2019 Supreme(Mad) 3024
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADRAS
R. Subbiah, C. Saravanan, JJ.
Seshadri S. and Ors. – Appellants
Versus
Andhra Social & Cultural Association and Ors. – Respondents
O.S.A. Nos. 452, 476 of 2018, C.M.P. Nos. 20739, 22859 of 2018, C.M.P. Nos. 3614, 3638, 5542 and 12352 of 2019
Decided On : 04-10-2019
Advocate Appeared:
For the Appellant : S. Thanka Sivan and B. Ravi
For the Respondent: G.R.M. Palaniappa, P.L. Narayanan, M.A. Gouthaman and Praveen for Rank Associates
Headnote:
Tamil Nadu Societies Registration Act, 1975 – Sake of clarity court – For the sake of brevity – For a permanent injunction restraining the defendant – For a declaration declaring – Calling for convening – Since some of the parties to the suits/appeals are common but their ranks differ in the suits and in these appeals, for the sake of clarity court shall be referring to their names to avoid confusion – All the above mentioned three suits were filed by the members the Andhra Social and Cultural Association – Andhra Social and Cultural Association is a society registered under the provisions of the Tamil Nadu Societies Registration Act, 1975 – For the sake of brevity, Andhra Social and Cultural Association shall be referred to as "Association/Club" interchangeably – Said Association runs a cultural club in the city of Chennai for its members sharing common cultural and linguistic background –Held, Applications were actively supported by the appellant himself – What is complained the present appeal is the consequences flowing from the order of the learned single judge after the appellant also participated in the meeting conducted by the learned Judge Commissioner pursuant to order as modified by an order which at best may have given to a separate cause of action but not reason – Convoluted and myriad legal submissions made to assail the judgment and decree of the learned single judge do not impress us – Fact that the appeal has been filed and not before also clearly establishes that the attempt of the appellant is to dismantle and deconstruct the decision of the majority in the Extraordinary General Meeting held under the supervision of the Learned Judge Commissioner after acquiring into it – Court are therefore of the view that the present attempt of the appellant in O.S.A to scuttle the election proceedings and to prolong the litigation after the majority of the members present at the meeting held defeated the concerted effort of the appellant and some of the members of the managing committee and few others cannot be allowed – Appeals are dismissed.
JUDGMENT :
C. Saravanan, J.
1. By this common judgment these two appeals are being disposed.
2. These two appeals arise of out a common judgment and decree dated 24.07.2018 passed by the learned single judge in three suits as detailed below:-
Table : 1
| O.S.A. No. 476 of 2018 | |||
| Sl. No. | Case No. | Status of the Parties | |
| 1. | C.S. No. 758/2015 | Plaintiff | Defendants and their ranks |
| Narasa Reddy Kondiapudi | 1. Andra Social and Cultural Association. | ||
|
| 2. M.S.Moorthy* | ||
| 3. Dr.K. Subha Reddy** | |||
| 2. | O.S.A.No.476/2018 | Appellant | Respondents |
| M.S. Moorthy (2nd Defedant) | 1. Narasa Reddy Kondiapudi (Plaintiff) | ||
|
| 2. Andra Social and Cultural Association (1st defendant) | ||
| 3. Dr. K.Subha Reddy (3rd defendant) | |||
| * Impleaded vide order dated 04.04.2018 in Appln.No.1547 of 2018. | |||
| ** Impleaded vide order dated 04.04.2018 in Appln.No.8399 of 2017. | |||
Table :2
| No appeal has been filed against this C.S. | |||
| O.S.A. | Case No. | Plaintiff | Defendants and their ranks |
| Nil | C.S.No. 278/2017 | 1. K.V.N. Prasad Reddy. | 1. Andhra Social and Cultural Association. |
| 2. Lakshmi Krishna Prasad. | 2. Dr. K.Subha Reddy. | ||
Table:3
| O.S.A. No. 452 of 2018 | |||
| Sl. No. | Case No. | Status of the Parties | |
| 1. | Tr.C.S.No.170 of 2018 (formerly O.S.No.5459 of 2017 before the XVI Assistant City Civil Court, Chennai) | Plaintiff | Defendant and their ranks |
| S. Seshadri | 1. Andhra Social and Cultural Association | ||
|
| 2. B. Sridhar Reddy.* | ||
| 2. | O.S.A. No. 452 of 2018 | S.Seshadri | 1. Andhra Social and Cultural Association. |
| 2. B. Sridhar Reddy. | |||
| 3. Narasa Reddy Kondlapudi.** | |||
| 4. R4 to R27*** | |||
| * Impleaded vide order dated 04.04.2018 in Appln.No. 2535 of 2018. | |||
| ** Impleaded vide order dated 07.12.2018 in CMP No. 22031 of 2018 in CMP.No. 20739 of 2018 in O.S.A.No. 452 of 2018. | |||
| *** Impleaded vide order dated 01.02.2019 in CMP.No. 2667 of 2019 in O.S.A.No. 452 of 2018. | |||
3. In O.S.A. No. 452 of 2018, the appellant Mr. S. Seshadri has challenged judgment and decree dated 24.07.2018 passed in Tr. C.S. No. 170 of 2018 (formerly O.S. No. 5459 of 2017 before the XVI Assistant City Civil Court) as modified by an order dated 28.09.2018 in Review Application No. 6769 of 2018 by the learned Single Judge.
4. Though C.S. No. 665 of 2015 filed by one Chagarlamudi Gandhi also pertains to the same dispute, it was not clubbed for being taken up for hearing before the Learned Single Judge.
5. In O.S.A. No. 476 of 2018, the appellant Mr. M.S. Moorty/2nd defendant in C.S. No. 758 of 2015 has challenged judgment and decree passed in C.S. No. 758 of 2015.
6. Since some of the parties to the suits/appeals are common but their ranks differ in the suits and in these appeals, for the sake of clarity we shall be referring to their names to avoid confusion.
7. All the above mentioned three suits were filed by the members the Andhra Social and Cultural Association. Andhra Social and Cultural Association is a society registered under the provisions of the Tamil Nadu Societies Registration Act, 1975.
8. For the sake of brevity, Andhra Social and Cultural Association shall be referred to as "Association/Club" interchangeably. The said Association runs a cultural club in the city of Chennai for its members sharing common cultural and linguistic background.
9. Dispute arose between the parties on account of certain events surrounding bye-laws No. 5(n) of the Association/Club and on account of induction of 89 persons as members at a concessional membership joining fee by 45 parent members. Bye-law No. 5 (n) of the Association/Club allows a parent member (regular member) of the club to nominate his son or son-in-law to be admitted as a regular memb