SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2012 Supreme(Mad) 1283

High Court of Judicature at Madras
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE V. PERIYA KARUPPIAH
P. Nataraj Gounder (Died) & Another
Versus
N. Murugesan
Second Appeal No.146 of 2004
Decided On : 12-03-2012

Important Points

The main legal point established in the judgment is that the plaintiff's suit for permanent injunction was not sustainable as the LBP channel was in existence since 1961, and the defendant had no control over the drainage of excess water from his land to the LBP channel.

Subject

Property Law - Easements and Rights of Way

Headnote

LBP Channel - Property Dispute - Ex.A1, Ex.B1 - The court discussed the recitals of Ex.A1, the findings of the First Appellate Court, the right to have water flow into the land of the plaintiff, and the power of the First Appellate Court to grant relief contrary to the pleadings. The court concluded that the LBP channel was in existence since 1961, and the plaintiff's suit for permanent injunction was not sustainable. The court also highlighted the legal principles regarding easementary rights and the natural flow of water, citing relevant case laws.

Fact of the Case:

The plaintiff sought a permanent injunction to restrain the defendant from letting excess water from the defendant's land into the plaintiff's land. The trial court decreed the suit in favor of the plaintiff, but the first appellate court reversed the decision, leading to the appeal before the current court.

Finding of the Court:

The court found that the plaintiff's suit for permanent injunction was not sustainable as the LBP channel was in existence since 1961, and the defendant had no control over the drainage of excess water from his land to the LBP channel. The court also noted that the plaintiff had not taken steps to injunct the defendant from draining the water for over 40 years.

Issues: The issues revolved around the construction of recitals of Ex.A1, the maintainability of the suit in the absence of the Government as a party defendant, the defendant's right to have water flow into the plaintiff's land, and the power of the First Appellate Court to grant relief contrary to the pleadings.

Ratio Decidendi: The court held that the LBP channel was in existence since 1961, and the plaintiff's suit for permanent injunction was not sustainable. The court also emphasized the legal principles regarding easementary rights and the natural flow of water, citing relevant case laws.

Final Decision: The judgment and decree passed by the first appellate Court were confirmed, and the second appeal was dismissed.

Advocates Appeared:
For the Appellants:Mr. N. Manokaran, Advocate.
For the Respondent:Mr. Sundaravathanan, Mr. V. Bharathidasan, Advocates.

Judgment :-

1. This appeal is directed against the judgment and decree passed by the first appellate Court in A.S.No.10 of 2002 dated 5.11.2002 in reversing the judgment and decree of the trial Court made in O.S.No.669 of 2000 dated 5.11.2001 in decreeing the suit. The first appellant herein was the deceased plaintiff and the respondent was the defendant in the suit before the trial Court. The second appellant is the legal representative of the deceased first appellant.

2. The case of the plaintiff as stated in the plaint are as follows:

The suit property along with other properties are the ancestral property of the plaintiff. On 15.6.1961, the plaintiff have partitioned his ancestral properties along with his co-sharers. The partition was effected through a registered document, in document No.1682/1 Registrar Office at Erode. In that partition, "A" schedule property fell to the share of the plaintiff and he is enjoying the property without any disturbance. Among the " A" schedule property the suit property fell into the item 5 of the "A Schedule property. In the suit property, the plaintiff has constructed his residential house, formed his cattle shed, hay stock and the remaining portions are garden land. The defendant is having his agricultural lands on the immediate west of the suit property. The defendants land is higher in level that of the plaintiff. The approximate height of the defendant's land is more than seven feet. The defendants have no right to drain the seepage water into the suit property and he has no right over the suit property. There was a election for the Milk Producers Co-operative Society, at the local area level, in which the plaintiff's son was taking an active role and elected as Vice President. The defendant was also elected as a President by the opposite group. So there is a long standing enmity between the plaintiff's son and the defendant. On 20.10.2002, at about 6.00 p.m., the defendant was trying to let out the seepage water by cutting the western side ridge of the suit property and by forming a new channel course with the help of rowdy elements. The unlawful act of the defendant was thwarted by the plaintiff with the help of neighbours and relation nearby. The plaintiff apprehends that if the defendant is succeeded in his attempt, the crops will be spoiled due to the over flow of the water. Hence, the suit for permanent injunction.

3. The case of the defendant as stated in the written statement are as follows:

The plaintiff has purposely suppressed the fact that there is an acquired LBP boothie course running from west to east in the northern most portion of R.S.No.430 almost on the boundary line dividing the defendant's land in R.S.No.410 from R.S.No.430 and the said acquired boothie course leads up to the plaintiff's land in R.S.No.433/2. The water drained from the defendant's land and the boothie course following from west to east enter into the cultivable land of the plaintiff and the sad water had been regularly used by the plaintiff for his paddy crops. The owner of the land R.S.No.430 situated on the south of defendant's land had previously demolished the acquired boothie course running from west to east in the northern portion of his land with the malafide intention to cause loss and hardship to the defendant. The defendant therefore filed the suit in O.S.No.483/98 on the file of District Munsif Court, Erode and obtained necessary reliefs. The plaintiff's suit is highly malafide. There is no cause of action for the suit and the suit is liable to be dismissed.

4. The trial Court had framed necessary issues and entered trial. After appraising the evidence adduced before the trial Court, the trial Court had come to a conclusion of decreeing the suit in favour of the plaintiff as prayed for.

5. Aggrieved defendant had preferred the appeal before the first appellate Court in A.S.No.10 of 2002 against the said judgment and decree passed by the trial Court The first appellate court heard the
























1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top