2019 Supreme(Mad) 2433
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
Deepak Gupta, Aniruddha Bose, JJ.
Krishna Prasad Verma (D) Thr. Lrs. - Appellant
Versus
State of Bihar & Others - Respondent
Civil Appeal No. 8950 of 2011
Decided On : 26-09-2019
Important Points
Subject
Judicial Independence - Disciplinary Proceedings
Act Referred
NARCOTIC DRUGS AND PSYCHOTROPIC SUBSTANCES ACT : S.22, S.23, S.24
Headnote
Independence of Judiciary - Article 235 of the Constitution of India - [Charge-1, Charge-2] - The judgment discusses the independence and fearlessness expected from the judiciary at all levels, emphasizing that disciplinary action should not be initiated solely based on wrong orders unless there is evidence of extraneous reasons. The court refers to various cases and legal principles to highlight the importance of protecting honest judicial officers and maintaining judicial independence. The judgment sets a precedent that disciplinary proceedings should not be initiated solely on the basis of incorrect orders, without clear allegations of misconduct or extraneous influences.
Fact of the Case:
The appellant, a judicial officer, faced two charges related to granting bail and closing evidence in a criminal case. The charges alleged extraneous considerations, gross judicial impropriety, and lack of integrity.
Finding of the Court:
The court found that the appellant's actions did not amount to misconduct or gross judicial impropriety. It highlighted the lack of evidence of extraneous reasons and emphasized the importance of protecting judicial officers from unwarranted disciplinary actions.
Issues: The issues revolved around the appellant's alleged misconduct in granting bail and closing evidence, and whether such actions warranted disciplinary proceedings.
Ratio Decidendi: The court established that disciplinary action should not be initiated solely based on incorrect orders unless there are clear allegations of misconduct or extraneous influences. It emphasized the need to protect honest judicial officers and maintain judicial independence.
Final Decision: The court allowed the appeal, set aside the judgment of the High Court, and quashed all orders against the appellant, directing the appellant to be given all consequential benefits.
JUDGMENT :
Deepak Gupta, J.
In a country, which follows the Rule of Law, independence of the judiciary is sacrosanct. There can be no Rule of Law, there can be no democracy unless there is a strong, fearless and independent judiciary. This independence and fearlessness is not only expected at the level of the Superior Courts but also from the District judiciary.
2. Most litigants only come in contact with the District judiciary. They cannot afford to come to the High Court or the Supreme Court. For them the last word is the word of the Magistrate or at best the Sessions Judge. Therefore, it is equally important, if not more important, that the judiciary at the District Level and at the Taluka level is absolutely honest, fearless and free from any pressure and is able to decide cases only on the basis of the facts on file, uninfluenced by any pressure from any quarters whatsoever.
3. Article 235 of the Constitution of India vests control of the subordinate Courts upon the High Courts. The High Courts exercise disciplinary powers over the subordinate Courts. In a series of judgments, this Court has held that the High Courts are also the protectors and guardians of the judges falling within their administrative control. Time and time again, this Court has laid down the criteria on which actions should be taken against judicial officers. Repeatedly, this Court has cautioned the High Courts that action should not be taken against judicial officers only because wrong orders are passed. To err is human and not one of us, who has held judicial office, can claim that we have never passed a wrong order.
4. No doubt, there has to be zero tolerance for corruption and if there are allegations of corruption, misconduct or of acts unbecoming a judicial officer, these must be dealt with strictly. However, if wrong orders are passed that should not lead to disciplinary action unless there is evidence that the wrong orders have been passed for extraneous reasons and not because of the reasons on the file.
5. We do not want to refer to too many judgments because this position has been laid down in a large number of cases but it would be pertinent to refer to the observations of this Court in Ishwar Chand Jain Vs. High Court of Punjab & Haryana and another ((1988) 3 SCC 370), wherein this Court held as follows:
"14. Under the Constitution the High Court has control over the subordinate judiciary. While exercising that control it is under a constitutional obligation to guide and protect judicial officers. An honest strict judicial officer is likely to have adversaries in the mofussil courts. If complaints are entertained on trifling matters relating to judicial orders which may have been upheld by the High Court on the judicial side no judicial officer would feel protected and it would be difficult for him to discharge his duties in an honest and independent manner. An independent and honest judiciary is a sine qua non for rule of law. If judicial officers are under constant threat of complaint and enquiry on trifling matters and if High Court encourages anonymous complaints to hold the field the subordinate judiciary will not be able to administer justice in an independent and honest manner. It is therefore imperative that the High Court should also take steps to protect its honest officers by ignoring ill-conceived or motivated complaints made by the unscrupulous lawyers and litigants. Having regard to facts and circumstances of the instant case we have no doubt in our mind that the resolution passed by the Bar Association against the appellant was wholly unjustified and the complaints made by Shri Mehlawat and others were motivated which did not deserve any credit. Even the vigilance Judge after holding enquiry did not record any finding that the appellant was guilty of any corrupt motive or that he had not acted judicially. All that was said against him was that he had acted improperly in granting adjournments."