2009 Supreme(Ori) 801
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA
Indrajit Mahanty, J.
L.P. ELECTRONICS (O) PVT. LTD. AND ANOTHER - APPELLANT
Versus
TIRUPATI ELECTRO MARKETING PVT. LTD. - RESPONDENT
Decided On : 23-12-2009
Important Points
Subject
Criminal Law - Negotiable Instruments Act
Act Referred
EVIDENCE ACT : S.43
INDIAN PENAL CODE : S.420
NEGOTIABLE INSTRUMENTS ACT : S.138, S.139
Headnote
N.I. Act - Criminal Proceeding - 138 - 139 - Summary: The court discussed the simultaneous continuance of civil and criminal proceedings, the presumption under Section 139 of the N.I. Act, and the burden of proof on the drawer of the cheque to discharge in the trial. The court emphasized that the mere filing of a civil suit after receipt of notice under Section 138 does not empower the petitioner to seek quashing or stay of the criminal complaint.
Fact of the Case:
The petitioner sought to quash the criminal proceeding under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act and requested a stay of further proceeding pending disposal of a civil suit.
Finding of the Court:
The court dismissed the application, stating that both civil and criminal proceedings can proceed simultaneously, and the filing of a civil suit after receipt of notice under Section 138 does not empower the petitioner to seek quashing or stay of the criminal complaint.
Issues: Quashing of criminal proceeding, stay of further proceeding, simultaneous continuance of civil and criminal proceedings
Ratio Decidendi: Simultaneous continuance of civil and criminal proceedings, presumption under Section 139 of the N.I. Act, burden of proof on the drawer of the cheque
Final Decision: The application was dismissed, and the court directed the lower court to proceed and dispose of the criminal case expeditiously.
JUDGMENT :
Indrajit Mahanty, J. - Indrajit Mahanty, J.-In the present application u/s 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, prayer has been made by the petitioner to quash the criminal proceeding in I.C.C. Case No. 847 of 2008 filed u/s 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act pending before the teamed S.D.J.M., Bhubaneswar and/or to direct stay of further proceeding till disposal of C.S. No. 91 of 2008 pending in the Court of learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), 1st Court, Cuttack.
2. Mr. Banshidhar Baug, learned Counsel for the petitioners submitted that the petitioners had issued a letter to the opp. party-claimant on 19.10.2007 requesting them to settle the accounts and the outstanding claims of the petitioners and claim that after adjustment of all outstanding claims of the petitioners with the opp. party, was entitled to get an amount of Rs. 28,293.70 from the petitioners. Based on such an assertion, the petitioner enclosed the Account Payee cheque for the self-same amount drawn on ICICI Bank, Cuttack and requested the opp. party-complainant to return back the blank cheque bearing No. 006033 of the State Bank of India, Cuttack City Branch which had been handed over to the opp. party-complainant in May 2007, as security. It is further alleged that the said letter was addressed to the complainant but the same was received by one of its employees, who used to go to the petitioners show-room at Cuttack either for giving delivery of materials or for collecting payments from the petitioners.
The petitioners further submission is that, although the opp. party-complainant received the said letter dated 19.10.2007, but did not give any reply thereto and instead, the complainant sent a letter dated 17.12.2007, claiming therein that of an amount Rs. 6,27,281/- was outstanding against the petitioners in terms of their book of accounts. It is further contended that in support of the petitioners reply to the complainant's letter dated 17.12.2007, petitioner No. 2 was threatened by the complainant-company that they would seek encashment of the blank cheque given by the petitioners as security. Based on such an apprehension the petitioners wrote to the Bank i.e. State Bank of India, Cuttack City Branch on 24.12.2007, requesting them to effect "stop payment" of cheque No. 006033, if presented for encashment. It is further stated on behalf of the petitioners that the opp. party-complainant filled up the said blank cheque given to it as security with an amount of Rs. 6,20,637/- and placed it for encashment which was dishonoured and returned on 27.12.2007 on "stop payment" as per instruction issued by the petitioners to its Bankers.
Learned Counsel for the petitioners further asserts that petitioner No. 1 at the relevant time i.e. on 24.12.2007 as well as on 27.12.2007 had sufficient funds in its account to honour the said cheque but since there was dispute regarding the quantum of entitlement of the opp. party-complainant, the petitioners had issued instructions to its Bankers to make stop payment.
3. From the pleadings, it further appears that, on the return of the cheque by the Bank on 27.12.2007, the opp. party-complainant on 8/10.1.2008 issued statutory notice, u/s 138, N.I. Act to the present petitioners followed up with a subsequent notice dated 15.1.2008. It is stated that the petitioners responded to the said notice under cover of its letter dated 31.1.2008.
4. In paragraph-19 of the petition, it is stated that after opp. party-complainant issued notice u/s 138, N.I. Act and after giving reply thereto by the petitioners on 31.1.2008, the petitioners filed C.S. No. 91 of 2008 in the Court of the Learned Civil Judge (Senior Division), 1st Court, Cuttack on 18.2.2008. The suit was filed with a prayer for settlement of accounts between the petitioner and opp. party-complainant and for a decree that the opp. party is only entitled to receive Rs. 28,294/- from the petitioners. The said suit remains pending as on date.
5. It is further stated th