SupremeToday Landscape Ad
Back
Next
Headnote Court Copy Facts Arguments Court observation Judicial Analysis Case Map Category Hierarchy Table of Content
Listen Article Pause Article
judgment-img

2019 Supreme(Ori) 508

IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA, CUTTACK
Dr. A.K.Rath, J.
Ramanand Sahu - Appellant
Versus
State Of Orissa & Anr. - Respondents
RSA No. 378 of 2003
Decided On : 28-06-2019

Important Points

The need for physical/actual, exclusive, open, uninterrupted, notorious, and hostile possession for adverse possession, and the inconsistency between claiming title and adverse possession.

Subject

Property Law - Adverse Possession

Act Referred

CIVIL PROCEDURE CODE : O.7 R.18(1)
CRIMINAL PROCEDURE CODE : S.145
ORISSA PREVENTION OF LAND ENCROACHMENT ACT : S.9
REGISTRATION ACT : S.17

Headnote

Adverse Possession - Suit for Declaration of Title - Orissa Prevention of Land Encroachment Act, 1971 - Section 9 - Order 7 Rule 18(1) CPC - Indian Registration Act - [SUIT FOR DECLARATION OF TITLE] - [Orissa Prevention of Land Encroachment Act, 1971 - Section 9, Order 7 Rule 18(1) CPC, Indian Registration Act] - The court discussed the admissibility of sale deeds, the requirement of compulsory registration, and the claim of adverse possession. It highlighted the need for physical/actual, exclusive, open, uninterrupted, notorious, and hostile possession for adverse possession, and the inconsistency between claiming title and adverse possession. The court found that the plaintiff failed to prove adverse possession and upheld the appellate court's decision.

Fact of the Case:

The plaintiff claimed ownership of suit lands under adverse possession, but the appellate court held the lands to be Government property. The plaintiff's claim was based on unregistered sale deeds and adverse possession.

Finding of the Court:

The court found that the plaintiff failed to prove adverse possession and upheld the appellate court's decision that the suit lands are Government property.

Issues: Admissibility of sale deeds, fabricated documents, jurisdiction of encroachment cases, and possession calculation.

Ratio Decidendi: The plaintiff failed to prove adverse possession as the possession was not physical/actual, exclusive, open, uninterrupted, notorious, and hostile to the true owner for the required period. Claiming title and adverse possession simultaneously is inconsistent.

Final Decision: The appeal was dismissed, and the court upheld the appellate court's decision that the suit lands are Government property.

Advocates Appeared:
Mr. P.C. Chhinchani, Advocate, for the Appellant; Mr. S. Mishra, ASC, for the Respondent
Cases Referred
Annasaheb Bapusaheb Patil vs. Balwant alias Balasaheb Babusaheb Patil dead By Lrs., (1995) 2 SCC 543
L.N. Aswathama vs. P. Prakash 2009 13 SCC 229
Mohan Lal deceased through his LRs. Kachru vs. Mirza Abdul Gaffer, (1996) 1 SCC 639

JUDGMENT

A.K.Rath, J. - This appeal at the instance of the plaintiff assails the reversing judgment of the learned Addl. District Judge, Gajapati, Parlakhemundi in Title Appeal No.18 of 1996 in a suit for declaration of title over Schedule-I to V immovable property, orders of eviction passed by the Tahasildar, R. Udayagir, defendant no.2, in L.E Case Nos.370/1991 and 531/1991 are illegal, permanent injunction and other consequential reliefs.

2. Case of the plaintiff was that he had purchased the suit property from different persons. He was the absolute owner in possession of the suit property. In the year 1974, the suit lands were recorded in the name of the Government. While matter stood thus, L.E. Case No.370 of 1991 was initiated against him under Section 9 of the Orissa Prevention of Land Encroachment Act, 1971 ('OPLE Act'). In Certificate Case No.10 of 1993, the plaintiff was served notice in L.E Case No.531 of 1991. When B.D.O., Nuagada tried to disturb his possession, he instituted the suit seeking the reliefs mentioned supra.

3. Pursuant to issuance of summons, defendants entered contest and filed a written statement denying the assertions made in the plaint. It was pleaded that the suit lands are Government lands. The area was not surveyed prior to 1971. The ROR was published in the year 1981. Schedule-I is recorded in the name of the Government. Since the plaintiff encroached upon Schedule-I land, he was evicted from the same. Schedule-II is the Patita land, which is recorded in the name of the Government. One Debaraj Panigrahi was in possession of the suit land. LE Case No.800 of 1989 was initiated against him. Subsequently the plaintiff was in possession of the said land. Encroachment proceeding was initiated against him. Schedule III and IV lands are recorded in the name of the Government under Anabadi khata. The plaintiff was in unauthorized occupation of Schedule III and IV lands for which an encroachment proceeding was initiated against him. He was evicted from the suit lands. In the year 1991, he again unlawfully occupied the suit lands. Therefore, another encroachment proceeding was initiated against him. Schedule-V land is Patita Anabadi land. The same is recorded in the name of the Government.

4. On the inter-se pleadings of the parties, learned trial court framed six issues. Parties led evidence, oral and documentary. Learned trial court decreed the suit holding that the plaintiff is in possession of the suit land since the date of purchase. Plaintiff's vendors were the true owners of the suit land. Plaintiff had purchased the suit land by means of unregistered sale deeds and acquired title by way of adverse possession. Felt aggrieved, defendants filed Title Appeal No.18 of 1996 before the learned Addl. District Judge, Gajapati, Parlakhemundi. Learned appellate court held that the suit lands are Government lands. The so-called vendors were not the owners of the suit land. Plaintiff is an encroacher of the Government land. He has not perfected title by way of adverse possession. Held so, it allowed the appeal.

5. The second appeal was admitted on the substantial questions of law enumerated in Ground Nos.A, B,E, F and G of the appeal memo. The same are -

"A) Whether the Mortgage Deed dated 23.2.1940 (Ext.1), Sale Deeds (Ext.5,7 and 11) are admissible in evidence under Order 7 Rule 18(1) CPC ?

B) In the absence of denial by the defendants in their W.S and advancing any plea that the Exts.5,7 and 11 are fabricated, whether the learned Appellate Court was correct in coming to conclusion that those documents are fabricated ?

E) Whether the Appellate Court was justified in not coming to a lawful conclusion that the orders passed by the Tahasildar in Land Encroachment cases against the appellant are nullity and void being without jurisdiction ?

F) Whether it being not the case of the parties that the sale deeds (Exts.5,7 and 11) are fabricated, it is open for the learned lower Appellate Court to make out a third ca

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
SupremeToday Portrait Ad
supreme today icon
whatsapp-icon Back to top