2009 Supreme(P&H) 484
PUNJAB & HARYANA HIGH COURT
Rakesh Kumar Jain, J.
Thuru Ram
Versus
State Of Punjab
RFA No. 4525 of 2001,
Decided On : MARCH 16, 2009
Headnote:(A) Land and Property Law--Acquistion of Land--Market value--Sale instances--Sale deeds duly proved by producing vendors and vendees--Rate per marla on an average comes to Rs.1718.75--Total acquired area is 47.77 acres--Keeping in view small size of sale deeds cut of 25% applied as a result value comes to be @ Rs.1289 per marla--Compensation enhanced accordingly--Land Acquisition Act, 1894, Sections 4, 6 & 8. (Para 16)
(B) Land and Property Law--Acquistion of Land--Compensation--Acquisition of land for construction of Hydel Channel--Acquisition of land of years 1990 and 1973--12% increase per year on value arrived at for acquisition of year 1990 @ Rs.1290 per marla would be appropriate--Claimants whose land was acquired in year 1993 should get additional sum of Rs. 4641/- per marla which come to Rs.1754 per marla--Compensation enhanced accordingly--Land Acquisition Act, 1894, Sections 4, 6 & 18. (Paras 18 & 19)
Rakesh Kumar Jain, J.
1. By this common judgment, 56 Regular First Appeals bearing Nos. 4304, 3527, 5091, 3529 to 3533, 3535 to 3540, 4258 to 4286, 4297, 4301 to 4303, 4305, 4525 to 4531 and 3528 of 2001 filed by claimants against the impugned award of the Additional District Judge, Gurdaspur dated 31.3.2001 are being disposed of together as identical question of law and facts are involved therein. However, the facts are being extracted from RFA No. 4525 of 2001 titled as Thuru Ram v. State of Punjab and others.
2. Vide notification issued under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (for short the Act) dated 12.1.1990, land measuring 23.83 acres in villages Jugial and Rajpura was acquired at the public expense, for public purpose, namely, for construction of Shahpur Kandi Hydel Channel from point A to A-l for the Shahpur Kandi Barrage Project. On the same date, another notification was issued under Section 4 of the Act and land measuring 23.94 acres of village Rajpura was acquired for construction of Shahpur Kandi Hydel Channel from point Al to A2 for the Shahpur Kandi Barrage Project. A follow up notification for both the acquisitions was issued under Section 6 of the Act on 28.2.1990. The Land Acquisition Collector (for short the Collector) vide his award dated 29.5.1991 pertaining to the acquisition of land measuring 23.83 acres, awarded the following rates :
Village Rajpura :
Nehri/Chahi Rs. 36,000/- per acre
Barani I Rs. 30,000/- per acre
Barani II Rs. 24,000/- per acre
Gair Mumkin/Rasta Rs.24,000/-per acre
Village Jugial :
Barani II Rs. 24.000/- per acre
In respect of acquisition of 23.94 acres of land, the Collector vide his award dated 26.9.1991 awarded the following rates for village Rajpura:
Nehri/Chahi
Rs. 36,000/- per acre
Barani I
Rs. 30,000/- per acre
Barani II
Rs. 24,000/- per acre
Gair Mumkin/Talab
Rs. 4000/- per acre
Gair Mumkin Abadi
Rs. 40,000/- per acre
Gair Mumkin Rasta
Rs. 24,000/- per acre
The land owners were not satisfied with the award of the Collector, therefore, they filed Objections under Section 18 of the Act and claimed Rs. 6,000/- per marla. On 27.3.1992, 19 references pertaining to the acquisition of the year 1990, were decided by the Additional District Judge, Gurdaspur and the market value was assessed @ Rs. 1,000/- per marla i.e. Rs. 1,60,000/- per acre after holding that the land was having potential value being adjoining to village Jugial Town which was having all the civic amenities. The State of Punjab challenged the said award of Additional District Judge, Gurdaspur dated 27.3.1992 by way of appeal in lead case bearing RFA No. 1927 of 1992 titled as Punjab State and others v. Thuru Ram.
3 The land owners in those appeals also filed Cross Objections. In the meantime, compensation that was awarded @ Rs. 1000/- per marla was paid to the land owners while the aforesaid appeals for the acquisition of the year 1990, were pending before the Reference Court. After remand, the State of Punjab issued another notification under Section 4 of the Act on 1.2.1993 and published it on 3.2.1993 to acquire 333.94 acres of land in villages Haroor, Barkula and Rajpura for the public purpose, namely, for construction of Shahpur Kandi Hydel Channel including Power House which was followed by a notification of declaration issued under Section 6 of the Act dated 17.9.1993. The Collector vide his award dated 21.12.1995 awarded the following compensation for the land of Villages Rajpura, Haroor and Barkula.
Village Rajpura
Chahi and Nehri Rs. 36,000/- per acre
Barani I Rs. 30,000/- per acre
Barani II Rs. 28,000/- per acre
Gair Mumkin Rs. 10,000/-per acre
Village Haroor
Barani I Rs. 30,000/-per acre
Barani II Rs. 28,000/- per acre
Bagicha I Rs. 32,000/- per acre
Bagicha II Rs. 30,000/- per acre
Gair Mumkin Rs. 10,000/- per acre
Gair Mumkin Abadi Rs. 30.000/- per acre
Village Barkula
Nehri Rs. 36,000/-per acre
Barani II Rs. 28,000/-per acre
Bagicha B II Rs. 3