2016 Supreme(Mad) 2900
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
A. SELVAM AND P. KALAIYARASAN, JJ.
Vanitha - Appellant
Vs.
State by the Inspector of Police Annamalai Nagar Police Station Cuddalore District - Respondent
Criminal Appeal No. 443 of 2016
Decided On : 08-09-2016
Important Points
Subject
Criminal Law - Murder
Act Referred
INDIAN PENAL CODE : S.302
Headnote
Criminal Appeal - Conviction and Sentence - Indian Penal Code - Section 302 - Summary of Acts and Sections: IPC Section 302 - The court discussed the evidence based on circumstantial evidence, including the accused's illicit intimacy with the deceased and the circumstances pointing towards the accused's guilt. The court also considered the confession statement, material objects recovered, and expert testimonies. The conviction and sentence were confirmed based on the overwhelming evidence.
Fact of the Case:
The case involved the conviction and sentence of the accused for the murder of a Sub Inspector of Police. The prosecution's case was based on circumstantial evidence, including the accused's illicit intimacy with the deceased and the circumstances leading to the murder. The accused denied the charge and claimed to be tried.
Finding of the Court:
The court found the accused guilty under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code based on the overwhelming evidence presented by the prosecution, including circumstantial evidence, confession statement, material objects, and expert testimonies.
Issues: The issues included the lack of direct eyewitnesses, the reliance on circumstantial evidence, and the validity of the confession statement as evidence.
Ratio Decidendi: The court relied on the evidence of illicit intimacy between the accused and the deceased, the circumstances pointing towards the accused's guilt, and the expert testimonies to confirm the conviction and sentence.
Final Decision: The Criminal Appeal was dismissed, and the conviction and sentence passed against the appellant/accused were confirmed.
For the Appellant : Mr. A. Arasu Ganesan
For the Respondent: Mr. E. Raja.
A. SELVAM, J.
1. Challenge in this Criminal Appeal is to the conviction and sentence dated 23.03.2016 passed in Sessions Case No. 287 of 2014 by the Additional District and Sessions Court, Chidambaram.
2. The case of the prosecution is that at the time of occurrence, the deceased, viz., Ganesan has served as Sub Inspector of Police in Annamalai Nagar Police Station. During tenure of his service, the accused, by name, Vanitha has had acquaintance with him and with an intention to marry the deceased, she divorced her husband and very often both of them have used to live as husband and wife in the house of the deceased. On 9.7.2014, the deceased has married one Sathya. After knowing the factum of marriage, with an intention to murder the deceased, on 21.7.2014, the accused has come to the house of the deceased and on 22.7.2014, at about 20.00 hours, the accused has impelled the deceased to consume liquor and accordingly, he has taken the same. Taking advantage of sozzle mood of the deceased, she placed him on a cot and subsequently by using a knife, she attacked him indiscriminately and due to her overtacts, he passed away.
3. After occurrence, one Govindasami (P.W.1) has given a complaint to the Sub Inspector of Police (P.W.18) and the same has been registered in Crime No.205 of 2014. The complaint alleged to have been given by him has been marked as Ex.P.1.
4. On receipt of Ex.P.1, the Investigating Officer, viz., P.W.24, has taken up investigation, examined the connected witnesses and also collected relevant materials. The Investigating Officer has also made arrangements for conducting autopsy on the body of the deceased and accordingly, Dr.Abirami (P.W.14) has conducted Post Mortem and She found the following external and internal injuries:-
“External Injuries:-
(i) 6 x 3 x 4cm cut injury rt. side of chin exposing mandible
(ii) 3 x 1 x2 cm cut injury at junction of chin & neck exposing neck muscle
(iii) 8 x 4 x 5 cm cut injury on center of neck extending from midline of neck towards rt.shoulder exposing clavicle. Muscles seen exposed & major vessels of the neck cut.
(iv) 12 x 5 x 10 cm cut injury over rt.side of neck
(v) 12 x 4 x 10 cm cut injury below injury no.4
(vi) 7 x 5 x 4cm cut injury over manubrium of sternum
(vii) 13 x 7 x 8 cm cut injury below rt.shoulder
(viii) 6 x 3 x 7 cm laceration above injury No.7
(ix) 19 x 7 x bone depth (right shoulder) cut injury (humerus bone exposed)
(x) 4 x 1 x 2cm cut injury rt.upper arum (upper region 1/3)
(xi) Lt.Hand: 3rd, 4th, 5th fingers cut & broken. Index finger amputated
(xii) cut injury 6 x 1 x 2 cm between ring finger & dorsum of hand
(xiii) cut injury 9 x 1 x 3 cm between the finger and dorsum of hand Rt side of neck:
(xiv) 7 x 2 x 4 cm horizontal cut injury
(xv) 6 x 1 x 2 cm horizontal cut injury below rt. ear -prone position
(xvi) 17 x 4 x 4 cm cut injury extending from about 5 cm below nape of neck
(xvii) 3 x 1/2 x 2 cm cut injury -three in number over lt. shoulder
(xviii) 10 x 3 x 3 cm cut injury from midline of neck to rt. side of neck
Internal examination:
Upper end of sternum cut. Thorax cavity filled with blood. Ribs intact. Heart intact. pale, chambers empty, Lungs- intact, congested, liver, kidney, spleen, intestine pale, intact, stomach-intact, pale, filled with dark brown fluid about 200ml. Hyoid bone preserved. Bladder intact, empty pelvis intact. skull intact. Brain, membranes-pale”
The Post Mortem Certificate has been marked as Ex.P.8.
5. The Investigating Officer has conducted further investigation and after completing the same, laid a final report on the file of the Judicial Magistrate Court No. I, Chidambaram and the same has been taken on file in P.R.C.No.26 of 2014.
6. The Judicial Magistrate No.1, Chidambaram, after considering the fact that the offence alleged to have been committed by the accused is triable by Sessions Court, has committed the case to the Court of Sessions, Cuddalore Division and the same has been taken on file in Sessions Case No.287 of 2014 and subsequ