SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2002 Supreme(Ori) 561

IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA
L. Mohapatra, J.
SRI RAMANATH DAS (DEAD) AFTER HIM RATIKANTA DAS AND ANOTHER - APPELLANT
Versus
SMT. JASODA DAS AND OTHERS - RESPONDENT
Second Appeal No. 66 of 1987
Decided On : 29-08-2002

Important Points

The main legal point established in the judgment is the determination of property rights based on the family genealogy, partition of properties, and the validity of the sale deed executed by Manguli in favor of Dhani.

Subject

Property Law - Partition and Ownership Disputes

Headnote

Partition - Property Dispute - Ext.B - The court discussed the family genealogy and the claims of the Plaintiffs-Respondents 1 and 2 for partition of the properties. The court found that the properties were not partitioned between the parties and that the sale deed executed by Manguli in favor of Dhani was not genuine, valid, and legal. The properties left by Krushna devolved to the branch of Raghu, and the suit was allowed. The appeal was dismissed based on similar findings. The substantial questions of law for adjudication included the acquisition of property by Siba and Dhani, the entitlement of the Plaintiffs to impugn the sale deed, and the validity of Ext.B. The court upheld the findings of the lower courts and dismissed the appeal.

Fact of the Case:

The suit was filed for partition of the properties claimed by the Plaintiffs-Respondents 1 and 2. The court found that the properties were not partitioned between the parties and that the sale deed executed by Manguli in favor of Dhani was not genuine, valid, and legal. The properties left by Krushna devolved to the branch of Raghu, and the suit was allowed. The appeal was dismissed based on similar findings.

Finding of the Court:

The court found that the properties were not partitioned between the parties and that the sale deed executed by Manguli in favor of Dhani was not genuine, valid, and legal. The properties left by Krushna devolved to the branch of Raghu, and the suit was allowed. The appeal was dismissed based on similar findings.

Issues: The issues included the acquisition of property by Siba and Dhani, the entitlement of the Plaintiffs to impugn the sale deed, and the validity of Ext.B.

Ratio Decidendi: The court upheld the findings of the lower courts regarding the partition of properties and the validity of the sale deed executed by Manguli in favor of Dhani.

Final Decision: The appeal was dismissed based on similar findings of the lower courts.

Advocates Appeared:
S. Misra, B. Das, S. Montry, R.C. Rath, K. Kar and A.K. Misra, for the Appellant; M. Patra, U.C. Patnaik, D.R. Mohapatra, M.R. Patra, S.K. Ray, B.K. Deo, A.K. Patra, P.K. Rout, P.N. Sahoo, D. Patra and K.T. Rao, for the Respondent

JUDGMENT :

L. Mohapatra, J. - Defendants 1 and 2 are the Appellants before this Court against a confirming judgment. The suit was filed by the Respondents 1 and 2 for partition of the kha Ga and Gha schedule properties claiming half share therein.

2. Before discussing of the respective cases of the parties, the family genealogy which is not in dispute is given below:

Nidhi Das

_________|____________

| |

Ragnu Das Krushna Das/W-Mangult

/ Baina Das (son)

/

__________________/____________

| | |

Hari Das Siba Das Dhani Das

/ /

/ /

Kali - son /

/ __________/___________

/ | |

/ Ramanath Das Priyanath Das

_____________/____________

| |

W-Subhadra Jasoda (daughter)

Plff. No. 1 Plff. No. 2

3. The case of the Plaintiffs-Respondents 1 and 2 is that Nidhi is the common ancestor of the family of the Plaintiffs and defendants 1 and 2. He had two sons, namely, Raghu and Krushna. Raghu and Krushna got separated prior to current settlement and were living in separate mess and property. Raghu left behind his three sons namely. Han. Siba and Dhani. Hari died as bachelor. Siba had one son namely. Kali whose wife is Subhadra (Plaintiff No. 1) and Jasoda is the daughter of Kali (Plaintiff No 2). Dhani had two sons namely. Ramanath Das and Priyanath Das who are defendants 1 and 2. The case of the Plaintiffs is that Krushna Das had one son namely. Baina and at the time of his death he had left his wife Manguli. After death of Krushna the properties developed upon Baina and after death of Baina. Manguli became the owner of the properties. After death of Manguli the properties devolved to the branch of Ragnu by survivorship and the Plaintiffs No. 1 being the wife of grand son of Raghu is also entitled to a share in the properties of Krushna which was received by the Dranch of Raghu by way of survivorship. The further case of the Plaintiffs is that Siba Das and Dhani Das were living in joint mess and property and after death of Siba. Dhani became the karta of the family as Kali Das was minor by that time. Dhani fatner of defendants 1 and 2, was looking after the properties as Karta of the family and taking advantage of minority of Kali managed to record specific share in the record of rights in the current settlement though both Kali and Dhani were living in joint mess and property during current settlement operation. In the year 1934, there was some ill feeling between Kali and defendant Nos. 1 and 2 for which they were possessing lands separately according to their convenience and after death of Kali, Plaintiffs No. 1 came to know that some more lands out of the joint family properties have been recorded in the name of Dhani Das, father of the defendants 1 and 2 though Dhani was not entitled to the same and accordingly, the suit was filed.

4. Defendants 3, 4 and 5 did not contest the suit and were ex parte. Defendants 1 and 2 filed their written statement stating that Dhani and Kali had been separated prior to current settlement and they were living separately and because of such separation the properties have also been separately recorded in the current settlement. The further case of the defendants 1 and 2 is that after death of Krushna the wife of Manguli transferred the entire share of Krushna in favour of their father Dhani and he was in possession of the entire properties that had fallen to the share of Krushna The Plaintiffs claim to the properties left by Krushna on the ground that it came to the branch of Raghu by surveyors was denied.

5. On the above pleadings of the parties, the learned Addl. Subordinate Judge, Balasore framed since nine issues. The learned Addl. Sub-Judge found that the properties were not partitioned by metes and bounds between Siba, Dhani or Kali and accordingly there was no partition between the Plaintiffs and defendants 1 and 2. He also found that the defendants measurably failed to prove that the saie deed dated 14.2.22 executed by Kamali alias Manguli in favo













1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top