SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

1955 Supreme(Ori) 19

HIGH COURT OF ORISSA
Panigrahi, C. J. , Mohapatra And Misra, JJ.
STATE - Appellant
Versus
NRUSINGHA NAIK - Respondent
Civil Ref.  6  Of  1954
Decided On : MARCH 23, 1955

Important Points

A pleader is not entitled to retain the moneys of his client and claim a lien to hold it until his own accounts are settled.

Subject

LEGAL PROFESSION - PROFESSIONAL MISCONDUCT

Act Referred

CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE : O.8 R.6
LEGAL PRACTITIONERS ACT : S.13
LEGAL PRACTITIONERS FEES ACT : S.3, S.4, S.5

Headnote

LEGAL PRACTITIONERS ACT - SECTION 14 - PROFESSIONAL MISCONDUCT - PLEADER RETAINING DECRETAL AMOUNT WITHOUT CLIENT'S CONSENT - APPROPRIATION OF MONEY - LIEN - DUTY OF PLEADER TO KEEP ACCOUNTS AND INFORM CLIENT OF RECEIPT OF MONEY - RULES OF ETIQUETTE FOR COUNSEL'S FEES.

Fact of the Case:

A pleader, Nrusingh Naik, was accused of professional misconduct for retaining Rs. 9/- from a decree-holder, Gajindra Das, without his consent. The pleader claimed that he had adjusted the amount towards his fees, but the decree-holder denied this. The District Judge held that the pleader should not have behaved in the way he had done, but recommended that the proceedings be dropped as the pleader had tendered an apology.

Finding of the Court:

The court held that the pleader was guilty of professional misconduct in having acted in a manner not in keeping with the duties of his profession. The court found that the pleader had not followed the proper procedure in holding the enquiry against the pleader and that he should have summoned the complainant as a witness at state expense. The court also found that the pleader's plea that the decree-holder had agreed to adjust his fees out of realizations was not supported by evidence.

Issues: 1. Whether the pleader was guilty of professional misconduct in retaining the decretal amount without the client's consent. 2. Whether the pleader had a lien on the decretal amount for his fees. 3. Whether the pleader had a duty to keep accounts and inform the client of the receipt of money.

Ratio Decidendi: 1. A pleader is not entitled to retain the moneys of his client and claim a lien to hold it until his own accounts are settled. 2. A pleader has no right to appropriate his client's money in exercise of the lien. 3. A pleader has a duty to keep accounts of his client's transactions and to inform the client of the receipt of money.

Final Decision: The court reprimanded the pleader and ordered him to pay the hearing fee of the Advocate-General.

Advocates Appeared:
R.N.SINHA

PANIGRAHI, C. J.

( 1 ) THIS is a reference made by the District Judge of Cuttack, under Section 14, legal Practitioners Act, against the opposite party, Nrusingh Naik, a pleader practising at Jajpur. The proceedings Were started on the complaint of one gajindra Das who had engaged the pleader for executing a small cause court decree obtained by him against Chintamoni Dora. The complainant, Gajindra Das, alleged that one Sukhadeb samal, the registered clerk of a pleader named Mukund charan Panda, realised Rs. 35/-from the judgment debtor and misappropriated the same. He further complained that he engaged the opposite party Nrusingh naik to execute his decree and that in the course of the execution the pleader had realised Rs. 9/-, but suppressed the payment made by the judgment-debtor from him (the decree-holder) and appropriated the same. The complainant then made enquiries and came to know that the pleader had actually received Rs. 9/- in the course of execution. He made a complaint to the bar Association, and thereafter reported the matter to the Munsif, but no action having been taken by the Munsif a petition was sent to this court on 18-1-1954, whereupon an enquiry was started. During the enquiry the pleader paid up the sum of Rs. 9/- to the complainant and produced a receipt dated 30-8-1954. When notice of the enquiry was served upon the complainant a petition dated 17-9-1954 was sent by the complainant to the Court pleading inability to attend the enquiry and praying that the proceedings !be dropped.

( 2 ) THE learned District Judge held that the pleader, Nrusingh Naik "should not have behaved with his client in the way he had done" but as he had tendered an apology, he recommended that the proceedings may be dropped.

( 3 ) THE plea taken by the opposite party is that he filed two execution petitions on behalf of the complainant-decree-holder, in Execution cases Nps. 188 of 1952 and 186 of 1953, and that he received Rs. 9/- on behalf of the decree-holder in the earlier Execution case No, 188 of 1952. He retained this amount as the decree-holder had agreed that he would adjust it towards his fees. He further says that he offered the amount to Gajindra Das in August or September 1953, but the decree-holder went away without making any adjustment towards his fee. He also expressed regret and tendered an apology and pleaded "good faith' in having retained the amount.

( 4 ) IT must be stated at the outset that the learned District Judge has not followed the proper procedure in holding the enquiry against the pleader. He ought to have framed a charge specifying the details of the alleged act of professional misconduct, and examined both the complainant and the accused to satisfy himself whether the one or the other version is correct. The complainant no doubt pleaded inability to incur any further expense in connection with the enquiry, but the District Judge should have summoned him as a witness at state expense, and given him an opportunity to prove the charge. It must be remembered that charges of professional misconduct should not be allowed to be made against a pleader on frivolous grounds. If the complaint made by the decree-holder was found to be substantially untrue, it was open to the District Judge to order his prosecution. Conversely, if his complaint was substantially true, the mere fact that the money retained by the pleader was subsequently repaid does not in any way extenuate the offence committed by the pleader. Apart from the civil liability of the pleader to return the money realised by him on behalf of his client, the court is bound to enquire into the misconduct of the pleader in the discharge of his professional duties, so that the prestige of the legal profession may be kept unsullied. Whenever a charge of professional misconduct is made against an officer of the court, it ceases to be a dispute between the litigant and his pleader. The court is bound to protect the reputation of the legal profession





















1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top