IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA, CUTTACK
B.R. Sarangi, J.
Sucharita Mohanty @ Mohapatra & Ors. - Appellants
Versus
State Of Odisha & Ors. - Respondents
W. P(C) No. 27367 of 2020
Decided On : 21-12-2021
Outsourcing - Regularization of Services - Motor Vehicle Act, 1988 - Sections 27, 64, 110 & 137 - Central Motor Vehicle Rules, 1989 - G.A. Department Resolution dated 17.09.2013
Fact of the Case:
The petitioners, Data Entry Operators/Computer Supervisors, sought regularization of their services in the Pay Band-1- 5200-20,200+GP Rs.1900/-, as per G.A. Department Resolution dated 17.09.2013. They were engaged by an outsourcing agency to implement e-Governance system in the Road Transport Sector.
Finding of the Court:
The petitioners, though engaged by outsourcing agency, were discharging duties for the Government and were entitled to the benefit of contractual appointment as per the resolution dated 17.09.2013. The Court emphasized the exploitation of outsourcing employees and directed the Government to extend the benefits to the petitioners within three months.
Issues: Regularization of services of outsourced Data Entry Operators, exploitation of outsourcing employees, applicability of G.A. Department Resolution dated 17.09.2013, and violation of Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
Ratio Decidendi: The petitioners, despite being paid through outsourcing agencies, were discharging duties for the Government and were entitled to the benefit of contractual appointment as per the resolution dated 17.09.2013. The Court emphasized the exploitation of outsourcing employees and directed the Government to extend the benefits to the petitioners within three months.
Final Decision: The writ petition was allowed, and the Government was directed to extend the benefits to the petitioners within three months.
JUDGMENT
Dr. B.R. Sarangi, J. - The petitioners, who are working as Data Entry Operators/Computer Supervisors in the establishment of opposite party no.2-State Transport Authority, have filed this writ petition seeking direction to the opposite parties to issue formal orders in their favour regularizing their services in the Pay Band-1- 5200-20,200+GP Rs.1900/-, as per G.A. Department Resolution dated 17.09.2013, on completion of satisfactory service as has been allowed to the similarly outsourced Data Entry Operators in various State Government Departments and other various Government Establishments with all consequential service and monetary benefits.
2. The factual matrix of the case, in brief, is that in order to introduce e-Governance system in the Road Transport Sector, Govt. of India in the Ministry of Road Transport & Highways, in exercise of their powers conferred under Sections 27, 64, 110 & 137 of the Motor Vehicle Act, 1988, amended the Central Motor Vehicle Rules, 1989 w.e.f. 31.05.2002, vide Ministry of Road Transport & Highways Notification No.GSR- 400(E) dated 31.05.2002 . The said Rules were called as the Central Motor Vehicle (Third Amendment) Rules, 2002. The said notification authorized both the State Government and Union Territories to specify their respective notification. Basing on the said notification of the Government of India, opposite party no.1 issued guidelines dated 10.08.2004 to implement the mandatory statutory provisions of Central Motor Vehicle (Third Amendment) Rules, 2002 by inviting private participation to carry out entire e-Governance system in the Road Transport Sector including various functions relating to issuance of Smart Card based driving license, registration certificates and other functions of the Transport Department in the State of Odisha. Thereafter, Govt. of Odisha-opposite party no.1 invited proposals from successful bidders vide NIT dated 15.09.2005 and finally accepted the bid of M/s. Smart Chip Limited, New Delhi-M/s Smart Chip (P) Ltd. by issuing letter of acceptance dated 01.05.2006 for implementation of the aforesaid project.
2.1. Opposite party no.1 made Registered Concession Agreement on 29.07.2006 with M/s. Smart Chip Ltd., New Delhi as the 'Concessionaire' for implementation of the specified services as defined in Schedule-II for a period of 15 years commencing from the date of agreement, i.e 29.07.2006. The tenure of the said agreement with M/s. Smart Chip Ltd. would come to an end during 2021. The agreement dated 29.07.2006 defines the term 'Govt. of Odisha Offices' to mean Regional Transport Office (RTO) and office of the Transport Commissioner, Odisha and further the 'Govt. of Odisha Receipts' has been defined to mean the moneys for issuance/renewal/amendment/ providing other services, including penalties and other incidental levies, in accordance with the Act in respect of fees for driving licence, fees for Learner Licence, fees for Registration Certificate, fees for Trade Certificate, fees for Fitness Certificate, Motor Vehicle Tax and Permit Fees.
2.2. Under Article-5 of the said agreement, the Govt. of Odisha-opposite party no.1 was to provide all reasonable assistance to the Concessionaire for procuring electrical and water connections. Under Article-6 of the agreement, the authority has been given to the Concessionaire for levying and collecting appropriate service charges from users for rendering special services in accordance with Schedule-IV of the agreement. Perusal of the agreement would reveal that the entire governmental work of the State of Odisha in respect of e-Governance of the Transport Department including Smart Card Based Driving License, Registration Certificates and other functions of the Department including collection of Govt. Fees and Receipts under the Act, as defined in the agreement, have been assigned to the said Concessionaire, namely, M/s. Smart Chip Ltd., New Delhi. On behalf of State of Odisha-opposite party no.1, the Principal Se
Login now and unlock free premium legal research
Login to SupremeToday AI and access free legal analysis, AI highlights, and smart tools.
Login
now!
India’s Legal research and Law Firm App, Download now!
Copyright © 2023 Vikas Info Solution Pvt Ltd. All Rights Reserved.