IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS
V. PARTHIBAN, J.
Haridas Purushothamdas @ P. Haridas – Appellant
Versus
Estate of Krishnadas Purushothamdas, Rep. by Bharat Kumar K. Shah & Others – Respondents
C.S. No. 115 of 2021 & O.A. No. 175 of 2021
Decided on : 30-09-2021
Civil Procedure Code, 1908 - Order IV Rule 1, Order XXIV Rule 1, Order VII Rule 1 - Property case - Partition - Permanent injunction - Plaint filed praying for the judgment and decree against the defendants - Whether appeal is maintainable - Held, Insofar as the second prayer (b) in the plaint seeking for permanent injunction, is concerned, the same does not arise, in view of the consent given by the parties for 1/3 share each - It is to be noted that the parties have paid necessary stamp duty/Court fee in respect of their respective shares allotted now in the partition of the suit property - Parties shall file application for appointment of Advocate Commissioner to divide the property into three equal halves by metes and bounds and to allot the respective shares to them - Case closed
JUDGMENT :
(Prayer: Plaint filed under Order IV Rule 1 with Order XXIV Rule 1 of the Original Side Rules of this Court read with Order VII Rule 1 of the Civil Procedure Code and the suit numbered as C.S.No.115 of 2021, praying for the judgment and decree against the defendants as under:
(a) For a preliminary decree declaring that the plaintiff is entitled to 1/3 share in the suit schedule property and effect division of the property by appointing an Advocate Commissioner to divide the immovable property of family into three equal shares and allot 1/3 share to the plaintiff;
(b) For permanent injunction restraining the defendants, their men, servants, agents, or any persons claiming under them from in any manner interfering with possession and enjoyment of the suit property by plaintiffs by way of sale, mortgage, charge or lease or joint development, of the suit property or encumbering or alienating or altering the suit schedule property by way of change the topography/physical features of the suit property except in accordance with law, and
(c) for costs of the suit.
Schedule
All that piece and parcel of vacant land with trees thereon ad-measuring 6606 Square Feet as per documents (as per Computer patta ad-measuring 6576 Square Feet in T.S.No.2/2, O.S.No.170/A in name of Ramaben @ Ramabai Ramdas, late wife of Ramdas Purushothamdas) in “Gokul Bagh”, situated in Block No.14, T.S.No.2, R.S.No.170/1, Part in No.107, Arumbakkam Village, Poonamallee High Road, Chennai-600 106, measuring North to South on the Eastern side 131’-6”, North to South on the Western Side 131’-0”, East to West on Northern Side 50’-6” and East to West on the Southern side 50”-9”, bounded on the North; Part of T.S.No.2/2 (R.S.No.170/1) and Poonamallee High Road; South by: T.S.No.3, Block No.14, and on the East by: Seth Purushothamdas Gokuldas Road, and West by: Dwaraka Doss Goverdhan Doss Vaishnav College, within the Registration District of Kodambakkam, and Registration District of Chennai Central.)
1. Though the Original Application is listed for hearing, considering the submissions made on either side and in view of the consent given by the parties for partition of the respective shares in the suit property, as stated infra, by amicably settling the issue among themselves, the present suit itself is taken up for hearing and is being disposed of by this judgment.
2. The case of the plaintiff as culled out form the plaint is as follows:
(b) Under partition deed, dated 01.04.1964, Late Ramdas Purushothamdas was allotted properties mentioned in the Schedule C-2, therein. During his life time, the properties allotted under the partition deed, were sold by Ramdas Purushothamdas, except for three grounds of vacant land/site in “Gokul Bagh” as described in the schedule of property.
(c) Shri.Bharat Kumar K.Shah, son of Late Krishnadas Purushothamdas, second defendant herein, taking advantage of bedridden sickness of his father and his fiduciary relationship among family members, gave portion of the land (3500 square feet or thereabouts in T.S.No.2, R.S.No.170/1 Part out of the three grounds of land) in the said Gokul Bagh, to Rotary Club of Madras South West for running of Down’s Research Society (India). Since the above said project failed, by 2014, late Krishnadas Purushothamdas become very sick, with the result, the above said Shri.Bharat Kumar K.Shah, had taken over the affairs of Late Krishnadas Purushothamdas.
(d) The said Shri.Bharat Kumar K.Shah, being the son of Late Krishnadas Purushothamdas, during the illness of Late Krishnadas Purushothamdas, took custody of title dee
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.