For the Petitioners:P. Sukumar, Advocate.
For the Respondent:T.L. Ram Mohan, Senior Counsel, for K. Muthuramalingam, Advocate.

Judgment

1. In both these revision petitions, defendants are the revision petitioners. Defendants are aggrieved by the ad-interim injunction granted by the lower court.

2. Plaintiff was suspended from service, and the same is challenged in O.S.No.1263 of 1998. I.A.No.1051 of 1998 was filed in that case for injunction. Ad-interim injunction was granted. Subsequently, the very same plaintiff was charge-sheeted, and he filed O.S.No.1591 of 1998. I.A.No.1057 of 1998 was filed in that case, and the same is the subject-matter of C.R.P.No.3865 of 1998. In both the injunction petitions, ad-interim injunction was passed. In I.A.No.1051 of 1998, the injunction order reads thus:

“Heard. Documents perused. Ad-interim injunction granted till 5.10.1998. Notice, O.39, Rules 1 and 3, to be complied with.”

In I.A.No.1057 of 1998, the injunction order reads thus:

“Heard. Documents perused. Interim injunction granted till 10.12.98. Notice by then. O.39, Rules 1 and 3 to be complied with.”

The above orders are challenged by defendants on various grounds. But I do not want to go into the merits of the case.

3. When the revision petitions came for admission, the interim order was suspended, and notice was directed to be served on respondent. After service, both parties were heard.

4. The Honourable Supreme Court has held in D.R.Chawla and others v. Municipal Corporation of Delhi D.R.Chawla and others v. Municipal Corporation of Delhi D.R.Chawla and others v. Municipal Corporation of Delhi (1993)3 S.C.C. 161 as to how an interim order has to be passed, and what are the ingredients that are to be taken into consideration while passing the order. In paragraphs 34 and 35 (at pages 176 and 177), their Lordships have held thus:

“The imperative nature of the proviso has to be judged in the context of Rule 3 of O.39 of the Code. Before the proviso aforesaid was introduced Rule 3 said, “the court shall in all cases, except where it appears that the object of granting the injunction would be defeated by the delay, before granting an injunction, direct notice of the application for the same to be given to the opposite party.” The proviso was introduced to provide a condition, where court proposes to grant an injunction without giving notice of the application to the opposite-party being of the opinion that the object of granting injunction itself shall be defeated by delay. The condition so introduced is that the court, “shall record the reasons” why an ex parte order of injunction was being passed in the facts and circumstances of a particular case. In this background, the requirement for recording the reasons for grant of ex parte injunction, cannot be held to be a mere formality. This requirement is consistent with the principle, that a party to a suit, who is being restrained from exercising a right which such party claims to exercise either under a statute or under the common law, must be informed why instead of following the requirement of Rule 3, the procedure prescribed under the proviso has been followed. The party which invokes the jurisdiction of the court for grant of an order of restraint against a party, without affording an opportunity to him of being heard, must satisfy the court about the gravity of the situation and court has to consider briefly these factors in the ex parte order. We are quite conscious of the fact that there are other statutes which contain similar provisions requiring the court or the authority concerned to record reasons before exercising power vested in them. In respect of some of such provisions it has been held that they are required to be complied with but non-compliance therewith will not vitiate the order so passed. But same cannot be said in respect of the proviso to Rule 3 of O.39. The Parliament has prescribed a particular procedure for passing of an order of injunction without notice to the other side, under exceptional circumstances. Such ex parte orders have far-reaching effect, as such a condition has been






1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top