HIGH COURT OF ORISSA: CUTTACK
SHRI V. GOPALA GOWDA AND B.N. MAHAPATRA, JJ.
Sri Subas Singh and others – Petitioners
Versus
State of Orissa and others - Opposite Parties
W.P. (C) NO. 3369 OF 2010
Decided On : 20.12.2012
Compared with the increase in population, the number of buses is also increasing. Due to increase in number of buses, more space is required for parking of the buses so also various other amenities are required, such as, shelter to the commuters and rest rooms etc. for passengers. On the other hand, the extent of land earmarked for bus stand is not increasing rather the same remains constant. Therefore, the land already earmarked for bus stand should not be sold or leased out to any private party causing prejudice to the larger interest of general public. Opposite party-authorities instead of selling/ leasing out the property earmarked for bus-stand to private party for its commercial use, should take steps to make for its commercial use, should take steps to make model bus-stands in a planned manner and provide all necessary facilities for parking of more number of buses arid amenities to the passengers and also provide commercial accommodations to restaurants and other allied facilities so as to render better services to the commuters as the bus-stand has link with the State Transport Service. (Paras - 15 and 16)
2. JUDICIAL REVIEW - Courts have very limited power of judicial review in the matter of policy decision of the Government - At the same time, Courts have constitutional duty and responsibility in exercise of their power of judicial review to see that constitutional goals set down in the preamble; the Fundamental Rights and Directive Principles of the Constitution are achieved. (Para - 20)
3. CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, 1950 - Art. 226 - Policy decision of Government - When the Court is satisfied that there is substantial amount of public interest the Court should intervene under the Article. (Para - 21)
4. ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - Government has to rise above the nexus of vested interests and nepotism and eschew window - dressing - The principle of governance has to be tested on the touchstone of justice, equity and fair play and if the decision is not based on justice, equity and fair play and has taken into consideration other matters, though on the fact of it, the decision may look legitimate but as a matter of fact, the reasons are not based on values but to achieve popular accolade; that decision cannot be allowed to operate. (Para - 25)
Judgment
B.N. MAHAPATRA, J.
By means of the present writ petition, challenge has been made to the decision of the opposite party-authorities for leasing out the land, building and other infrastructure of Badambadi Bus Stand, Cuttack in favour of opposite party No.4-Reliance Retail Ltd. (for short, ‘RRL’) on the ground that such decision is illegal, unwarranted and uncalled for, and against the interest of the people of State of Odisha, more particularly the people of Cuttack.
2. The present writ petition has been filed in the nature of public interest litigation. Petitioner No.1 is a social worker and a Trade Unionist and also the Convener of the “Cuttack Banchao Committee”, which has been formed in the year 2005 and since then it has been taking the issues relating to the interest of the people. Petitioner No.2 is a renowned person of Cuttack and presently is the President of Utkal Sahitya Samaja. He is associated with various social organizations and is also one of the functionaries of Cuttack Banchao Committee. Petitioner No.3 is an eminent educationist and former Vice-Chancellor of Berhampur University and also associated with different social organizations and activities concerning the public issues. Thus, all the petitioners claim to be public spirited persons.
3. Petitioners’ case is that Badambadi Bus-Stand situates in both sides of the road which is called “Link Road” measuring about 50 acres of land belonging to State Government. The Bus stand was established in the early part of 1970 by the State Government. At that point of time, Government was owner of two main Transport Corporations, namely, Orissa Road Transport Corporation (ORT) and Orissa State Road Transport Corporation (for short ‘OSRTC’) which were plying their buses from Badambadi Bus Stand. Besides the Government Corporation owned buses, some private buses were plying from Badambadi Bus Stand when the bus stand was established. Initially, Badambadi Bus Stand was planned to provide parking place for 100 buses in the early 1970. By efflux of time, number of buses increased and many private buses came to ply. Practically, there are three bus stands, namely, main bus stand, Rourkela-Angul bus stand and Puri-Bhubaneswar bus stand. All the bus -stands were being maintained by the State opposite parties and the private buses were plying from the said bus stands on payment of prescribed fees and were enjoying the facilities on quid pro quo basis. At present, about 2200 buses are plying from Badambadi Bus stand to different parts of Odisha. Out of that, 1000 buses are express buses, which reach Badambadi in the morning and mostly park on the road side. Apart from that, about 4000 auto rickshaws, 200 taxies and about 1000 town buses are operating daily from Badambadi Bus Stand. Thus, more than 7000 vehicles are operating from Badambadi Bus Stand everyday catering to the need of the people and provide private transport facilities. In the year 2006, petitioners came to know that the State Government has taken a decision to sell out/lease out the land of five Bus stands of the State, such as, Cuttack, Dhenkanal, Sundargarh, Berhampur and Baripada to private parties and also to handover the maintenance of those bus-stands, which was seriously objected by the Social Organizations at the relevant point of time. In the year 2008, members of the Cuttack Banchao Committee had taken up the issues with the State Government for making the Bus stand a model and planned one under control of the State Government and also to provide all other necessary facilities for parking of the buses and amenities to the passengers as Badambadi Bus stand is linked with the State Transport and it is the prime Bus stand of the State. The petitioner-Cuttack Banchao Committee protesting the transfer of Badambadi Bus Stand staged a two days’ day and night Dharana on 3rd and th December, 2008. A similar Dharana was also staged on 28th February, 2009 for development of Badambadi Bus Stand and for oppos
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.