1997 Supreme(Mad) 762
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
E. Padmanabhan, J.
Adaikam Ambalam
Versus
P. Renuka Devi
C.R.P. No.3156 of 1996 to C.R.P. No.3157 of 1996C.R.P. No.3158 of 1996 and C.M.P. No.17184 of 1996
Decided On : 30th July, 1997
Important Points
Subject
Civil Law - Amendment of Pleadings
Act Referred
Headnote
V.Balasubramanian, for Petitioner.
R.Nandakumar, for Respondent.
The petitioner herein filed I..A./Nos.98, 99 and 106,24 and 30 of 1996 in C.M.A.No.47 of 1995 on the file of the District Court, Dindigul Anna District and by a common order dated 29.10.1996, the District Court allowed the applications I.A.Nos.24 and 30 of 1996 while dismissing I.A.Nos.98,99 and 196 of 1996. Being aggrieved by the rejection of l.A.Nos.98,99 and 106 of 1996, the present revisions have been preferred.
2. The petitioner herein instituted the suit O.S.No.1405 of 1994 on the file of the District Munsif Court, Dindigul for relief of permanent in- junction forbearing the respondent from putting up any construction on the suit property. The said suit is pending on the file of the trial Court. Pending the suit the petitioner filed I.A.No.1604 of 1994 for the relief of interim injunction. After, contest, the trial Court dismissed the injunction application. Being aggrieved by the dismissal of the injunction application, the petitioner preferred C.M.A.No.47 of 1995 on the file of the District Court, Dindigul Anna District.
3. Pending the Civil Miscellaneous Appeal, the petitioner filed I.A.No.98 of 1996 seeking to amend the description of property in the said plaint i.e. in O.S.No.1405 of 1994 and the particulars of amendment reads thus:
“In the description of property given in the plaint of appeal, after the words, “O.61 cents” delete the word “northern” and substitute it with “southern” and after the word 0.30 1/2 cents“, add the following: which has not been subdivided as S.No.l55/5A2”.
The petition also filed l.A.No.99 of 1996 seeking for amendment in the injunction application with respect to the description of the property for which the injunction was applied for before the trial Court. The petitioner also filed I.A.No.106 of 1996 to amend the description of the property in the civil miscellaneous appeal. In the affidavit filed in support of these application it has been stated that the mistake was accidental, and that the description of the property has to be amended correctly in the suit plaint, in the injunction application, as well as in the appeal and in the additional injunction application pending the appeal. According to the petitioner, the said mistake was noted recently and hence the application for amendment. The petitioner had also pointed out that the trial court dismissed the injunction application as there is a discrepancy in the description of the property in the sale agreement as well as in the sale deed and that the amendment has to be effected as the mistake in the description is a bona fide mistake. All the applications filed under O.6 , Rule 17 of the Civil Procedure Code read with Sec.151 of the Civil Procedure Code were resisted by the respondent herein and the District Judge, by a common order dated 29.10.1996 dismissed all the applications.
4. Mr. K.Sarva Bhauman, Senior Counsel for the revision petitioner raised very many contentions and contended that on facts, the amendment applied for should have been allowed as the amendment will not introduce a new case, that it will alter the suit, and that the first appellate Court should not have gone into the merits of amendment while deciding the amendment application. The learned counsel also contended that the order passed by the first appellate Court amounts to failure to exercise the jurisdiction vested in it and that the order passed by the District Court has be set aside in those revisions.
5. Mr. Nandhakumar appearing for the respondent in all the revisions contended that no interference is called for.
6. The merits of amendment will not be taken into consideration while deciding the amendment application and this is a well-settled proposition. In the present case, the amendment though belated, cannot be suggested that it would amount to change in the cause of action or it would change the character of the suit. However, this Court is not expressing any final opinion in this respect.
7. The main question arising for consideration in the pres